Gaudreau, Monahan, Tkachuk, Bennett, and Hamilton vs. Matthews, Marner, Nylander, Brown, and Rielly

[Wayne Primeau]

Which quintet do you take going forward?

Click to read more...

 

[Painful Quandary]

Flames now, but Leafs going forward.

 

[CantLoseWithMatthews]

This is the Leafs. Also it's really funny that 4th overall Bennett is being compared to 156th overall Connor Brown

 

[IPS]

Leafs group 1000x over. Especially once everyone sees how badly Gaudreau regresses this year.

 

[GlitchMarner]

Roughly...

Matthews > Gaudreau
Marner > Monahan
Nylander = Tkachuk
Bennett > Brown
Hamilton > Rielly

I'd take Toronto's group. I'm giving Bennett the benefit of the doubt in assuming he'll be better than Brown, but I would need to see him do better than he has before considering taking the Calgary players.

 

[Bando]

Roughly...

Matthews > Gaudreau
Marner > Monahan
Nylander = Tkachuk
Bennett > Brown
Hamilton > Rielly

I'd take Toronto's group. I'm giving Bennett the benefit of the doubt in assuming he'll be better than Brown, but I would need to see him do better than he has before considering taking the Calgary players.

right now and debateable for the future
Gaudreau > mathews
Monahan >/= marner

 

[jetsforever]

Toronto because of Matthews

 

[Ainec]

Leafs

 

[Bando]

Leafs group 1000x over. Especially once everyone sees how badly Gaudreau regresses this year.

You literally post the same thing in EVERY poll that involves a leaf player. At least be a little original...

Everyone on the leafs is going to regress to 0 points! dur dur dur

 

[Haatley]

Matthews>Monahan
Gaudreau>>Marner
Tkachuk>>Nylander
Bennett>Brown
Hamilton>>>>Rielly

Easy.

 

[IPS]

Matthews>Monahan
Gaudreau>>Marner
Tkachuk>>Nylander
Bennett>Brown
Hamilton>>>>Rielly

Easy.

Holy f*** Haatley gave us one!

 

[Haatley]

Holy **** Haatley gave us one!

This is only until Gaudreau regresses to AHL 3rd line, right? By then Marner will be 120 point player.

 

[flamesforcup]

This is the Leafs. Also it's really funny that 4th overall Bennett is being compared to 156th overall Connor Brown

Funny how 104th overall Gaudreau is better than 1st overall Matthews and 4th overall Marner

 

[Weast]

Gaudreau<Matthews
Monahan<Marner
Tkachuk>Nylander
Bennett=Brown
Hamilton<Rielly

 

[Rhaegar Targaryen]

Matthews >> Monahan
Gaudreau >> Marner
Tkachuk > Nylander
Bennett >> Brown
Hamilton > Rielly

 

[CantLoseWithMatthews]

Funny how 104th overall Gaudreau is better than 1st overall Matthews and 4th overall Marner

Funny how you don't realize that getting a ~70 point player 4th overall is better than getting a ~25 point player at 4th overall, and that's why this doesn't really work. Also Matthews is better and will be going forward

 

[Bando]

Funny how you don't realize that getting a ~70 point player 4th overall is better than getting a ~25 point player at 4th overall, and that's why this doesn't really work. Also Matthews is better and will be going forward

Funny how you didn't read what he wrote. He never mentioned bennet. Gaudreau is better now and going forward.

 

[VoluntaryDom]

Matthews>Gaudreau
Marner>Monahan
Nylander>Tkachuk
Brown<Bennett
Rielly>Hamilton

Leafs pretty easily

 

[rent free]

Gaudreau < Matthews
Monahan < marner
Tkachuk > nylander
Bennett > brown
Hamilton > Reilly

 

[Spirit of 67]

Leafs.

 

[Tkachuky]

Leafs group 1000x over. Especially once everyone sees how badly Gaudreau regresses this year.

Werent the holy trinity all supposed to outscore him this year?

 

[tacogeoff]

Tough poll. I think I would have to go with Toronto though. Matthews and Marner just puts them over the top. Also in the back of my mind it makes sense to pick Toronto moving forward as they have a goalie.

Gaudreau<Matthews
Monahan<Marner
Tkachuk = Nylander
Bennett>Brown
Hamilton>Rielly

 

[Dump Itch]

Matthews> Calgary

Therefore Leafs lol.

 

[CantLoseWithMatthews]

Funny how you didn't read what he wrote. He never mentioned bennet. Gaudreau is better now and going forward.

Funny how you clearly didn't follow the conversation

 

[Ryan Michaels]

This is some top notch discourse, keep up the good work guys.