Great NHL Coaches

Canadiens1958

Registered User
Nov 30, 2007
20,020
2,779
Lake Memphremagog, QC.
Listed alphabetically, not a ranking. Comments appreciated. Thank you.

Al Arbour
Played for a number of the great coaches on this list and managed to take the best qualities from each to guide a dynasty team after a learning stage.

Mike Babcock
Has managed to assimilate the various hockey philosophies while mastering in game strategies and making excellent use of all his players, coaching resources. Has improved the team everywhere he coached while improving as a coach at every step.

Toe Blake
Superior at evaluating talent and defining each player's role and contribution. Mastered in game strategy. Players coach. Managed to re-direct players negatives into positive on ice performances. Coached two dynasties while leaving a legacy upon retirement.

Scotty Bowman
True career coach after serious junior injury forced him to abandon hopes of a playing career. Great in game strategist one of the few who managed to adapt with the changing times in the NHL.

Hap Day
Master teacher and strategist. Great with young players and a great defensive strategist. Multiple Stanley Cups.

Tommy Gorman
Underrated. Excellent evaluator of talent. Won Stanley Cups in successive seasons with two different teams.

Cecil Hart
Won Stanley Cups with talented teams and overachieved with so-so teams.

Punch Imlach
Re-built a floundering Maple Leaf team into a Stanley Cup finalist in app 2/3 of a season then proceeded to win four Stanley Cups in 9 years with the same core. Then built an expansion team from scratch to a Stanley Cup finalist status within five years. Excellent at recognizing the talents and roles for each of his players.

Tommy Ivan
Excellent coach especially defining roles and responsibilities for young players. Coached the Red Wings dynasty from the start then went to Chicago and built the foundation for their rise from the basement.

Jacques Lemaire
Could coach any style but insisted on defensive responsibilty first. Always improved his players and teams.

Roger Neilson
Pioneered video as a coaching/teaching aide. Always managed to get his teams to play better than their talent level.

Ted Nolan
Managed to build teams that overachieved if given a key part. Had a knack for recognizing what a players specific assets were and put these assets to optimum us within a team concept.

Lester Patrick
One of the founders. Managed to adapt to various leagues, rule changes and produce quality teams.

Milt Schmidt
Always managed to make his teams better. His influences were seen in the Bobby Orr era Bruins.

Fred Shero
Players coach. Excellent strategist. Had the knack for recognizing each players talents and putting them in roles where they could contribute the most to team success.
 

Fish on The Sand

Untouchable
Feb 28, 2002
60,241
1,942
Canada
Lemaire, Nielson and Nolan clearly do not belong. Combined they have a total of 1 cup, and Nolan especially, ahs only coached 3 seasons in the NHL. As for Nielson, after his years of underachieving and failure in New York, the Rangers went on to win the cup a year after he was fired, and the Panthrs went to the Cup finals after 2 disappointing years under Roger Nielson in Florida. That should discredit the argument that he always made teams play better than they should. A better argument would be that he was never able to get the best out of his players.
 

Big Phil

Registered User
Nov 2, 2003
31,703
4,146
Geez I hate saying anything negative about Roger Neilson, but with him being in the HHOF in the builders wing it kind of trivializes it a bit. He was a good coach. And he probably got in based on his "Captain Video" reputation. But Pat Quinn, Mike Keenan and even Bryan Murray did just as much in their coaching careers.

Nolan can't hold an NHL job.

Lemaire was lucky enough to be coaching in the trap happy era back in 1995. He won one Cup, missed the playoffs the next year and won one playoff series with New Jersey until he got fired in '98. He ran Guy Lafleur out of town in Montreal in 1984 and he's played his teams the same regardless of the era or the talent that they possess. I mean think about it, he's with Minnesota for 9 years and even post lockout he doesnt get the hint that he should change his style? He does not belong on that list
 

TheDevilMadeMe

Registered User
Aug 28, 2006
52,271
6,981
Brooklyn
Geez I hate saying anything negative about Roger Neilson, but with him being in the HHOF in the builders wing it kind of trivializes it a bit. He was a good coach. And he probably got in based on his "Captain Video" reputation. But Pat Quinn, Mike Keenan and even Bryan Murray did just as much in their coaching careers.

Nolan can't hold an NHL job.

Lemaire was lucky enough to be coaching in the trap happy era back in 1995. He won one Cup, missed the playoffs the next year and won one playoff series with New Jersey until he got fired in '98. He ran Guy Lafleur out of town in Montreal in 1984 and he's played his teams the same regardless of the era or the talent that they possess. I mean think about it, he's with Minnesota for 9 years and even post lockout he doesnt get the hint that he should change his style? He does not belong on that list

Like it or not, Lemaire is one of the most influential coaches of modern times. You say he was "lucky enough to be coaching in the trap happy era," but he's the one who showed how successful you could be using a defensive system, spawning copycats the next year, including the expansion Florida Panthers. The rest is history.

