Value of: Chicago Calgary

[RasmusAndersson]

To CHI:
LD Noah Hanifin
Conditional 2020 2nd (if Gustafsson resigns)
W Austin Czarnik


To CGY:
LD Erik Gustafsson
W Brandon Saad

Click to read more...

 

[Toby Flenderson]

The value seems fair, but I don’t see the Flames biting at all.

I just don’t think they’re in the market for Saad. They need more right-shot talent in the lineup IMO.

If they are going to dangle Hanifin in a trade (which I don’t think they should), they’d probably call Anaheim for Rakell.

 

[YP44]

Calgary should be upgrading their Defense. Thought this before injuries and now especially do.

 

[thesaadfather]

I mean, I’d do it. Hawks would most likely need to ship out one of Maatta, Keith, or De Haan in a separate deal though.

 

[HawkeyTalkMan]

I mean, I’d do it. Hawks would most likely need to ship out one of Maatta, Keith, or De Haan in a separate deal though.

I'm sure they could move Maatta for some measly return, but if worse comes to worse, Maatta's buyout is peanuts

 

[Bond]

Don't need another LS LW on the Flames.

 

[Mrfenn92]

With Brodie and Hamonic both unrestricted, I just can't see why Calgary would move hanifin.

 

[RasmusAndersson]

If I’m the Flames I’m interested in adding more offense from the blue line and finding the right partner for Rasmus Anderson. I think Gustafsson-Rasmus would be a really solid second pair, and I’m not that high on Hanifin. Also I think Saad and his 25 goals and solid two way play would be a great as a winger alongside Johnny and Money

 

[Wayne Primeau]

Flames say no.

 

[CraigsList]

What? Why? Makes no damn sense.

 

[RasmusAndersson]

Erik Gustafsson is one season removed from getting 60 pts and we have no defenseman putting up any offense this year. I see no reason we couldn’t resign him too, and he could be a great partner for Rasmus. Hanifin is younger and bigger and signed longer term, but Gustafsson is better offensively and Saad more than makes up the difference.

 

[Tkachuk Norris]

Hanifin is showing his potential since Gio went down. Guy is 6’3 and skates as well as any D in the game. Guy can become one of the best D in the league if he can play like this consistently.

Would take a stud young RW or RD to trade him

 

[FameFlame069]

I wouldn't do this... no thanks

 

[super6646]

We need a right shot top 6 winger or centre... ffs lol.

Saad is good, but he'd be our 3rd best LW. Don't see a fit. Hanifin also looking a lot better without Hammer as of late.

 

[MakeCgyGreatAgain]

I really question if you are a Flames fan.

 

[Ledge And Dairy]

Gus is a UFA and Saad has 1 year left on his contract Hanifin is a 23 year old with massive potential thats just blooming now. Hawks take this and run. This is horrid for Calgary

 

[RasmusAndersson]

Crazy how Flames fans overrate Hanifin. Are you watching these games? Last night again completely cost us the Kings 2nd goal and looked lost. He’s played 377 career games and has limited offensive upside, not to mention the defensive mistakes that happen every game. When are people gonna realize he’s a career 2nd pairing dman? He’s not just gonna all of a sudden become a 50 point great 2 way guy. Saad is a quality 2 way winger and Gustafsson although a rental scored 60 points last year and we could very likely resign him to play w our abundance of Swedish D. More than Hanifin could ever dream of

 

[FameFlame069]

Crazy how Flames fans overrate Hanifin. Are you watching these games? Last night again completely cost us the Kings 2nd goal and looked lost. He’s played 377 career games and has limited offensive upside, not to mention the defensive mistakes that happen every game. When are people gonna realize he’s a career 2nd pairing dman? He’s not just gonna all of a sudden become a 50 point great 2 way guy. Saad is a quality 2 way winger and Gustafsson although a rental scored 60 points last year and we could very likely resign him to play w our abundance of Swedish D. More than Hanifin could ever dream of

I think you're the only one who wants to trade Hanifin because you wish we would have kept Hamilton

 

[Mrfenn92]

Crazy how Flames fans overrate Hanifin. Are you watching these games? Last night again completely cost us the
Kings 2nd goal and looked lost. He’s played 377 career games and has limited offensive upside, not to mention the defensive mistakes that happen every game. When are
people gonna realize he’s a career 2nd pairing dman? He’s not just gonna all of a sudden become a 50 point great 2 way guy. Saad is a
quality 2 way winger and Gustafsson although a rental scored 60 points last year and we could very likely
resign him to play w our abundance of Swedish D. More than Hanifin could ever dream of

I'm not going to comment on what hanifin is or isn't, or the trade value.
But if your complaining about a dman not playing good defense then I don't know how you will like watching Gustafsson in the d zone.

 

[Esq]

Easy yes from Hawks.

 

[treple13]

I think you're the only one who wants to trade Hanifin because you wish we would have kept Hamilton

Which is just weird, because Hanafin's weaknesses are very similar to the weaknesses Hamilton had, especially at a younger age.

 

[FameFlame069]

Which is just weird, because Hanafin's weaknesses are very similar to the weaknesses Hamilton had, especially at a younger age.

Yeah well i still think we're hanging onto him,i think Kylington might be moved for a rhs top 6 forward

 

[Bounces R Way]

Any winger the Flames look to acquire needs to check Yes in the following boxes before even being considered:

Does he shoot right?	Y	N
Does he shoot good?	Y	N

[TBODY] [/TBODY]

Saadly Brandon only checks one.

 

[treple13]

Yeah well i still think we're hanging onto him,i think Kylington might be moved for a rhs top 6 forward

Wasn't saying get rid of. Just saying I don't see why Hanafin couldn't have a similar career arc to Hamilton

 

[Tkachuk Norris]

Crazy how Flames fans overrate Hanifin. Are you watching these games? Last night again completely cost us the Kings 2nd goal and looked lost. He’s played 377 career games and has limited offensive upside, not to mention the defensive mistakes that happen every game. When are people gonna realize he’s a career 2nd pairing dman? He’s not just gonna all of a sudden become a 50 point great 2 way guy. Saad is a quality 2 way winger and Gustafsson although a rental scored 60 points last year and we could very likely resign him to play w our abundance of Swedish D. More than Hanifin could ever dream of

Our fan base said the same thing about Dougie, Jay Bo, etc. Look at how those turned out for us...