Cooperstown 2025

[Say Hey Kid]

1	Alex Rodriguez	4th	35.7%	390	77	22	117.5	64.3	90.9	55.4	2784	10566	2021	3115	696	2086	329	1338	.295	.380	.550	.930	140														*6*5DH/3
2	Ichiro Suzuki	1st		235	44	19	60.0	43.7	51.9	56.7	2653	9934	1420	3089	117	780	509	647	.311	.355	.402	.757	107	0	0	9.00	59	2.000	1	0	0	1.0	2	0	0	0	*9*8H7D/1
3	Manny Ramirez	9th	33.2%	226	69	19	69.3	39.9	54.6	53.4	2302	8244	1544	2574	555	1831	38	1329	.312	.411	.585	.996	154														*7*9*DH
4	7th	72.2%	175	59	17	61.8	46.6	54.2	53.4	2247	7962	1401	2519	369	1406	37	1335	.316	.414	.539	.953	133														*3H/7D9
5	2nd		163	55	21	93.5	48.7	71.1	55.8	2933	11068	1524	3166	477	1707	121	848	.286	.339	.480	.819	116														*5D/H64
6	Andy Pettitte	7th	17.0%	128	44	18	60.2	34.1	47.2	61.4	108	196	6	27	1	13	0	6	.138	.163	.184	.346	-10	256	153	3.85	117	1.351	531	521	0	3316.0	3448	288	1031	2448	*1/H
7	CC Sabathia	1st		128	48	19	62.3	39.4	50.8	61.4	48	121	7	25	3	15	0	2	.207	.220	.306	.525	38	251	161	3.74	116	1.259	561	560	0	3577.1	3404	382	1099	3093	*1/H
8	Carlos Beltrán	3rd	46.5%	126	52	20	70.1	44.4	57.3	58.1	2586	9768	1582	2725	435	1587	312	1084	.279	.350	.486	.837	119														*8*9*DH/73
9	Francisco Rodríguez	3rd	10.8%	124	16	16	24.2	17.6	20.9	32.5	437	2	0	1	0	0	0	0	.500	.500	.500	1.000	178	52	53	2.86	148	1.155	948	0	437	976.0	738	98	389	1142	*1
10	Jimmy Rollins	4th	12.9%	121	42	17	47.6	32.7	40.1	55.4	2275	9294	1421	2455	231	936	470	813	.264	.324	.418	.743	95														*6H/D4
11	Omar Vizquel	8th	19.5%	120	42	24	45.6	26.8	36.2	55.4	2968	10586	1445	2877	80	951	404	1028	.272	.336	.352	.688	82														*65H4/D379
12	Matt Holliday	2nd		110	41	15	44.5	34.3	39.4	53.4	1903	7009	1157	2096	316	1220	108	802	.299	.379	.510	.889	132														*7DH/3
13	Andruw Jones	8th	58.1%	109	34	17	62.7	46.4	54.6	58.1	2196	7599	1204	1933	434	1289	152	891	.254	.337	.486	.823	111														*89H7D/3
14	Billy Wagner	10th	68.1%	107	24	16	27.7	19.8	23.7	32.5	810	20	1	2	0	1	0	1	.100	.143	.100	.243	-35	47	40	2.31	187	0.998	853	0	422	903.0	601	82	300	1196	*1
15	Bobby Abreu	6th	15.4%	95	54	18	60.2	41.6	50.9	56.7	2425	8480	1453	2470	288	1363	400	1476	.291	.395	.475	.870	128														*9DH7/8
16	Chase Utley	2nd		94	36	16	64.5	49.3	56.9	57.0	1937	6857	1103	1885	259	1025	154	724	.275	.358	.465	.823	117														*4H3/D5
17	Dustin Pedroia	1st		94	32	14	51.9	41.0	46.5	57.0	1512	6031	922	1805	140	725	138	624	.299	.365	.439	.805	113														*4/HD6
18	2nd		92	41	15	55.2	39.0	47.1	44.2	1858	6930	1018	2123	143	923	52	939	.306	.388	.439	.827	124														*2*3*DH/9
19	Adrián González	2nd		90	31	15	43.5	34.6	39.1	53.4	1929	7139	997	2050	317	1202	6	782	.287	.358	.485	.843	129														*3HD/9
20	Bartolo Colón	2nd		88	37	21	46.2	35.5	40.9	61.4	148	299	11	25	1	11	0	1	.084	.092	.107	.199	-46	247	188	4.12	106	1.312	565	552	0	3461.2	3593	439	948	2535	*1
