Proposal: Eichel Mega Thread

[Hunter368]

Continue

Click to read more...

 

[turnagainoutlaw]

Gaudreau Monahan Valimaki 2021 1st

for

Eichel Thompson

 

[ibleedkings]

I'd offer Byfield, 1st rounder this year, Mikey Anderson (Doughty's partner) and Kupari from LA.

 

[FlyguyOX]

Konecny
Frost
Zamula
1st

If that's not good enough I'll swap Zamula, but I think that should be competitive as is.

 

[GuerinUp]

Dont know if this has been said in previous pages, but wild are on board for:

Dumba
Rossi
Both '21 1sts
Rask

 

[CraigsList]

Dont know if this has been said in previous pages, but wild are on board for:

Dumba
Rossi
Both '21 1sts
Rask

that’s probably the best one so far.

 

[ManwithNoIdentity]

Someone on the wings board offered:

Raymond +Mantha + out first in 2021 I believe

 

[Fjordy]

Byfield++ would look interesting, but proposal would have to be finalized.

 

[Zach716]

This is brutal. For most teams you'll need to take your best young nhler with term/rfa status (top line potential), top 2 prospects (top 6 potential), and 1 forsure maybe 2 firsts depending on where you are expected to finish to start the convo.

That's a big if Buffalo even decides to shop him

 

[Fjordy]

that’s probably the best one so far.

Really?

 

[Dr Jan Itor]

Really?

It’s certainly not at the bottom of any list.

 

[archangel2]

Really?

they have been some very bad ones

 

[16thOverallSaveUs]

This is brutal. For most teams you'll need to take your best young nhler with term/rfa status (top line potential), top 2 prospects (top 6 potential), and 1 forsure maybe 2 firsts depending on where you are expected to finish to start the convo.

That's a big if Buffalo even decides to shop him

I don't think you're going to get a young top line player, 2 firsts, and 2 top prospects. If that were the ask, at least from Minnesota's perspective it would be a no from me.

 

[57special]

I'd offer Byfield, 1st rounder this year, Mikey Anderson (Doughty's partner) and Kupari from LA.

serious offer

 

[57special]

that’s probably the best one so far.

the LA one is nice, too.

 

[DJN21]

Dont know if this has been said in previous pages, but wild are on board for:

Dumba
Rossi
Both '21 1sts
Rask

swap Rask for Foligno

 

[KaprizovEntitlelist]

swap Rask for Foligno

Foligno was just signed to 3 years extension, he isn't available/ going anywhere

 

[Fjordy]

It’s certainly not at the bottom of any list.

Of course, I saw a lot of worse offers, but as I said before, why do we need Dumba if we will not claim anything in the near future? I am also confused by Rossi's situation after covid, this is a huge risk. As a result, we get RD, which does little for us, and a really good prospect, but which has health problems and it is not clear how this can be said on it in the future.

they have been some very bad ones

Of course, but this is not very attractive, my explanation is just above.

 

[57special]

swap Rask for Foligno

I suspect that some might start to squawk at that. Foligno isn't going to be a scoring champ, but he is an important player for MN. I've done a complete 180 on him since the trade.

If Foligno was subbed for Rask, then Bjugstad (don't worry, he's expiring, and PIT is retaining 50% on him) would have to be included to balance salaries. I would also want a 2nd from BUF.

 

[DJN21]

Foligno was just signed to 3 years extension, he isn't available/ going anywhere

meh when it comes to a player of Eichel's caliber and getting the 1C you desperately need those things really dont matter. And from my more petty side no Foligno no Eichel lol.

 

[DJN21]

I suspect that some might start to squawk at that. Foligno isn't going to be a scoring champ, but he is an important player for MN. I've done a complete 180 on him since the trade.

If Foligno was subbed for Rask, then Bjugstad (don't worry, he's expiring, and PIT is retaining 50% on him) would have to be included to balance salaries. I would also want a 2nd from BUF.

Swap the 2nd from our end to a Tage Thompson. We'd have to many bodies coming in and need actual bodies going out.

All fun conjecture aside the Kings are the team that can make the most impressive offer here and I'd just as soon deal with them because I value Byfield over Rossi and if I could pry kayliev away as well I value that over a 2021 first from Minny but thats just personal bias.
Didn't mean that as an attack or counter offer just thinking out loud to myself.

 

[7even]

This is brutal. For most teams you'll need to take your best young nhler with term/rfa status (top line potential), top 2 prospects (top 6 potential), and 1 forsure maybe 2 firsts depending on where you are expected to finish to start the convo.

That's a big if Buffalo even decides to shop him

I disagree, it depends on what the Sabres are trying to do with an Eichel trade, philosophically. Are they trying to improve the team (a tall order when you're losing the best player in the deal no matter what), or are they trying to reshuffle him into another blue chip + collateral? Those deals could look very different.

 

[MayDayMayDay]

Dont know if this has been said in previous pages, but wild are on board for:

Dumba
Rossi
Both '21 1sts
Rask

As a Sabres fan, provided we extend Dumba, I think I take this.

 

[Dr Jan Itor]

Of course, I saw a lot of worse offers, but as I said before, why do we need Dumba if we will not claim anything in the near future? I am also confused by Rossi's situation after covid, this is a huge risk. As a result, we get RD, which does little for us, and a really good prospect, but which has health problems and it is not clear how this can be said on it in the future.


Of course, but this is not very attractive, my explanation is just above.

Dumba is salary and value. Buffalo would be free to do whatever they wanted with him. Teams would be calling. If you’d rather we left him out and figured it out ourselves, the fine I guess, but he’s not going to be replaced by a ton more stuff.

The COVID thing is what it is. Maybe it kills the deal, maybe it doesn’t.

 

[Techcoockie]

Someone on the wings board offered:

Raymond +Mantha + out first in 2021 I believe

adn you woudl run with which wingers ? Bertuzzi ?