What Hanifin are you guys watching? Brodie is closer to being a #1 D man than he is. Playing with Hamonic doesn't help him but I don't think he looked great with Andersson either.
I don't think I've ever seen a more average player get that much hype, I think you should go watch the actual future elite defenseman of this league if you think his guy is one of them. When comparing him to guys like Makar, Hughes, Werenski, Heiskanen, Provorov or Dahlin. He's well behind all of them despite them being drafted in the same range as him and all of them being younger or the same age.
I just don't see it he makes mistakes like Kylington/Brodie (not lately TJs been fire) do but rarely gets called out for them for some reason. Hamilton was a better player in his time here and got twice the shit that Noah gets.