I agree that Ted Nolan should in no way be on the list.

If you want more modern coaches, I'd suggest Pat Burns - the only three times Jack Adams winner, a guy who demanded the most from his players, overachieved quite a few times with clubs that were weak on paper, and finally won the Stanley Cup on a Devils team full of players past their prime and grinders. Multiple players (Tie Domi among them) said he was the best coach they ever had.
 

Canadiens1958

Registered User
Nov 30, 2007
20,020
2,779
Lake Memphremagog, QC.
Jacques Lemaire

Geez I hate saying anything negative about Roger Neilson, but with him being in the HHOF in the builders wing it kind of trivializes it a bit. He was a good coach. And he probably got in based on his "Captain Video" reputation. But Pat Quinn, Mike Keenan and even Bryan Murray did just as much in their coaching careers.

Nolan can't hold an NHL job.

Lemaire was lucky enough to be coaching in the trap happy era back in 1995. He won one Cup, missed the playoffs the next year and won one playoff series with New Jersey until he got fired in '98. He ran Guy Lafleur out of town in Montreal in 1984 and he's played his teams the same regardless of the era or the talent that they possess. I mean think about it, he's with Minnesota for 9 years and even post lockout he doesnt get the hint that he should change his style? He does not belong on that list

Jacques Lemaire started coaching in 1979 after leaving the Canadiens as a player with stops in Europe, US college and junior hockey. Took an expansion QMJHL team - Longueuil to the league finals teaching a bunch of rejects to score along the way. Coached the Canadiens and prepared the team for Jean Perron while turning Chris Nilan into a twenty goal scorer. When Perron lost the team - near the end of the season he helped Perron get back control and a rookie laden team won a Stanley Cup.

Laid the coaching foundation in New Jersey - that is why he was hired back. Took Minnesota an expansion team to playoff contention and participation including a few upsets with less talent then most teams out west. Actually had Alexandre Daigle playing hockey for a while.
 

Canadiens1958

Registered User
Nov 30, 2007
20,020
2,779
Lake Memphremagog, QC.
Pat Burns

Like it or not, Lemaire is one of the most influential coaches of modern times. You say he was "lucky enough to be coaching in the trap happy era," but he's the one who showed how successful you could be using a defensive system, spawning copycats the next year, including the expansion Florida Panthers. The rest is history.

I agree that Ted Nolan should in no way be on the list.

If you want more modern coaches, I'd suggest Pat Burns - the only three times Jack Adams winner, a guy who demanded the most from his players, overachieved quite a few times with clubs that were weak on paper, and finally won the Stanley Cup on a Devils team full of players past their prime and grinders. Multiple players (Tie Domi among them) said he was the best coach they ever had.

Thought about Pat Burns but he is basically a one dimensional coach. The four coaches he replaced - Jean Perron in Montreal, Tom Watt in Toronto, Steve Kasper in Boston and Kevin Constantine in NJ had lost the team. Pat Burns a former police officer, took over instilled discipline and improved the team BUT then he slowly started losing the team and was let go. He finally won the Stanley Cup in New Jersey. After taking the Canadiens to the Stanley Cup finals his first year performance dropped. This trend repeated at every stop in his career. Not a good sign.
 

Ward Cornell

Registered User
Dec 22, 2007
6,398
2,624
I can understand why Tarasov is on the list but you gotta admit he did have a few advantages over his competition.

Total dictatorship (in more ways than one) over his players.
Pick of the litter for players in the USSR.
Real lack of competition from soon to be emerging countries.
 

