Speculation: Columbus Blue Jackets - All Time Team?
- Thread starter Eye of Ra
- Start date
CBJWerenski8
Formerly CBJWennberg10 (RIP Kivi)
- Jun 13, 2009
- 42,370
- 24,285
Honestly our current team would probably beat our all time team
I know there are a lot of players on our current team who I would rather have.
Honestly our current team would probably beat our all time team
True. And our top two centers in franchise history might be Johansen and Dubinsky.
candyman82
Registered User
Double-Shift Lasse
Just post better
Is this "all-time" meaning we get the players in their prime? Or all-time as in we get the players at the level they played when in Columbus? (e.g. do we get Columbus Adam Foote or Colorado Adam Foote?)
Last edited:
Chimera and Denis - there are better options, IMO, for them. If you are using current roster players, as you did with Johnson, RJ, and Bob, then your list is all jacked up.
Cassels should be in there. With current roster players there is no way Methot is in there and I'd argue there is no place for Hejda
Cassels should be in there. With current roster players there is no way Methot is in there and I'd argue there is no place for Hejda
theD86
Winging it
Sore Loser
Sorest of them all
Sure
Rick Nash-Ryan Johansen-Ray Whitney
Geoff Sanderson-Brandon Dubinsky-David Vyborny
RJ Umberger-Andrew Cassels-Nathan Horton
Kristian Huselius-Sergei Fedorov-Jeff ******
Espen Knutsen (HM)
Jack Johnson-Adam Foote
Fedor Tyutin-James Wisniewski
Jaroslav Spacek-Jan Hejda
Marc Methot (HM)
Sergei Bobrovsky
Steve Mason
Ron Tugnutt (HM)
Are you basing that on their play in a CBJ uniform or just their overall performance as a player? E.g. Horton hasn't done anything to warrant him being a top 9 forward in CBJ history. So it seems you are basing that on his play as a Bruin/Panther more so than his contributions for Columbus. Which is the problem with "all-time" teams. Is it based on the player that he was in Columbus or his entire career in the NHL? Because surely Federov had a better than Dubinsky has put together, no?
I think Brassard should be included. 5th most points all time for the Blue Jackets, one ahead of Geoff Sanderson.
Wisnutsen21
Registered User
One of my Xbox franchise teams:
Rick Nash - Ryan Johansen - Ray Whitney
Nathan Horton - Espen Knutsen - Vinny Prospal
Geoff Sanderson - Sergei Fedorov - Marian Gaborik
Jody Shelley - Brandon Dubinsky - Nick Foligno
Jack Johnson - James Wisniewski
Fedor Tyutin - Ryan Murray
Bryan Berard - Ole-kristian Tollefsen
Sergei Bobrovski
Ron Tugnutt
Rick Nash - Ryan Johansen - Ray Whitney
Nathan Horton - Espen Knutsen - Vinny Prospal
Geoff Sanderson - Sergei Fedorov - Marian Gaborik
Jody Shelley - Brandon Dubinsky - Nick Foligno
Jack Johnson - James Wisniewski
Fedor Tyutin - Ryan Murray
Bryan Berard - Ole-kristian Tollefsen
Sergei Bobrovski
Ron Tugnutt
Eye of Ra
Grandmaster General of the International boards
Sore Loser
Sorest of them all
The question was "How well would this team fare today?" ... I iced what I felt would be the best lineup if each player played up to their full potential. If I made a "CBJ All-time Roster" based on how guys performed here, it would be dominated by one year wonders like Grant Glitsome and Steve Heinze.
Robert
Foligno family
Nor was Gaborik, Foote, Fedorov, Sydor, Filatov, Zhedev or many others I guess... Carter looks pretty smart being one game from winning the Cup as of today...
Tugger should be the #1 all-time goal tender.. (as of today)
Last edited:
