Wait are we not calling for Rutherford's head anymore?
Well when you look at this team in back before the Sprong for Pettersson deal in tbe middle of the 2018-19 season and look at it now Rutherford has done an amazing job. I will bold all the new players Rutherford added to surround the core with a younger, faster, and more skilled group in just 2 years time.
Guentzel-Crosby-
Kapanen
Zucker-Malkin-Rust
McCann-Jankowski-Tanev
Rodriguez-Blueger-
Scevior
Dumoulin-Letang
Pettersson-Marino
Riikola/Matheson-Ceci/Ruhwedel
Of course Blueger is new to the team also but he was in the system already and the bolded are adds from Rutherford.
Two forwards fast and in primes added to the top 6. Some complain about the price but all use 1st round picks and prospects for players like that with term and in primes any day. I hated doing it for rentals and or aging veterans like Shero did many times. You go all in for that season and then have nothing left for your picks and prospects. Getting your young 2nd pairing in Pettersson and Marino for Sprong and a 6th! If we drafted two defenseman in the 1st round I would be happy if they developed into those two. It doesn't matter if you draft your prospects and develop them or trade for developed ones as long as you add youth to the lineup.
Bottom line is Rutherford has done a nice job adding tons of players that are young and in primes with speed and skill. If this team doesn't do well it won't be Rutherford's fault but the core. So far this season it is our core letting the team down. Rutherford might not of done perfect during this transition but I like how Rutherford improved this team and also traded for POJ and getting O'Connor, Lee, and Maniscalco for free to help add to the prospect pool. So while our prospect pool might not be up to some other teams that is because we used those assets for Zucker, Kapanen, McCann, Marino, and Pettersson that we can use now. Smart move because many 1st round picks and prospects will never turn out near as good as these players. Many more Sprongs, Boe Bennett, and Poulin's than players equal to a Zucker, Kapanen, Marino, or even a McCann.
The thing that jumps out to me most with those bolded players are that all the best moves improved the top 6, 3rd line, and 2nd pairing defense pairing which are the most important spots compared to his not so good moves that are either 4th liner or 3rd pairing or backup defenseman.