Draft #4 Round 2 Voting

Pick the winner


  • Total voters
    21
  • Poll closed .

Joey Moss

Registered User
Aug 29, 2008
36,153
7,997
First two rounds of the voting will be in-house. The next rounds will go to the polls section. Tie-breaker for the polls section will be most votes from people within the draft. I am not counting votes for people who have a connection which are;
LucBourdon and cocoloco
Paralyzer008 and McMozesmadness
BeLeafing and DatsyukianDekes
BumDum, McMullet, and Llamamoto

These groups can either vote for opposite person, or no vote for that matchup.

Everything else fair game. If you can't vote in polls you can PM me your votes! We are looking for 25 votes, or leader after 1 day. If each matchup has 25 votes we can move to next round.

extralarge.png

Andreas Johnsson - John Tavares - Mitch Marner
Brady Tkachuk - Ryan Strome - Cam Atkinson
Artturi Lehkonen - Erik Haula - Rocco Grimaldi
Mitchell Stephens - Tomas Nosek - Garnet Hathaway

Darnell Nurse - Ivan Provorov
Brady Skjei - Chris Tanev
Jamie Oleksiak - Zach Bogosian

Joonas Korpisalo
Alexandar Georgiev

extralarge.png

Brad Marchand / Nick Bonino / Mikko Rantanen
Jack Roslovic / Tyler Bozak / Kailer Yamamoto
Brendan Lemieux / Colton Sissons / Ondrej Kase
Jansen Harkins / Johan Larsson / Sam Lafferty

Brian Dumoulin / Erik Karlsson
Will Butcher / TJ Brodie
Slater Koekkoek / Jon Merrill

Jordan Binnington
Petr Mrazek

__________________________________

extralarge.png

Jaden Schwartz - Steven Stamkos - Dustin Brown
Jake Debrusk - Nico Hischier - Brett Connolly
Richard Panik - Travis Zajac - Alex Chiasson
Jujhar Khaira - Brad Richardson - Christian Fischer

Miro Heiskanen - Matt Dumba
Vladislav Gavrikov - Damon Severson
Mirco Mueller - Matt Benning

Marc Andre Fleury
Pekka Rinne

extralarge.png

Alex Ovechkin - Pierre-Luc Dubois - Alex Radulov
Jordan Greenway - Mikael Backlund - Valeri Nichushkin
Brock McGinn - Alex Kerfoot - Barclay Goodrow
Michael Dal Colle - Valtteri Filppula - Denis Malgin

Jonas Brodin - John Carlson
Marco Scandella - Erik Cernak
Caleb Jones - Justin Schultz

Robin Lehner
Jake Allen

______________________________________

extralarge.png

Alex Killorn - Evgeni Malkin - Bryan Rust
Ondrej Palat - David Krejci - Tom Wilson
Matthew Nieto - Radek Faksa - Josh Archibald
Blake Comeau - Lucas Wallmark - Tyler Pitlick

Jaccob Slavin - John Klingberg
Nikita Zadorov - David Savard
Dan Hamhuis - Robert Hagg

Igor Shesterkin
Anton Khudobin

extralarge.png

Nino Niederreiter - Anze Kopitar - Viktor Arvidsson
Conor Garland - Logan Couture - Josh Anderson
Ryan Donato - Boone Jenner - Luke Kunin
Dmitry Timashov - Brian Boyle - Chris Wagner

Shea Theodore - Brett Pesce
Esa Lindell - Stephen Johns
John Moore - Erik Gudbranson

Ben Bishop
Louis Domingue

_________________________________

extralarge.png

Timo Meier - Evgeni Kuznetsov - Alex Debrincat
Vladislav Namestnikov - Bryan Little - Alex Tuch
Miles Wood - Cody Eakin - Martin Necas
Nick Paul - Ryan Kesler - Noah Gregor

Morgan Rielly - Seth Jones
Joel Edmundson - Travis Sanheim
Nick Hague - Justin Holl

Juuse Saros
Cam Talbot

extralarge.png

Nikita Gusev - Mathew Barzal - Kyle Palmieri
Jonathan Drouin - Tyler Seguin - Patric Hornqvist
Patrick Marleau - Kirby Dach - Filip Zadina
Kyle Clifford - Riley Sheahan - Alexander Steen

