Defenders for 2007 NHL DRAFT

[bigv]

Everyone know that Alzner is No.1 but lets go talk about other D.........s
here is my Ranking for D and I put there who looks like who in NHL and other specials
Rating 10-best
9-very good
8- good
7-solid
6-average
5-poor
4-bad
3-very bad
Ranking

1 Alzner 9 Philips
2 Hickey 8 Niedermayer
3 Ellerby 8 Redden
4 Cole 8 I dont know
5 Plante 8 Malik
6 Katic 7 Boyle
7 Valach 7 Pronger
8 Cross 7 Salej
9 Mcdonaugh 6 I dont know
10 Grant 5 I dont know
11 Doyle 5 Schneider
12 Brennan 5 I dont know
13 Petrecki 5 Foot ..................hmmmm this guy can go higher but I think he is overrated
other D are less than 5 and NI for me I didnt see potential Shatenkirk????? Reul??? Thank you for reading this Ranking

Click to read more...

 

[Canadienjet]

Brennan aint 5. more like a 6.

 

[Chrisd]

umm

phillips a 9 and niedermayer a 8...

Quite frankly there will be no niedermayers in this draft most likely..

 

[Hockey-Freak]

umm

phillips a 9 and niedermayer a 8...

Quite frankly there will be no niedermayers in this draft most likely..

I guess he meant style of play, not skill set...

If the 7 (solid) means top-4 defender I doubt there´s a 9 in this draft wich would be a true No.1. Alzner maybe an 8 (top pairing defenseman) but not special enough to create stupid nicknames like "JMFJ"