Corey Crawford vs Chris Osgood

[ClydeLee]

Lol yeah if you want to talk about a 20th finish in Vezina voting maybe. He got 5 first place votes, 6 second place votes and 3 third. You dont do that with just wins, come on

What are you focusing on here? Just 95-96 Yes voters of that go by the top teams guys and guys with most wins.

Why didn't Hasek win it or get top 3 that year? Why not Brodeur? Why not Puppa(who finished 3rd) Hextall, Roy, or Hebert?

If you think Carrey and Osgood had a better case than those goalies, how? Based on what?

 

[Albatros]

I would love to hear the argument for ten goalies that is better than that at the time

Even in 1995/96 you can easily make an argument for most or all of the selection of Brodeur, Burke, Carey, Fuhr, Hasek, Hackett, Hebert, Hextall, Khabibulin, Potvin, Puppa, Richter, Roy, Vanbiesbrouck being on par or better. It's one of the few seasons when Osgood belonged in the mix, but even then he wasn't a lock for the top ten.