In 2017-18, they had the Lightning beating the Oilers in the Stanley Cup Final.
2017-18 NHL® SEASON SIM - NHL® 18
The year before that, they had Nashville defeating Montreal in the Cup Final.
NHL®17 | 2016-17 Season Simulation
In 2016, they had the Ducks beating the Canadiens.
NHL 16 Season Sim
2015, the sim had the Ducks beating the Rangers.
2015 Stanley Cup Playoffs Sim
So there ya go, the EA Sports simulations suck.
Remember, those fools don't even bother to update player ratings. I'm sure Corey Perry is still rated in the high 80s, along with Ryan Kesler.