2020 Cup Champions
Formerly Sila v Kucherove
- Nov 26, 2013
- 14,774
- 4,404
So Horvat is a rising star and Karlsson is broken?You don’t get a signed rising star for an unsigned(1 year to go) broken guy.
You don’t get a signed rising star for an unsigned(1 year to go) broken guy.
LMFAO. Bo Horvat is a underrated low end #1 Center with huge upside and tremendous defensively. We’re not trading our #1 Center for a #1 dman in his prime with one year left, because by the time we can contend he’ll be old. Oh and if you think Horvat is an overrated #2 Center then GTFO as you have no idea what you’re talking about
As a canuck fan id do this value wise but the canucks arent in a position to make this type of deal
Very good for the Canucks, but, objectively, the trade is awful.
What the heck are some Canuck fans smoking here... I take this deal and run like a bandit. Canuck can easily extend Karlsson with the cap space once we get him. Not often a #1 defensemen becomes available for the cheap haha.
I think both fanbases would be disappointed, if this happens
You caught me.So Horvat is a rising star and Karlsson is broken?
No agenda here...
You caught me.
The serious part of my post was that no team is going to trade their best center who is signed for 5 years for any d man who has only 1 year left. Not without being able to work out a deal first. And then I’m guessing this deal is no longer offered.
Then, where's our center depth?
So you start off by saying Horvat has limited upside then proceed to say “he’s basically a selke winner”.
Weird post.
You don’t get a signed rising star for an unsigned(1 year to go) broken guy.
What the heck are some Canuck fans smoking here... I take this deal and run like a bandit. Canuck can easily extend Karlsson with the cap space once we get him. Not often a #1 defensemen becomes available for the cheap haha.
This is what I said too. If he was made available for contract discussion then bo is not enough.I can agree with the bolded and I'm fine agreeing that it wouldn't be in the best interest of Vancouver to do the trade but the value is heavily in the Canucks favour. If there was a deal in place, the add to Horvat would be huge. Probably your 1st plus Juolevi.
Yes yes I called ek brokenlol...a signed what??
We'll find one. When was the last time a defensemen of Karlsson calibre played for this team in the past 40 years?
LMFAO. Bo Horvat is a underrated low end #1 Center with huge upside and tremendous defensively. We’re not trading our #1 Center for a #1 dman in his prime with one year left, because by the time we can contend he’ll be old. Oh and if you think Horvat is an overrated #2 Center then GTFO as you have no idea what you’re talking about