I will not look too deeply into how an 20 man team plays plus or minus 1 player, however... on the whole Taylor Hall did not play a sound brand of hockey for most of his career here. if we take out the MVP season where he was so good and productive nothing else mattered. but if you look at all his other years he was not a sound player. This doesn't mean I don't think he was a good player and a productive one, but his style of play lended to turnovers, risky plays, etc etc. point is , if he is your go to guy and he plays a certain style and the head coach ( hynes) absolutely loves him, well then maybe a certain mentality starts to creep into the mindset. I will never take away what Hall did in 2018, but I for one was never a fan of how he played the game. certainly not saying now that he is gone the devils will be fine... far from it, he was their most productive forward, but we may start to see style of hockey that lends itself to winning.
is there a reason he was always on losing teams? jury is out