Tripod
I hate this team
No...TK is not a 50 point player yet. He should break that barrier this year.No, it's not dumb.
1) Is TK a 50 point player? We're not talking projecting late round picks, we're talking Lindblom (top forward in SHL at age 20), Farabee #14, Ratcliffe #35 (Ron liked him so much he traded up), Rubtsov #22, Laughton #20 who may have limitations at center but has potential at LW. Not all of them will pan out, but a couple should. And that's the key, there is safety in numbers, we have so many numbers we're bound to hit the "hockey lottery."
2) Skinner has been solid, last three years (23-25), 2.03 pp/60, Corsi 52.42, CorsiRel -0.09, xGF 52.12, xGFrel +1.03, but he's not an elite winger.
He's averaged 14 minutes 5x5 in Carolina, but only 3.82 pp/60 on the PP, so in Philly he'd be a 12 minute 5x5%, PP2 player (or 14-15 minutes a night total).
Not because he's a bad player, but he's not beating out Giroux and JVR. And one of those four guys will provide similar production at a fraction of the cost on the 3rd line. Because here Skinner is a 30-35 ES wing with 5-10 on the PP, or 35-45 points, not 50+. How many points would say Laughton give you as Frost's LW? Or Lindblom?
That's really the issue going forward, with the depth Ron has built, either a FA has to be elite (and worthy of moving a big salary to make room for him), or at a position of need - but going forward, what position of need will we probably (because crap happens) have?
2nd of all, you never listed Lindblom in your post. You said: "Don't want Skinner at all, I don't think in two years he'll be able to beat out Ratcliffe/Farabee/Rubtsov/Laughton at LW."
Only Laughton will be in the NHL from that group this year. Then in year 2, will be NHL rookies. Will they be 50 point 3rd liners in their 2nd year...not likely considering TK wasn't and spent half the year on the top line.
Then for Skinner, you are under valuing him. He has put up 60+ point seasons before. The 50 points is almost the floor, yet you are saying he would get even less. With his shot, he easily bumps out Couts as well on the PP.
And as I said before, we have no need for Skinner once we added JVR. But that does not mean these kids will be better than him in 2 years. That's just dumb to say and underselling a 26 year old with multiple 30 goal seasons.
Side note....I love you mentioning TK considering you spent all last season saying he is not a top 6 player yet because he can't lead his own line. Something Skinner has done for years.