Proposal: Florida-Carolina-Winnipeg

[Deam78]

He was barely mentioned in the top 5 centers thread. that's all you need to know.

Him and Scheifele are definitely two of the most valuable assets out there.

 

[Jared Dunn]

He was barely mentioned in the top 5 centers thread. that's all you need to know.

To be fair to OP Slavin gets that treatment to a lesser extent as well, but Barkov is a borderline top 10 player right now at 22. Florida should have three fairly solid lines this year so it'll be intriguing to see if this is the year he truly goes off

 

[Jared Dunn]

Him and Scheifele are definitely two of the most valuable assets out there.

Mackinnon too, all three on absolute sweetheart contracts

 

[LordZapp]

Barkov is better than every player in this deal.

 

[Howboutthempanthers]

Why the hell is Barkov in all of these proposals lately? I guess it's a summer time thing, but anyway....

Barkov is not going anywhere. Stop wasting your time.

 

[Laus723]

Maybe try to simply this and remove Winnipeg from the proposal as they don't sound interested.

Florida won't trade Barkov but if Staal is going back you wonder if they might trade Trocheck b/c Staal can take all the defensive matchups giving Barkov more Ozone starts and easier minutes. Obviously you'd have to add a big piece to Staal for the offensive downgrade they'd be taking at 2C so one of the Canes top Dmen. But then the Panthers are probably over cap so I don't see how you'd make it work and it would take a big overpayment.

Something like Staal 3m retained, Pesce 1m retained, + Fleury for Trocheck. But I don't think that deal happens from either side.

Decent package, but Trocheck is very good defensively and can be a heart and soul guy. No reason to move him for a package and then try to figure where everyone fits in.

Barkov and Tro are Panthers for a LOOONG time. And it’s aweosme.

 

[Jeti]

Really bad for Florida and Winnipeg. Carolina is the only one that benefits

 

[JetsHomer]

Guy says 2 years of Trouba > 7 years of Slavin
Guy then accuses other party massively overrating his own player

That irony is thicky thick as cornbread

Where did I say this? 7 years of Trouba > 7 years of Slavin.

Or did I miss where Trouba signed a 2 year contract?

 

[Flyerfan52]

Best off leaving Florida out.
To Carolina Trouba, Kulikov (if Carolina isn't on his 6 team no trade list) & Roslovic
To Winnipeg Slavin, McKeon & Canes 2019 2nd rounder

Slavin is a good LD but Trouba is a better RD & RD is the more valued position. Canes also get Kulikov to fill their RD/LD pairings.
McKeon is a decent RD prospect with 1 year left on his ELC while Roslovic is a C used as a W last year that already has 32 NHL games under his belt & has 2 years left of his ELC & the Canes need centers.
Hence the 2nd from the Canes.

This, of course, means the Jets need to re-sign Myers which eats more that the cap saved should Trouba come in @ even 6 but Kukikov gives that wiggle room.
Jets D ends up weaker as it leaves Morrissey without that shudown partner. Not great but I could live with it.

 

[LakeLivin]

Best off leaving Florida out.
To Carolina Trouba, Kulikov (if Carolina isn't on his 6 team no trade list) & Roslovic
To Winnipeg Slavin, McKeon & Canes 2019 2nd rounder

Slavin is a good LD but Trouba is a better RD & RD is the more valued position. Canes also get Kulikov to fill their RD/LD pairings.
McKeon is a decent RD prospect with 1 year left on his ELC while Roslovic is a C used as a W last year that already has 32 NHL games under his belt & has 2 years left of his ELC & the Canes need centers.
Hence the 2nd from the Canes.

This, of course, means the Jets need to re-sign Myers which eats more that the cap saved should Trouba come in @ even 6 but Kukikov gives that wiggle room.
Jets D ends up weaker as it leaves Morrissey without that shudown partner. Not great but I could live with it.