21	Fernando Rodney	1st		86	7	17	7.4	8.3	7.9	32.5	227	1	0	0	0	0	0	0	.000	.000	.000	.000	-100	48	71	3.80	110	1.373	951	0	327	933.0	817	73	464	943	*1
22	Brian McCann	1st		84	35	15	32.0	24.6	28.3	44.2	1755	6067	742	1590	282	1018	25	640	.262	.337	.452	.789	110														*2HD/3
23	José Bautista	2nd		78	26	15	36.7	38.2	37.5	56.7	1798	6051	1022	1496	344	975	70	1032	.247	.361	.475	.836	124														*9*5DH873/4
24	José Reyes	2nd		76	36	16	37.5	29.3	33.4	55.4	1877	7552	1180	2138	145	719	517	589	.283	.334	.427	.761	103	0	0	54.00	10	7.000	1	0	0	1.0	5	2	2	0	*654H/871
25	David Wright	2nd		74	36	14	49.2	39.5	44.3	55.8	1585	5998	949	1777	242	970	196	762	.296	.376	.491	.867	133														*5/HD6
26	Brandon Phillips	2nd		68	28	17	28.4	24.8	26.6	57.0	1902	7378	1005	2029	211	951	209	420	.275	.320	.420	.740	95														*4H/5D6
27	Ian Kinsler	1st		67	35	14	54.1	38.1	46.1	57.0	1888	7423	1243	1999	257	909	243	693	.269	.337	.440	.777	107	0	0	0.00		3.000	1	0	0	1.0	1	0	2	0	*4DH/51
28	Félix Hernández	1st		67	31	15	49.7	38.5	44.1	61.4	22	50	3	4	1	7	0	2	.080	.115	.160	.275	-24	169	136	3.42	117	1.206	419	418	0	2729.2	2487	264	805	2524	*1
29	Hanley Ramírez	1st		64	36	15	38.0	35.1	36.6	55.4	1668	6349	1049	1834	271	917	281	660	.289	.360	.486	.847	124														*6D357H
30	Víctor Martínez	2nd		63	37	16	32.0	29.0	30.5	44.2	1973	7297	914	2153	246	1178	7	730	.295	.360	.455	.815	118														*D*23H
31	Curtis Granderson	1st		61	28	16	47.2	34.7	40.9	58.1	2057	7236	1217	1800	344	937	153	924	.249	.337	.465	.803	113														*8*97HD
32	Torii Hunter	5th	6.9%	58	34	19	50.7	30.8	40.7	58.1	2372	8857	1296	2452	353	1391	195	661	.277	.331	.461	.793	110														*8*9DH/7
33	Russell Martin	1st		54	30	14	38.8	27.3	33.0	44.2	1693	5701	803	1416	191	771	101	792	.248	.349	.397	.746	101	0	0	0.00		0.500	4	0	0	4.0	2	0	0	2	*2H5/D41679
34	Mark Buehrle	5th	10.8%	52	31	16	59.1	35.8	47.4	61.4	55	125	4	9	1	3	0	2	.072	.087	.112	.199	-47	214	160	3.81	117	1.281	518	493	0	3283.1	3472	361	734	1870	*1
35	Troy Tulowitzki	1st		46	35	13	44.5	40.2	42.4	55.4	1291	4804	762	1391	225	780	57	511	.290	.361	.495	.856	118														*6/HD
36	Carlos González	1st		44	22	12	24.4	23.7	24.1	53.4	1377	5033	821	1432	234	785	122	448	.285	.343	.500	.843	112														*9*78H/D
37	Ryan Madson	2nd		41	14	13	13.5	12.6	13.0	32.5	562	49	3	6	0	2	0	2	.122	.157	.143	.300	-23	61	48	3.48	125	1.242	740	18	91	869.2	830	82	250	775	*1
38	Adam Jones	1st		36	19	14	32.6	25.7	29.2	58.1	1823	7009	963	1939	282	945	97	340	.277	.317	.454	.771	106														*89H/7D
39	Melky Cabrera	1st		30	19	15	20.6	21.2	20.9	53.4	1887	6878	895	1962	144	854	101	510	.285	.334	.417	.751	103														*7*89HD
40	James Shields	2nd		28	18	13	30.7	28.2	29.4	61.4	70	142	15	24	0	6	0	3	.169	.186	.190	.376	5	145	139	4.01	102	1.272	407	405	0	2616.0	2581	361	746	2234	*1/H