Ryan Suter - Jeff Petry
Dmitry Orlov - Matt Roy
Jake Bean - Tucker Poolman

Semyon Varlamov
Casey DeSmith

______________________________

extralarge.png

Mike Hoffman - Sean Couturier - Blake Coleman
Dominik Kahun - Max Domi - Tyler Toffoli
Nick Ritchie - Jeff Carter - Nick Bjugstad
Melker Karlsson - Alex Galchenyuk - Nicolas Aube Kubel

Mattias Ekholm - Shea Weber
Calvin De Haan - Sami Vatanen
Rasmus Sandin - Kris Russell

Elvis Merzlikins
Mikko Koskinen

extralarge.png

Alexandre Texier - Dylan Larkin - Brendan Gallagher
Matthew Tkachuk - Nick Schmaltz - Craig Smith
Patrick Maroon - Jordan Staal - Josh Leivo
Drake Caggiula - Luke Glendening - Colin Blackwell

Nate Schmidt - Alex Pietrangelo
Radim Simek - Filip Hronek
Brayden McNabb - Dante Fabbro

Carey Price
Adin Hill

______________________________

extralarge.png

Max Pacioretty - Mika Zibanejad - Zach Sanford
Anders Lee - Brock Nelson - Joonas Donskoi
Matt Calvert - Casey Cizikas - Dominik Simon
Matt Martin - Nick Cousins - Mathieu Joseph

Devon Toews - Kris Letang
Ian Cole - Justin Faulk
Jonas Siegenthaler - Jan Rutta

Tuukka Rask
Matiss Kivlenieks

:vegas
Johnny Gaudreau - Nathan MacKinnon - Sonny Milano
Oskar Lindblom - Matt Duchene - Jakub Voracek
Derick Brassard - Jared McCann - Ryan Dzingel
Joakim Nygard - Sam Bennett - Yakov Trenin

Hampus Lindholm - Neal Pionk
Noah Hanifin - Brandon Montour
Andrej Sekera - Troy Stecher

Jacob Markstrom
Aaron Dell

________________________________

extralarge.png

Tyler Bertuzzi - Brayden Point - Kevin Fiala
Tanner Pearson - Jonathan Toews - Jake Virtanen
Danton Heinen - Chris Tierney - Ivan Barbashev
Trevor Moore - Michael Amadio - Ryan Reaves

Oscar Klefbom - Colton Parayko
Vince Dunn - Jason Demers
Mark Borowiecki - Tim Heed

Frederik Andersen
Alex Stalock

extralarge.png

Denis Gurianov - Alex Barkov - Vladimir Tarasenko
Filip Forsberg - Adam Henrique - T.J Oshie
Carl Hagelin - Derek Ryan - Mattias Janmark
Antoine Roussel - Morgan Frost - Michael Frolik

Oliver Ekman-Larsson - Rasmus Andersson
Duncan Keith - Markus Nutivaara
Carl Gunnarsson - Ilya Lyubushken

Tristan Jarry
Anthony Stolarz

_______________________________

extralarge.png

Zach Parise - Sidney Crosby - Josh Bailey
Jakub Vrana - Eric Staal - Kevin Labanc
Tyler Ennis - Carl Soderberg - Troy Terry
Zach Aston-Reese - Teddy Blueger - Kyle Okposo

Quinn Hughes - Brandon Carlo
Ryan Lindgren - Aaron Ekblad
Andy Greene - Taylor Fedun

Antti Raanta
Thomas Greiss

extralarge.png

Kyle Connor - Connor McDavid - Anthony Mantha
Marcus Johansson - Kevin Hayes - Mikael Granlund
Filip Chytil - Robby Fabbri - Kaapo Kakko
Leo Komarov - Zemgus Girgensons - Martin Kaut

Ryan Graves - Tony DeAngelo
Mackenzie Weegar - Travis Hamonic
Carson Soucy - Adam Boqvist

Braden Holtby
Jonathan Bernier​
 

Joey Moss

Registered User
Aug 29, 2008
36,153
7,997
Columbus vs. Minnesota.

Malkin > Kopitar
Killorn > Niederreiter
Rust > Arvidsson
Krejci < Couture
Palat > Garland
Wilson > Anderson

Am I missing something? I'll give Minnesota the goaltending edge but surprised by the early results.
 