Canes already have Hamilton, Pesce, Faulk, and TVR on the right side. Why would they create a big hole on the left side in order to bring in a RD they don't need?

 

[Starat327]

Best off leaving Florida out.
To Carolina Trouba, Kulikov (if Carolina isn't on his 6 team no trade list) & Roslovic
To Winnipeg Slavin, McKeon & Canes 2019 2nd rounder

Slavin is a good LD but Trouba is a better RD & RD is the more valued position. Canes also get Kulikov to fill their RD/LD pairings.
McKeon is a decent RD prospect with 1 year left on his ELC while Roslovic is a C used as a W last year that already has 32 NHL games under his belt & has 2 years left of his ELC & the Canes need centers.
Hence the 2nd from the Canes.

This, of course, means the Jets need to re-sign Myers which eats more that the cap saved should Trouba come in @ even 6 but Kukikov gives that wiggle room.
Jets D ends up weaker as it leaves Morrissey without that shudown partner. Not great but I could live with it.

Arent the Canes already trying to dump a RD? Why are they interested in adding another?

 

[untouchable21]

Even if you believed Trouba was better than Slavin comparing 1D to 1D, Slavin is signed for $5.3 million x 7 years. Trouba is about to get more than that for 1-2 years and hit UFA. Their value isn’t close.

I wouldn’t be so sure he gets more than that. If he were signing a longer term deal then maybe, but doubtful on a 1 year.

 

[Stickpucker]

Decent package, but Trocheck is very good defensively and can be a heart and soul guy. No reason to move him for a package and then try to figure where everyone fits in.

Barkov and Tro are Panthers for a LOOONG time. And it’s aweosme.

Agreed Florida should enjoy that duo for a long time and try to build around them.

 

[Breaking Dadonov]

How come every proposal involving the panthers has them getting completely ***raped? Barkov is not going anywhere so just stop this madness.

 

[BB88]

Maybe try to simply this and remove Winnipeg from the proposal as they don't sound interested.

Florida won't trade Barkov but if Staal is going back you wonder if they might trade Trocheck b/c Staal can take all the defensive matchups giving Barkov more Ozone starts and easier minutes. Obviously you'd have to add a big piece to Staal for the offensive downgrade they'd be taking at 2C so one of the Canes top Dmen. But then the Panthers are probably over cap so I don't see how you'd make it work and it would take a big overpayment.

Something like Staal 3m retained, Pesce 1m retained, + Fleury for Trocheck. But I don't think that deal happens from either side.

Some Florida fans have the feeling that Trocheck will be the next C in Florida, and he's on a damm good contract.

 

[ConnorMcNugesaitl]

It’s definitely not bad for the Jets. I think basically anyone besides yourself could agree with that.
You should appreciate I tried to give the jets good value for their guy even though I think the majority of the fan base overrates his value big time.

But yes, more value should have gone to Florida

I'm not a Jets Homer and I think it's pretty bad for Winnipeg.

Interesting that you're claiming your opinion is definitely right and everyone would agree with you.

 

[CantLoseWithMatthews]

If I was a Panthers fan and the main piece coming back for Barkov was Trouba, I'd find a new team to cheer for. Pretty awful

 

[Pragmatic Panther]

I actually laughed out loud at this proposal.

 

[StatisticsAddict99]

Winnipeg and Florida get beefed(I couldn’t think of a proper term that would suffice for how bad thi trade is) in this trade.

 

[Panthers94]

At the very least give the panthers some lube, jesus..

 

[Laus723]

I actually laughed out loud at this proposal.

He goes into so much detail in the OP, too. Lol

 

[SaskCanesFan]

Bad for Florida, there's just no way they trade Barkov.

How exactly is Trouba much better than Slavin?

 

[DudeWhereIsMakar]

Close this disgusting thread...

 

[MinJaBen]

No way Florida trades Barkov. Love to have him, but no way we’d be able to get him realistically.

 

[Negan4Coach]

Slavin goes nowhere do you understand nowhere