An article published on Sportsnet some time ago provides some insight into the role MacKenzie will play and the “new CHL hierarchy”:
“[T]he new president will report to what we call our executive council which is each of the three league commissioners. And we bring a wealth of experience and knowledge, we have over 100 years of experience amongst the three commissioners.”
Q&A with David Branch: On president search, taking CHL to a new age - Sportsnet.ca
In other words, David Branch (OHL), Gilles Courteau (QMJHL) and Ron Robison (WHL) do not report to new CHL-boss MacKenzie. Rather, he reports to them.
That’s an interesting setup, to say the least.
Also, while the “over 100 years of experience amongst the commissioners” is genuinely valuable, the flip side is that all 3 league commissioners are getting a bit long in the tooth. Branch is in his early-70s and both Courteau Robison are in their mid-60s. They’ve led their respective leagues for 41, 34 and 20 years, respectively, and all 3 held senior positions within hockey leagues/governance bodies prior to assuming major junior hockey league presidencies.
It’s a fine line between guiding the new CHL commissioner and getting out of his way as junior hockey is on the cusp of its 3rd decade of the 21st century. Can the 3-headed monster to which MacKenzie must report pull this off? Maybe.
About a year or so ago the CHL moved from being a self-described “umbrella organization” to a fully incorporated entity, so corporate governance issues do matter now. Is Dan MacKenzie just the President, or is he the President and CEO? There’s a significant difference, and one would need to see the official CHL Letters Patent and Articles of Incorporation to know for sure and to get a grip on MacKenzie’s true role within the CHL’s corporate hierarchy. The Devil (or the Angel) is usually in those structural Details.
My sense right now — and this could definitely change in the future if more information becomes public knowledge — is that MacKenzie was hired to be something akin to a Senior Marketing Officer (or Executive Director) reporting to the 3 league commissioners.
The CHL doesn’t really have an employee infrastructure — it’s used David Branch’s OHL office and staff since 1996. Will there be a separate CHL headquarters? A staff infrastructure to do the work? Even Branch’s general counsel with the OHL in Ontario has been on retainer for years and usually undertakes CHL-related business too. Will that continue with MacKenzie?
Lastly, there’s the issue of “right-hand man.” Bettman has Daley, and they are both graduates of NYU law. This kind of “I need someone I completely trust beside me” approach to leadership is the norm these days, and don’t be surprised if MacKenzie does not come alone when his new job begins in September. Frankly, while MacKenzie has an impressive resume on the marketing side (a lot with TSN), I’m a bit surprised the 3 commissioners didn’t opt for a trained attorney, and their decision to hire a “Marketing Guy” probably speaks to the role he will fill. I wonder what he told the 3 commissioners during his interviews? Most marketing experts try to sell a signature strategy they wish to pursue if hired, and I’d love to have been a fly on the wall listening in.