Okay, I lied. I ended up coming home a bit early and got busy spending time with my wife and playing too much Pokemon Go. Apologies for the delay.
Before I start posting the results, here's an explanation:
The Denominator Index (DI) is the primary score. It gives each mock pick a valuation relative to the actual draft. The more accurate you are, the better your DI. It also punishes mock-GMs for picking players that the NHL GMs didn't care to draft with negative points. I have ranked the teams according to their DI score.
The Pick Corsi (PC) is a secondary statistic, which shows how well mock-GMs did at picking players that the real GMs valued highly. It assumes that the real GMs and scouts know more about hockey than the mock GMs and that they are more likely to be correct. A positive PC means you were finding gems later, while a negative PC score means you were reaching for duds earlier.
Obviously, these two scores are often out of alignment - if you have a high PC score you cannot have a high DI score. So don't look at the two numbers together, they measure different things.
We also, as a whole, have low PC scores because we drafted many, many players that the real GMs didn't. Picking an undrafted player comes with a big negative PC, while it was much more rare/difficult to find that player with a big positive PC (Lauzon, Lindstrom, Norris, etc).
The coloured cells have some meaning - I coloured the scores green to draw your eye to the important information. Green cells on the number mean an exact pick, black cells mean an undrafted pick. Red cells on the name mean an auto-pick. I am not sure what to do with these, other than to note them. [edit: forgot to add this before posting images]
I am posting team by team to force everyone to read every chart. I know if I block posted all 31, we'd all just scroll to what we want to see (our team). Plus, suspense and all that.
