Cringing anytime I see comparisons and comments here or anywhere else where McDavid and Matthews are brought up as it is and then you see things like comparing his shot last night to a Gretzky goal and I just wish people would reel it in a bit. Not going to lie, when he scored I laughed and the first thing I thought of was how many times I saw that exact shot from Gretzky lol.
Were you cringing when people called McDavid a generational player before he even played a game?
These people, at least that I can see, aren't saying after 10 games that Pettersson is as good/better than McDavid full stop. They're saying that the sky is the limit with this kid and he
could be just as good as these players based on what we've seen so far. This is an extremely reasonable statement. The only deficiency in his game so far is his size. This may change, he may be hot right now and then bust. People aren't unironically saying "it's over, Pettersson > McDavid move aside trashcan", they're saying he could
potentially be just as good as McDavid.
I cringe far more when people say "wow this guy could be the 2nd/3rd best player in the league behind McDavid/Matthews". Why? Because he wasn't 1st overall? I'm not saying he is or will ever be better than those two players, especially McDavid, but I do think the potential is there to be every bit as good. I'm not saying he is or definitely will be, I'm just saying his ceiling is as high as anyone's and arbitrarily putting a ceiling of just under McDavid or even Matthews because of who they are is silly. When someone compares his shot to a Gretzky shot, that doesn't mean they think he is every bit as good as Gretzky either.
I would say people should "reel it in a bit" but aside from
high hopes I have yet to see a single person claim that he will definitely be as good as McDavid rather than saying he
could be if he keeps up his pace and keeps developing at the rate he has over the past few years.