Proposal: detroits 4OA for a prospect or young nhler

[Lil Sebastian Cossa]

Poolparty?

Long answer: Hahah hahahahahaha.

short answer: no

 

[Oddbob]

We aren't getting anyone worth trading 4th overall for, one for one! Keep the pick and move on!

 

[DFC]

To be honest the only player I would consider one for one is Sergachev. Not sure how Tampa fans would feel, but I heard rumblings about a combo of him and Cirelli due for raises in this off season.

There's no way we let Sergachev go. I think there's a small chance either Cernak or Cirelli go. If it comes down to those two, Cirelli is the better player, but, because we're deeper at C, I think he would be the guy we move. But that's very debatable.

Plan A is obviously to keep all three, and, because it's TB, I don't think it's implausible. But if it can't happen, I think there's a slightly higher chance that we part with Cirelli instead of Cernak, but no chance whatsoever we let Sergachev go.

 

[DFC]

Sabres offer the 8th overall for Cirelli.

I don't think it's unrealistic. Good value for both sides, IMO. He's playing hurt at the moment, but, when healthy, he's a hell of a player. TB's gonna try to sign him to something waaaay under market value.

 

[mrinsane]

Domi

 

[Syckle78]

We aren't getting anyone worth trading 4th overall for, one for one! Keep the pick and move on!

This.

 

[Syckle78]

Domi

Definitely not this.

 

[OilerSuperstar17]

cant be older than 23 , and its just a 1 for 1 deal

Jesse Puljujarvi

No take-backs

 

[Colt55]

Vince dunn + Nikita alexandrov

 

[Balthazar]

To be honest the only player I would consider one for one is Sergachev. Not sure how Tampa fans would feel, but I heard rumblings about a combo of him and Cirelli due for raises in this off season.

Yikes. Sergachev isn't worth the 4OA pick.

Why would Detroit trade that pick anyway? They are early in the rebuilding process, just take the pick.

 

[Henkka]

Werenski? Done. Though it's almost a foregone conclusion he'll sign in DET in a few years as UFA, (home/MI roots/best buddies w/Larkin @ U.M. etc.)

Current needs:
young Top4 LD with Top Pair (near certainty).

young 2C (prefer RHS, 2-way) now with small possibility of 1C ceiling.[/USER]

What if Larkin signs to Columbus cause of Werenski ?

 

[Hostile Offer]

You're not getting the value you want, but for the sake of playing the game I'll offer Kotkaniemi.

 

[Henkka]

There's no way we let Sergachev go. I think there's a small chance either Cernak or Cirelli go. If it comes down to those two, Cirelli is the better player, but, because we're deeper at C, I think he would be the guy we move. But that's very debatable.

Plan A is obviously to keep all three, and, because it's TB, I don't think it's implausible. But if it can't happen, I think there's a slightly higher chance that we part with Cirelli instead of Cernak, but no chance whatsoever we let Sergachev go.

Would you think Yzerman goes after Cirelli ?

If Red Wings get Krug, there's no need for "sergachev", but still that need for a center.

 

[Ghost of Ethan Hunt]

What if Larkin signs to Columbus cause of Werenski ?

What year does Werenski become UFA? '23-'24 or '24-'25? He (or someone his caliber) is probably the final big piece for a cup contender if we hadn't already filled that role. They're both Michiganders. Lastly in 3-4 seasons do you expect the cap to be over $85-90M? I think that's a good range, but a bit high considering 3 yrs of Flat Cap...CBJ won't be able to/won't want to pay $10M+ ? for ZW, we however would. Remember they gotta pay PLD & Seth Jones, that's probably $20M++ in 3-4 seasons.

 

[WingsMJN2965]

Werenski? Done. Though it's almost a foregone conclusion he'll sign in DET in a few years as UFA, (home/MI roots/best buddies w/Larkin @ U.M. etc.)

 

[Wingsfan 4 life]

Why would a rebuilding team trade the 4th overall pick? Yzerman isn't dumb.

In all likelihood, they're not, but OP is probably like me, and not a fan of Yzerman's drafting in the 1st round.

 

[CanadienShark]

You're not getting the value you want, but for the sake of playing the game I'll offer Kotkaniemi.

Why?

 

[Hostile Offer]

Why?

For value discussion. Habs won't obviously trade Kotkaniemi but if they decided right now that it's better off to send him to another organization, would he fetch a 4th overall? It's not like we currently have a clear picture of what KK is going to be. Actually the Habs don't seem to have a clear picture on anyone other than Suzuki.

 

[CanadienShark]

For value discussion. Habs won't obviously trade Kotkaniemi but if they decided right now that it's better off to send him to another organization, would he fetch a 4th overall? It's not like we currently have a clear picture of what KK is going to be. Actually the Habs don't seem to have a clear picture on anyone other than Suzuki.

I just don't see the point. Kotkaniemi is going nowhere. A draft pick isn't what the Habs need either. He along with Suzuki are the future #1/2C.

 

[Hostile Offer]

I just don't see the point. Kotkaniemi is going nowhere. A draft pick isn't what the Habs need either. He along with Suzuki are the future #1/2C.

That's the idea, obviously, if everything goes as expected. And I know they aren't trading KK at this point. But also the return discussed here is not just "a" draft pick. It's the 4th overall pick.

 

[Dr Quincy]

Werenski? Done. Though it's almost a foregone conclusion he'll sign in DET in a few years as UFA, (home/MI roots/best buddies w/Larkin @ U.M. etc.)

Current needs:
young Top4 LD with Top Pair (near certainty).

young 2C (prefer RHS, 2-way) now with small possibility of 1C ceiling.[/USER]

Why would anyone trade those for #4?

 

[Dr Quincy]

Vince dunn + Nikita alexandrov

It was for #4 not #14.

 

[pld459666]

Why would a rebuilding team trade the 4th overall pick? Yzerman isn't dumb.

He won't, but if he did, its not on a one for one basis.

I'd venture a guess he'd want to stay in top 10 this year, add another good prospect and add another 2nd this year or next.

Not to many players out there available that fir a 1 for 1 scenario

 

[KevinFinnerty]

Ryan Strome + 22 + Georgiev

 

[Jrtu]

Poolparty?

He said the 4th overall pick, not a 4th round pick.

okay... I might have exaggerated a little, but still, he doesn’t get you anything remotely close to a 4th overall. Not even sure if anyone is willing to cough up a 1st rounder at this point.