41	Mark Trumbo	1st		24	12	10	9.5	11.0	10.2	53.4	1097	4085	532	1018	218	629	23	299	.249	.302	.459	.761	108														*3*D97H/5
42	Ben Zobrist	1st		22	23	14	44.5	39.7	42.1	57.0	1651	5880	884	1566	167	768	116	832	.266	.357	.426	.783	113	0	0	0.00		2.000	1	0	0	1.0	0	0	2	1	*4*967H8/D351
43	Martín Prado	1st		21	15	14	27.7	26.7	27.2	55.8	1458	5373	664	1542	100	609	40	385	.287	.335	.412	.747	103														*547H3/69D
44	Jim Johnson	2nd		21	7	13	8.3	11.7	10.0	32.5	206	2	0	0	0	0	0	0	.000	.000	.000	.000	-100	38	46	3.79	111	1.335	674	2	178	704.2	704	54	237	531	*1
45	Yovani Gallardo	2nd		17	13	12	22.3	20.8	21.6	61.4	221	427	37	86	12	42	0	13	.201	.228	.335	.563	50	121	101	4.06	101	1.365	319	307	1	1816.2	1770	205	710	1584	*1/H
46	Brad Ziegler	2nd		17	13	11	13.3	13.0	13.1	32.5	477	7	1	1	0	0	0	0	.143	.143	.143	.286	-22	37	38	2.75	149	1.257	739	0	105	717.1	654	32	248	479	*1
47	Phil Hughes	2nd		16	9	12	11.0	13.4	12.2	61.4	32	18	0	0	0	0	0	0	.000	.000	.000	.000	-100	88	79	4.52	93	1.314	290	211	3	1291.0	1384	191	313	1040	1
48	Santiago Casilla	2nd		16	15	15	9.2	8.3	8.8	32.5	410	4	0	1	0	1	0	1	.250	.400	.250	.650	92	42	31	3.29	119	1.285	655	0	144	645.1	552	58	277	583	*1
49	Francisco Liriano	1st		15	11	14	18.1	17.6	17.8	61.4	180	218	7	34	2	15	0	9	.156	.189	.197	.387	7	112	114	4.15	99	1.359	419	300	1	1813.2	1649	184	816	1815	*1/H
50	Ian Desmond	1st		15	17	11	16.2	18.6	17.4	55.4	1478	5442	724	1432	181	711	181	387	.263	.315	.427	.742	95	0	0	0.00		1.000	1	0	0	1.0	1	0	0	0	*6837H/4D91
51	Kendrys Morales	1st		15	12	13	13.3	15.4	14.3	53.4	1363	4856	584	1289	213	740	6	417	.265	.327	.453	.780	111	0	0	4.50	146	2.000	2	0	0	2.0	1	0	3	0	*D*3H/915
52	Denard Span	2nd		14	15	11	27.9	24.8	26.3	58.1	1359	5326	773	1498	71	490	185	515	.281	.347	.398	.745	103														*879H/D
53	Mark Reynolds	1st		14	19	13	6.8	8.3	7.6	55.8	1688	5432	794	1283	298	871	64	707	.236	.328	.453	.780	103	0	0	13.50	53	2.250	2	0	0	1.1	2	0	1	0	*5*3HD/49718
54	Clay Buchholz	1st		13	13	13	16.8	20.0	18.4	61.4	29	46	0	4	0	1	0	2	.087	.125	.109	.234	-37	90	69	3.98	109	1.298	236	218	0	1332.1	1272	139	458	1024	1/H
55	Doug Fister	2nd		12	9	10	19.6	19.5	19.5	61.4	65	105	6	16	0	4	0	3	.152	.176	.181	.357	-1	83	92	3.72	109	1.257	242	226	1	1422.1	1456	140	332	970	1/H
56	Chase Headley	2nd		11	13	12	25.9	24.2	25.1	55.8	1436	5088	637	1337	130	596	93	574	.263	.342	.399	.742	106														*57H3/D4
57	Jason Vargas	1st		11	6	14	16.9	17.1	17.0	61.4	88	132	8	24	0	4	0	4	.182	.206	.205	.410	12	99	99	4.29	93	1.322	298	277	0	1643.0	1664	216	508	1147	1/H
58	Brandon Morrow	2nd		10	9	12	11.1	10.5	10.8	32.5	115	24	0	0	0	0	0	1	.000	.040	.000	.040	-88	51	43	3.96	106	1.314	334	113	40	859.0	761	88	368	877	*1
59	Chris Tillman	2nd		10	8	10	8.7	12.2	10.4	61.4	9	14	1	0	0	0	0	0	.000	.000	.000	.000	-100	74	60	4.57	91	1.378	210	205	0	1145.0	1142	164	436	847	1