pnep

Registered User
Mar 10, 2004
2,950
1,328
Novosibirsk,Russia
Coach|FIRST SEASON|LAST SEASON|Seasons|Adj Reg Season WINS
BOWMAN, Scotty|1967-68|2001-02|30|1294
IRVIN, Dick|1928-29|1955-56|27|1036
ARBOUR, Alger Joseph|1970-71|2007-08|23|799
ADAMS, John James "Jack"|1927-28|1946-47|20|702
ROSS, Arthur Howie|1917-18|1944-45|18|669
KEENAN, Michael|1984-85|2008-09|20|659
QUINN, Patrick John Brian|1978-79|2005-06|19|659
MURRAY, Bryan Clarence|1981-82|2007-08|17|625
REAY, William Tulip|1957-58|1976-77|16|593
BLAKE, Hector "Toe"|1955-56|1967-68|13|583
WILSON, Ronald Lawrence|1993-94|2008-09|15|548
LEMAIRE, Jacques Gerard|1983-84|2008-09|15|533
BURNS, Patrick|1988-89|2003-04|14|518
MARTIN, Jacques|1986-87|2007-08|14|508
SATHER, Glen Cameron|1979-80|2003-04|13|508
PATRICK, Lester Curtis|1926-27|1938-39|13|496
HITCHCOCK, Kenneth|1995-96|2008-09|13|494
NEILSON, Roger Paul|1977-78|2001-02|16|480
CRAWFORD, Marc|1994-95|2007-08|13|478
SUTTER, Brian Louis Allen|1988-89|2003-04|13|472
QUENNEVILLE, Joel Norman|1996-97|2008-09|12|464
IMLACH, George "Punch"|1958-59|1979-80|14|461
ABEL, Sidney Gerald|1952-53|1975-76|16|442
DEMERS, Jacques Jean|1979-80|1998-99|14|426
SUTTER, Darryl John|1992-93|2005-06|11|422
FRANCIS, Emile Percy|1965-66|1982-83|13|415
RUFF, Lindy Cameron|1997-98|2008-09|11|411
MURRAY, Terry Rodney|1989-90|2008-09|12|410
SHERO, Frederick Alexander|1971-72|1980-81|10|403
 

Canadiens1958

Registered User
Nov 30, 2007
20,020
2,779
Lake Memphremagog, QC.
Upsets

No Billy Reay? Anatoli Tarasov? Art Ross? Emile Francis?

Tarasov not NHL.

Francis, Reay, Ross history of having superior teams yet being upset.
Ross = six 1st place finishes with perhaps the player of the decade Shore (thirties), one Stanley Cup being the prime example.
 
Last edited:

Canadiens1958

Registered User
Nov 30, 2007
20,020
2,779
Lake Memphremagog, QC.
Nice List

Coach|FIRST SEASON|LAST SEASON|Seasons|Adj Reg Season WINS
BOWMAN, Scotty|1967-68|2001-02|30|1294
IRVIN, Dick|1928-29|1955-56|27|1036
ARBOUR, Alger Joseph|1970-71|2007-08|23|799
ADAMS, John James "Jack"|1927-28|1946-47|20|702
ROSS, Arthur Howie|1917-18|1944-45|18|669
KEENAN, Michael|1984-85|2008-09|20|659
QUINN, Patrick John Brian|1978-79|2005-06|19|659
MURRAY, Bryan Clarence|1981-82|2007-08|17|625
REAY, William Tulip|1957-58|1976-77|16|593
BLAKE, Hector "Toe"|1955-56|1967-68|13|583
WILSON, Ronald Lawrence|1993-94|2008-09|15|548
LEMAIRE, Jacques Gerard|1983-84|2008-09|15|533
BURNS, Patrick|1988-89|2003-04|14|518
MARTIN, Jacques|1986-87|2007-08|14|508
SATHER, Glen Cameron|1979-80|2003-04|13|508
PATRICK, Lester Curtis|1926-27|1938-39|13|496
HITCHCOCK, Kenneth|1995-96|2008-09|13|494
NEILSON, Roger Paul|1977-78|2001-02|16|480
CRAWFORD, Marc|1994-95|2007-08|13|478
SUTTER, Brian Louis Allen|1988-89|2003-04|13|472
QUENNEVILLE, Joel Norman|1996-97|2008-09|12|464
IMLACH, George "Punch"|1958-59|1979-80|14|461
ABEL, Sidney Gerald|1952-53|1975-76|16|442
DEMERS, Jacques Jean|1979-80|1998-99|14|426
SUTTER, Darryl John|1992-93|2005-06|11|422
FRANCIS, Emile Percy|1965-66|1982-83|13|415
RUFF, Lindy Cameron|1997-98|2008-09|11|411
MURRAY, Terry Rodney|1989-90|2008-09|12|410
SHERO, Frederick Alexander|1971-72|1980-81|10|403

PNEP,

Nice list but I noticed the adjusted wins. Trust you have an adjusted losses index that balances against the adjusted wins?
 
