Value of: Faulk to Edmonton

[MasterMatt25]

With Sekera out long term, Edmonton is in need of defense. Faulk will be able to quaterback the powerplay and generate some offense from the blueline and fill in for Sekera.

What would be a good/fair proposal here?

Click to read more...

 

[super6646]

Rnh lol

 

[Chan790]

Faulk was given an A yesterday. Also, Pesce is out with "a lung issue" indefinitely.

At this point, Faulk is probably not being moved unless someone offers something better than market value, involving a substantial asset.

 

[bluedevil58]

RNH would be the answer. Although if Larson can return a Hall then they night have to add in order to make this a fair trade from Carolina's perapective.

 

[NotOpie]

Faulk was given an A yesterday. Also, Pesce is out with "a lung issue" indefinitely.

Pretty certain Pesce was a full participant during the 1st 2 days of camp.

 

[Mr Positive]

Faulk was given an A yesterday. Also, Pesce is out with "a lung issue" indefinitely.

At this point, Faulk is probably not being moved unless someone offers something better than market value, involving a substantial asset.

I don't think him getting a letter is an indicator that he isn't for sale. They wanted to go into camp with the players' letters in place, and even if Faulk is marked as a tradeable asset, that is no guarantee that he gets traded, so of course at this point they should assume he's on the team and that's it. It's also not uncommon for players at risk of leaving by one way or another are given letters, or having a A upgraded to a C.

The Pesce issue is a far better point that indicates Faulk wouldn't be for sale. At least, it would show that Carolina could and should delay the trade to do what is best for their team.

 

[Cardiac Jerks]

Faulk was given an A yesterday. Also, Pesce is out with "a lung issue" indefinitely.

At this point, Faulk is probably not being moved unless someone offers something better than market value, involving a substantial asset.

Huh? I’m not seeing this Pesce news anywhere.

 

[780il]

They want RNH or Pulju, we laugh at them, shit keeps going in a circle.

Seriously, all these Faulk to EDM threads go the same way so why do they keep coming up? The 2 sides are not gonna agree on a trade, lock er up.

 

[hockeyguy1967]

With Sekera out long term, Edmonton is in need of defense. Faulk will be able to quaterback the powerplay and generate some offense from the blueline and fill in for Sekera.

What would be a good/fair proposal here?

No, he gets decimated in his own zone no freaking thanks.

 

[Boom Boom Apathy]

We don’t need Faulk, we’ve got Schultz.
Did I say Schultz? I meant Fayne.
Did I say Fayne? I meant Davidson.
Did I say Davidson? I meant Sekera.
Did I say Sekera? I meant Russell.
Did I say Russell? I meant Benning.

no freaking thanks.

 

[vorbis]

best I can tell Pesce is not 'out' so much as slowly ramping up his practicing after something that went on / occurred over the summer.

 

[VoluntaryDom]

RNH for Faulk would be awful for Carolina

 

[LTIR]

Strome + Benning/ Kassian

Gives CAR a replacement RD and a 3C

 

[La Bamba]

RNH for Faulk would be awful for Carolina

Good thing they wont get RNH because they would likely be getting Benning + Kassian + pick.

Have people not learned after the Skinner trade and many other trades? The team trading the "best" player ALWAYS loses.

 

[Boom Boom Apathy]

Have people not learned after the Skinner trade and many other trades? The team trading the "best" player ALWAYS loses.

That's not true

Jones/Johansson
J. Staal for 8th OA, Dumoulin, Sutter
St. Louis for Callahan and 2 1sts
Duchene for Girard, Kamanev, Bowers, 2019 1st, 2nd and 3rd
Erat (who was the best player at the time) for Forsberg
Kessel to Toronto for a 1st (Seguin) and 2nd (Hamilton)
M. Richards for Simmonds and B Schenn
Drouin for Sergachev

That's just off the top of my head. There are plenty of trades where value is equal or the team trading the best player does well.

No two trade are alike as team needs, contracts etc. Come into play. Skinner was a year away from UFA and wasn't going to be re-signed had a full NMC, and the team wanted to go in a different direction. Not even remotely apples to apples to Faulk.

I'm not predicting what a return for Faulk would be (and I'd expect it to be less the closer he gets to UFA status), just saying that your statement above isn't true.

 

[Cardiac Jerks]

Strome + Benning/ Kassian

Gives CAR a replacement RD and a 3C

And what would motivate us to do that?

 

[GoldiFox]

Trevor Van Riemsdyk to Edmonton for Strome or 2nd + prospect is more in line with what Edmonton fans want to pay. Solves the Canes RHD logjam if Pesce is ready.

 

[OTC]

Blackhawks Murphy out back injury. Anisimov/prospect for Faulk
will help both teams.

 

[Mr Positive]

Blackhawks Murphy out back injury. Anisimov/prospect for Faulk
will help both teams.

I think a trade like that would have already happened if Anisimov would waive his NTC, but this does make it more likely that the Hawks up the ante.

 

[spockBokk]

Blackhawks Murphy out back injury. Anisimov/prospect for Faulk
will help both teams.

How does that help CAR? They have guys that can fill in as a 3 C for much cheaper than Anisomov. Want Faulk to CHI? Pony up Saad or bust...

 

[hockeyguy1967]

Faulk off, we do not want him in Edmonton at all unless he is traded for like a second.

 

[Mcnotloilersfan]

If I'm Faulk I'd gladly take this deal in Edmonton.

If he doesn't see himself here long-term, that is fine for both us and him. He see's the opportunity that this gives us to slowly develop Bouch, while it gives him the opportunity to put up big PP numbers that will make him high value when he hits free agency. He's lost his spot on the PP to Dougie, and won't be getting any big minutes in Carolina.

 

[bluedevil58]

Hall for Larson.

 

[ottawa]

Did the Oilers magically find cap space? they can barely even sign Nurse for 4m.

 

[LTIR]

Did the Oilers magically find cap space? they can barely even sign Nurse for 4m.

Sekera' Injury opened up cap space