Taylor Hall - Patrice Bergeron - XXX
Clayton Keller - Ryan Johansen - XXX
XXX - XXX - XXX
XXX - XXX - XXX
Darnell Nurse - Erik Karlsson
XXX - Ethan Bear
XXX - XXX
XXX
XXX
Thoughts?
I really like your top pairing. I think both guys get a bad rap defensively: they aren't studs, but they're not going to get walked every other play like some suggested. They're both minute munchers for a reason and I think Nurse brings in spades everything Karlsson needs to succeed and play his game. Bear is fine too, but I think there were better value picks there.
Bergeron is a stud obviously, but I'm not sure how Hall fits with him. They play completely opposite styles. I think one of the reasons Hall's teams always seem to struggle is because he very much only plays his game, he doesn't tend to fit into a system well unless it's built around him. Bergeron is the exact opposite. A coach's nightmare vs. a coach's dream. Maybe I'm wrong on Hall, but it's what I've noticed over the years watching him play. He's no doubt incredibly talented, but there's a lot more to being great than just that.
I still like Johansen even though he can be lazy. He's fine as a 2C. Keller is a great 2nd liner as well, although again I think he plays a bit like Hall, just not as extreme.
I like the players but I'd be curious to see how well they fit together. I'm not sure they'd put it all together but the talent is there.