Evaluation - 23.09.2014

[HABsurde]

Bruins vs Habs
23.09.2014

GRADE (out of 10)

Tokarski
MacDonald

Markov
Gilbert
Tinordi
Pateryn
Finley
Nygren


De La Rose
Plekanec
Sekac
Bourque
Hudon
Scherback
Sorkin
Andrighetto
Thomas
Bowman
Dowell
McCarron


do your best assesment

Click to read more...

 

[WeThreeKings]

all 20 out of 10

 

[macavoy]

15.5

 

[Kojo]

25.0/1.0

ca sent la coupe

 

[Lshap]

Didn't bother with our vets. Also didn't grade a few prospects who I didn't get a good look at.

Bruins vs Habs
23.09.2014

GRADE (out of 10)

Tokarski : 7
MacDonald : 8

Markov :
Gilbert : 7.5
Tinordi : 6.5
Pateryn : 7
Finley
Nygren


De La Rose : 7
Plekanec :
Sekac : 9
Bourque :
Hudon : 7
Scherback : 8
Sorkin : 7.5
Andrighetto : 7.5
Thomas : 8.5
Bowman
Dowell
McCarron : 8


do your best assesment

 

[Number 57]

Tokarski 6.5
MacDonald 9.5

Markov 7
Gilbert 7.5
Tinordi 8
Pateryn 8
Finley 6
Nygren 6.5


De La Rose - 7
Plekanec - 7.5
Sekac - 9
Bourque - 5.5
Hudon - 7.5
Scherback - 7.5
Sorkin - 7
Andrighetto - 8
Thomas - 9
Bowman - 7.5
Dowell - 6.5
McCarron - 9

 

[Frank JT]

Is McCarron seriously injured?

 

[dkd]

Is McCarron seriously injured?

I hope not...

 

[No More Subban]

Sekac 8
McCarron 8
Scherbak 7
De la Rose 6.5
Andrighetto 6
Tinordi 5

These guys are the future, while the other prospects don't have any chance of making the team, including Thomas, unfortunately.

I just don't see it.

 

[David Suzuki]

One guy who impressed me was Sorkin. Didn't expect a lot but he was really fast and active.

 

[MasterD]

Sekac 7.5
De La Rose 6 but lots of potential
Thomas 7 LOTS of hustle but he just sends the puck in front of the net, don't see a big future for him... lacks smoothness in his game, somehow.
Pateryn 8 His ceiling is low, but as a 6th dman I prefer him to both Tinordi and Beaulieu
Tinordi 6.5
Tokarski 7
McCarron 8.5 not sure what his ceiling is but he played great, very involved, close to the net, pushing and hitting. Love him.