Who should and should not get in?

Click to read more...

 

[Big Poppa Puck]

Who will get in:

Ichiro
Wagner
maybe Andruw Jones (if not in 2025, then he for sure will in 2026)


Who should get in but won't:

Beltran (he will eventually, probably in '26)
A-Rod
Ramriez


I think Utley may eventually get in on the back end of his eligibility.

 

[Tecumseh]

Wagner might get a bump but I can see this just being Ichiro

 

[Say Hey Kid]

1	Alex Rodriguez	4th	35.7%	390	77	22	117.5	64.3	90.9	55.4	2784	10566	2021	3115	696	2086	329	1338	.295	.380	.550	.930	140														*6*5DH/3
2	Ichiro Suzuki	1st		235	44	19	60.0	43.7	51.9	56.7	2653	9934	1420	3089	117	780	509	647	.311	.355	.402	.757	107	0	0	9.00	59	2.000	1	0	0	1.0	2	0	0	0	*9*8H7D/1
3	Manny Ramirez	9th	33.2%	226	69	19	69.3	39.9	54.6	53.4	2302	8244	1544	2574	555	1831	38	1329	.312	.411	.585	.996	154														*7*9*DH
4	7th	72.2%	175	59	17	61.8	46.6	54.2	53.4	2247	7962	1401	2519	369	1406	37	1335	.316	.414	.539	.953	133														*3H/7D9
5	2nd		163	55	21	93.5	48.7	71.1	55.8	2933	11068	1524	3166	477	1707	121	848	.286	.339	.480	.819	116														*5D/H64
6	Andy Pettitte	7th	17.0%	128	44	18	60.2	34.1	47.2	61.4	108	196	6	27	1	13	0	6	.138	.163	.184	.346	-10	256	153	3.85	117	1.351	531	521	0	3316.0	3448	288	1031	2448	*1/H
7	CC Sabathia	1st		128	48	19	62.3	39.4	50.8	61.4	48	121	7	25	3	15	0	2	.207	.220	.306	.525	38	251	161	3.74	116	1.259	561	560	0	3577.1	3404	382	1099	3093	*1/H
8	Carlos Beltrán	3rd	46.5%	126	52	20	70.1	44.4	57.3	58.1	2586	9768	1582	2725	435	1587	312	1084	.279	.350	.486	.837	119														*8*9*DH/73
9	Francisco Rodríguez	3rd	10.8%	124	16	16	24.2	17.6	20.9	32.5	437	2	0	1	0	0	0	0	.500	.500	.500	1.000	178	52	53	2.86	148	1.155	948	0	437	976.0	738	98	389	1142	*1
10	Jimmy Rollins	4th	12.9%	121	42	17	47.6	32.7	40.1	55.4	2275	9294	1421	2455	231	936	470	813	.264	.324	.418	.743	95														*6H/D4
11	Omar Vizquel	8th	19.5%	120	42	24	45.6	26.8	36.2	55.4	2968	10586	1445	2877	80	951	404	1028	.272	.336	.352	.688	82														*65H4/D379
12	Matt Holliday	2nd		110	41	15	44.5	34.3	39.4	53.4	1903	7009	1157	2096	316	1220	108	802	.299	.379	.510	.889	132														*7DH/3
13	Andruw Jones	8th	58.1%	109	34	17	62.7	46.4	54.6	58.1	2196	7599	1204	1933	434	1289	152	891	.254	.337	.486	.823	111														*89H7D/3
14	Billy Wagner	10th	68.1%	107	24	16	27.7	19.8	23.7	32.5	810	20	1	2	0	1	0	1	.100	.143	.100	.243	-35	47	40	2.31	187	0.998	853	0	422	903.0	601	82	300	1196	*1

I think those guys deserve to get in.

 

[Blitzkrug]

Wagner might get a bump but I can see this just being Ichiro

Wagner came up just a few votes short. You gotta figure he breaks through next year.

 

[Big Poppa Puck]

There's more love for CC Sabathia than I thought. I thought he might be a borderline case but it seems like a lock he's in within like his first 3 years.

Especially given that '26 and '27 are pretty light when it comes to first time eligibles. No one really in '26 and just Posey in '27. 2026 seems like it'll be Beltran's year. Maybe/Probably Jones too if he doesn't make it in '25.

 

[Say Hey Kid]

There's more love for CC Sabathia than I thought. I thought he might be a borderline case but it seems like a lock he's in within like his first 3 years. ...

Agreed. He and Pettitte are tied for 4th most deserving on my list.

 

[Say Hey Kid]

Here's how the next 5 HOF ballots look

The Hall of Fame's Class of 2024 is complete. Now the question becomes: Who's next? When the Baseball Writers' Association of America (BBWAA) revealed the results of its 2024 voting cycle on Tuesday night, three players had punched their tickets to Cooperstown: first-timers Adrián Beltré and Joe...

www.mlb.com