Joey Moss

Registered User
Aug 29, 2008
36,153
7,997
Vote from PM

Round 2 voting

Arizona over Pittsburgh
Edmonton over Montreal
Minnesota over Columbus
St. Louis over San Jose
Chicago over Winnipeg
Calgary over Vegas
Buffalo over Vancouver
 
  • Like
Reactions: Llamamoto49

Blinny

This is the Sway
Jan 6, 2010
1,768
1,413
Dorchester
Columbus vs. Minnesota.

Malkin > Kopitar I agree.
Killorn > Niederreiter I disagree
Rust > Arvidsson I think they are closer to equals
Krejci < Couture Agree
Palat > Garland Palat is better now but don’t count Garland out
Wilson > Anderson Disagree

Am I missing something? I'll give Minnesota the goaltending edge but surprised by the early results.

What your not talking about is the Great Wall of Minnesota and their General Ben Bishop. The Minnesota defense is very strong with a WORLD class goalie. Against a good defense and an unproven goaltender
 

Joey Moss

Registered User
Aug 29, 2008
36,153
7,997
What your not talking about is the Great Wall of Minnesota and their General Ben Bishop. The Minnesota defense is very strong with a WORLD class goalie. Against a good defense and an unproven goaltender
I don't really see how the forwards can be debated at all but respect the opinion.
 

Blinny

This is the Sway
Jan 6, 2010
1,768
1,413
Dorchester
I don't really see how the forwards can be debated at all but respect the opinion.
Because this is a game of semantics. People hold different views on different players. Still haven’t addressed the defense or goaltending. Both of which I think I am better in. Not to mention the defensive capability of my offensive players is fantastic.
 

Joey Moss

Registered User
Aug 29, 2008
36,153
7,997
Because this is a game of semantics. People hold different views on different players. Still haven’t addressed the defense or goaltending. Both of which I think I am better in. Not to mention the defensive capability of my offensive players is fantastic.
Ok well to dive deeper.

How are you honestly going to argue Niederreiter, Arvidsson and Anderson there?

Niederreiter and Arvidsson were playing on 4th lines for their respective teams this season. Both of them had the production of 3rd line players this season while Rust was PPG playing with Malkin (who I happen to have). Anderson scored 1 goal in a miserable year. He's the player you take in the middle of the draft based on what he is capable of. But how are you going to justify him being better than Wilson, who does everything Anderson does much better?

To me Slavin is better than Theodore by a hair and Klingberg is equal to Theodore.

Bishop is great, but Malkin is so much better than Kopitar right now it's perplexing.
 

Joey Moss

Registered User
Aug 29, 2008
36,153
7,997
As of right now..

Arizona mathematically moves forward
Edmonton (9) vs. Montreal (10)
Columbus (10) vs. Minnesota (11)
St. Louis mathematically moves forward
One more Winnipeg vote sinks Chicago
One more Vegas vote sinks Calgary
Two more Tampa votes sinks Dallas
Buffalo mathematically move forward
 

Panda Bear

Registered User
Apr 2, 2010
6,566
5,699
for the greater good vote calgary

Milano line 1 is awful

Hanifin-Montour is 100% lol defensively
 

Blinny

This is the Sway
Jan 6, 2010
1,768
1,413
Dorchester
Ok well to dive deeper.

How are you honestly going to argue Niederreiter, Arvidsson and Anderson there?

Niederreiter and Arvidsson were playing on 4th lines for their respective teams this season. Both of them had the production of 3rd line players this season while Rust was PPG playing with Malkin (who I happen to have). Anderson scored 1 goal in a miserable year. He's the player you take in the middle of the draft based on what he is capable of. But how are you going to justify him being better than Wilson, who does everything Anderson does much better?

To me Slavin is better than Theodore by a hair and Klingberg is equal to Theodore.

Bishop is great, but Malkin is so much better than Kopitar right now it's perplexing.
Didn’t realize it was Tom Wilson. Yes I agree is way better than Anderson.
 

Llamamoto

Nice Bison. Kind Bison. Yep.
Sep 5, 2018
8,855
12,207
All right. T'was a fun ride, a 10-9 loss is pretty much the best way to go.

Credit to @OB5 for the great team.
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad

-->