Last edited:

pnep

Registered User
Mar 10, 2004
2,950
1,328
Novosibirsk,Russia
Coach|FIRST SEASON|LAST SEASON|Seasons|Adj Reg Season Loses
IRVIN, Dick|1928-29|1955-56|27|780
ADAMS, John James "Jack"|1927-28|1946-47|20|665
BOWMAN, Scotty|1967-68|2001-02|30|595
ARBOUR, Alger Joseph|1970-71|2007-08|23|590
ROSS, Arthur Howie|1917-18|1944-45|18|589
KEENAN, Michael|1984-85|2008-09|20|547
ABEL, Sidney Gerald|1952-53|1975-76|16|495
DEMERS, Jacques Jean|1979-80|1998-99|14|489
QUINN, Patrick John Brian|1978-79|2005-06|19|485
WILSON, Ronald Lawrence|1993-94|2008-09|15|479
MURRAY, Bryan Clarence|1981-82|2007-08|17|472
SCHMIDT, Milton Conrad|1954-55|1975-76|13|457
SUTTER, Brian Louis Allen|1988-89|2003-04|13|432
LEMAIRE, Jacques Gerard|1983-84|2008-09|15|427
REAY, William Tulip|1957-58|1976-77|16|423
MARTIN, Jacques|1986-87|2007-08|14|408
BOUCHER, Frank|1939-40|1953-54|11|406
NEILSON, Roger Paul|1977-78|2001-02|16|399
LALONDE, Newsy|1917-18|1934-35|11|383
IMLACH, George "Punch"|1958-59|1979-80|14|382
PATRICK, Lester Curtis|1926-27|1938-39|13|381
GERARD, Edward George|1917-18|1934-35|11|381
MAURICE, Paul|1995-96|2008-09|12|376
CRAWFORD, Marc|1994-95|2007-08|13|370
BURNS, Patrick|1988-89|2003-04|14|368
BERRY, Robert Victor|1978-79|1993-94|11|361
BERGERON, Michel|1980-81|1989-90|10|359
KELLY, Leonard Patrick "Red"|1967-68|1976-77|10|348
TROTZ, Barry|1998-99|2008-09|10|342



Coach|FIRST SEASON|LAST SEASON|Seasons|Adj Reg Season W-L DIF
BOWMAN, Scotty|1967-68|2001-02|30|700
BLAKE, Hector "Toe"|1955-56|1967-68|13|286
IRVIN, Dick|1928-29|1955-56|27|257
ARBOUR, Alger Joseph|1970-71|2007-08|23|209
SATHER, Glen Cameron|1979-80|2003-04|13|195
QUINN, Patrick John Brian|1978-79|2005-06|19|174
HITCHCOCK, Kenneth|1995-96|2008-09|13|171
REAY, William Tulip|1957-58|1976-77|16|170
SHERO, Frederick Alexander|1971-72|1980-81|10|170
QUENNEVILLE, Joel Norman|1996-97|2008-09|12|159
MURRAY, Bryan Clarence|1981-82|2007-08|17|153
BURNS, Patrick|1988-89|2003-04|14|150
GREEN, Peter|1919-20|1924-25|6|140
IVAN, Thomas Nathaniel|1947-48|1957-58|9|139
HART, Cecil M.|1926-27|1938-39|9|132
BABCOCK, Mike|2002-03|2008-09|6|126
FRANCIS, Emile Percy|1965-66|1982-83|13|121
PATRICK, Lester Curtis|1926-27|1938-39|13|115
KEENAN, Michael|1984-85|2008-09|20|112
CRAWFORD, Marc|1994-95|2007-08|13|108
LEMAIRE, Jacques Gerard|1983-84|2008-09|15|106
JOHNSON, Thomas Christian|1970-71|1972-73|3|104
MARTIN, Jacques|1986-87|2007-08|14|100
||||
SMEETON, J. Cooper|1930-31|1930-31|1|-60
HOLMGREN, Paul Howard|1988-89|1995-96|8|-61
GOTTSELIG, John Peter|1944-45|1947-48|4|-62
DEMERS, Jacques Jean|1979-80|1998-99|14|-63
NEALE, Harold Watson|1978-79|1985-86|7|-64
EVANS, John William "Jack"|1975-76|1987-88|8|-68
LAYCOE, Hal|1969-70|1971-72|3|-69
STASIUK, Victor John|1969-70|1972-73|4|-69
GOODFELLOW, Ebbie|1950-51|1951-52|2|-71
MacMILLAN, William Stewart|1980-81|1983-84|3|-73
THOMPSON, Percy|1920-21|1921-22|2|-75
CARPENTER, Douglas|1984-85|1990-91|6|-76
WATT, Thomas|1981-82|1991-92|7|-78
KINGSTON, George|1991-92|1992-93|2|-101
SULLIVAN, George "Red"|1962-63|1974-75|7|-102
FRASER, Curtis Martin|1999-00|2002-03|4|-105
BOUCHER, Frank|1939-40|1953-54|11|-124
DUTTON, Mervyn "Red"|1935-36|1941-42|7|-126
McVIE, Thomas Ballentine|1975-76|1991-92|8|-140
GLOVER, Frederick Austin|1968-69|1973-74|6|-143
SCHMIDT, Milton Conrad|1954-55|1975-76|13|-164
BOWNESS, Rick|1988-89|2003-04|9|-181
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad