Current best Canadian Winger?

[alg363636]

Which Canadian Winger is currently the best? I feel like the 4 below are the best options but if you'd like me to add anyone else let me know.

Click to read more...

 

[Sky04]

Marchand... 3 straight elite seasons, coming off a 100 point season with very good playoff numbers during that time as well.

 

[PoutineSp00nZ]

Marchand
Stone
Hall
Marner

 

[Connor McConnor]

Stone
Marchand
Marner
Hall

 

[Just Linda]

Stone
Marchand
Marner
Hall

Bingo what I got.

I like Marchand a lot but I think playing with who he plays with and the chemistry they got takes him from being a nearly elite to a truly elite winger whereas Stone is elite on his own.

 

[nowhereman]

I hate his guts but I'm going Marchand. He's one talented piece of ****.

 

[Halla]

leafs fan voting marchand

 

[DirtDiver]

I hate his guts but I'm going Marchand. He's one talented piece of ****.

What he said.

 

[majormajor]

I think Marchand is pretty dumb defensively a lot of the time, he gets away with it because of his linemates. Great scorer, great p.o.s. though.

Stone can come close enough on scoring that he's more valuable.

 

[A4T1L6]

Bingo what I got.

I like Marchand a lot but I think playing with who he plays with and the chemistry they got takes him from being a nearly elite to a truly elite winger whereas Stone is elite on his own.

I agree with this

 

[Eternal Leaf]

Definitely Marchand.

 

[Mike Hasselhoffman]

Coming from a Habs fan who despises all things Bruin, it’s Marchand.

 

[LuckyBoeser]

Stone
Hall
Marchand
Marner

 

[AvroArrow]

The most chicken shit guy is the answer

 

[Lebowski]

For how good Canada’s center depth is, it’s a pretty pitiful state on the wings.

 

[KoozNetsOff 92]

I think Marchand is pretty dumb defensively a lot of the time, he gets away with it because of his linemates. Great scorer, great p.o.s. though.

Stone can come close enough on scoring that he's more valuable.

Stone's career high is 73pts. Marchand just put up seasons of 85, 85 and 100pts. Stone has never been close to a top 10 pts finish, Marchand has come top 5 2x. They are in no way "close enough" in scoring, unless you think a ~60pt guy = a ~90pt guy.

 

[KoozNetsOff 92]

Bingo what I got.

I like Marchand a lot but I think playing with who he plays with and the chemistry they got takes him from being a nearly elite to a truly elite winger whereas Stone is elite on his own.

Chemistry isn't the reason why 1 guy is a ~60pt player and the other is a ~90pt player.

 

[Hustlr]

Stone's career high is 73pts. Marchand just put up seasons of 85, 85 and 100pts. Stone has never been close to a top 10 pts finish, Marchand has come top 5 2x. They are in no way "close enough" in scoring, unless you think a ~60pt guy = a ~90pt guy.

I think his point was just that Stone is better defensively and that closes the gap for him. Just trying to clarify

Marchand
Stone
Marner/Hall

 

[CallMeShaft]

It's the Rat.

 

[Sky04]

I think Marchand is pretty dumb defensively a lot of the time, he gets away with it because of his linemates. Great scorer, great p.o.s. though.

Stone can come close enough on scoring that he's more valuable.

By close like how a 60 point scorer is close to a 90 point scorer?

Yeah sure that's the same logic people tried to argue Toews was better than Malkin.

 

[Just Linda]

Chemistry isn't the reason why 1 guy is a ~60pt player and the other is a ~90pt player.

True but I feel Stones defensive skill makes him the better player

 

[Sky04]

For how good Canada’s center depth is, it’s a pretty pitiful state on the wings.

A hart trophy winner, a 100 point scorer, a 94 point 21 year old and the best defensive winger in the game? Awful take.

 

[North Cole]

Yeah, I mean...Marchand. He's good enough defensively that there isnt any merit to Stone's defensive ability closing a 25 point gap. Not that I think it should anyways, defense is overrated when it comes to forward imo

 

[Trap Jesus]

I'd have Stone 1st and Marchand 2nd. Way ahead of everyone else.

 

[Suntouchable13]

Marchand. I'd love a player like him on my team.