Domi Value vs W. Nylander Value

[Hunter368]

Fairly straight forward poll question. Who has greater value overall, Domi or W Nylander?

Click to read more...

 

[bobholly39]

Nylander slightly, because of contract.

They're really close though in terms of value. Depending on team needs/what you like more.

 

[Holymakinaw]

Nylander.

He scores more goals and has more consistent level of production. Domi plays with a better "edge" but his production is all over the place.

 

[Syckle78]

Nylander without a doubt.

 

[The Moose is Loose]

Nylander by a slight margin. He has better numbers but he has A LOT more support/better teammates, is paid more, and lacks the physicality that Domi brings.

the question of who produced more is obviously easily Nylander, but all other factors help Domi make it close. In the end I’d still take Nylander tho

 

[KevSkillz4]

Value? Nylander no doubt.

Better player? Max Domi, he got the talent but with more grit than Nylander.

 

[joe dirte]

Nylander by a decent margin.

Ive seen one havs fan claim hes just as good. Just one. Toolegit or something. You might get a few more habs fans claiming this vut thats about all. This poll will go 100% nylander among non habs fans.

 

[CatchyTune]

Value? Nylander no doubt.

Better player? Max Domi, he got the talent but with more grit than Nylander.

Everyones favorite word.

I bet you think Gallagher is better too.

 

[Northern Avs Fan]

I would give up more in a trade for a Nylander.

 

[CanadienShark]

Going Nylander, but it's not a big gap.

 

[7even]

Value? Nylander no doubt.

Better player? Max Domi, he got the talent but with more grit than Nylander.

There's grit and then there's functional grit. Domi isn't very efficient in leveraging his physicality to create higher percentage chances than other players get. If you look at the numbers, Nylander is one of the most successful players in the league through the "dirty" areas even though he never initiates physically, just because he's got great positioning and puck protection skills.

Domi's got a dimension Nylander lacks, for sure. I just don't know how much value it actually adds to his game though.

 

[stopclickbait]

Nylander easily but if Domi can shoot at a 30% clip it’s closer plus you can’t forget about the intangible that is “grit”

 

[LeafsNation75]

The obvious answer is Nylander if you value goal scoring and the fact he set a new career high in goals this past season with 31.

 

[The Winter Soldier]

I think what Domi signs for will determine the answer of this poll. He is a proven 72 point player and he did it an entire year at Center. Whom most would regard as more value. Also he has a lot more bite in his game. Nylander is talented, but until I see him break some eggs when he goes into corners, he is abit soft and that is question mark for me in the playoffs.

 

[CanadienShark]

I don't see why the gap is so big in voting. Domi hit a career high last year similar to what Nylander paced this year. It's a tough call, but I'm taking Nylander by a small margin.

 

[WetcoastOrca]

Close. I picked Nylander but I don’t think there’s a big gap. If Domi played with Matthews and on the much more offensive minded Leafs he’d put up similar numbers to Nylander imo.

 

[Dion TheFluff]

I think what Domi signs for will determine the answer of this poll. He is a proven 72 point player and he did it an entire year at Center. Whom most would regard as more value. Also he has a lot more bite in his game. Nylander is talented, but until I see him break some eggs when he goes into corners, he is abit soft and that is question mark for me in the playoffs.

one season over 52 points isn't a proven 72 point center.

 

[Fatass]

What’s of more value: second line centre, or second line winger?

 

[CatchyTune]

What’s of more value: second line centre, or second line winger?

Nylander was 8th in goals and 23rd in points for wingers this year. He is a 1st line winger.

 

[LeafsNation75]

I think what Domi signs for will determine the answer of this poll. He is a proven 72 point player and he did it an entire year at Center. Whom most would regard as more value. Also he has a lot more bite in his game. Nylander is talented, but until I see him break some eggs when he goes into corners, he is abit soft and that is question mark for me in the playoffs.

There are always specific goal posts you must think Leafs players need to go through when it comes to their accomplishments.

In the 2018-19 season you called Nylander overpaid because he only put up 27 points making $10.2 million since Dubas pro rated his salary.

However this past season when he scores a new career high of 31 goals in 68 games and was on track for a new career high in points you want to ignore all that.

 

[TSN Jdog]

Need to see Domi's next contract to make a fair assessment.

Nylander is the better offensive player for sure but he has a lot of defensive short comings. Domi isn't an offensive stud but he definitely can grind and check with the best of the league.

 

[ACC1224]

No really very close, Nylander by a margin.
This should be a pretty lopsided poll.
Has a player ever received zero votes? This could be a contender.

 

[spiny norman]

Lopsided result.