Chabot VS Rielly

[IPS]

Karlsson is 2x better defensively than Rielly is. Not to mention he put up far more points than Rielly, while playing with far worse players. Stupid comparison and backwards logic from two bias fans here.

Karlsson was garbage defensively on a garbage Sens team. Wasn't even comparing them to begin with, boy did this come off as insecure.

 

[Cleatus]

Karlsson is 2x better defensively than Rielly is. Not to mention he put up far more points than Rielly, while playing with far worse players. Stupid comparison and backwards logic from two bias fans here.

2x better eh? I wonder what kind of unbiased thought process got you to come to that conclusion.

 

[LivingRentFree]

Karlsson was and probably still is putrid defensively no matter how you slice it. Guy gets danced every game.

 

[Erik Alfredsson]

Karlsson was garbage defensively on a garbage Sens team. Wasn't even comparing them to begin with, boy did this come off as insecure.

Not going to waste my time trying to convince you that Karlsson was better than Rielly. It's like teaching Stevie Wonder how to drive.

2x better eh? I wonder what kind of unbiased thought process got you to come to that conclusion.

It's called watching other teams besides the Leafs.

 

[Cleatus]

Not going to waste my time trying to convince you that Karlsson was better than Rielly. It's like teaching Stevie Wonder how to drive.



It's called watching other teams besides the Leafs.

Oh right, Sens games haven't been worth watching in a long time, so you must have a lot of time to watch other teams play, and therefore, know better than most about what makes a d-man good defensively.

Enjoy the season.

 

[Erik Alfredsson]

Oh right, Sens games haven't been worth watching in a long time, so you must have a lot of time to watch other teams play, and therefore, know better than most about what makes a d-man good defensively.

Enjoy the season.

Lol, you can chirp when you make it out of the first round, okay buddy?

 

[IPS]

Lol, you can chirp when you make it out of the first round, okay buddy?

And you can chirp when that garbage Senators organization has any semblance of hope towards doing something.

 

[Erik Alfredsson]

And you can chirp when that garbage Senators organization has any semblance of hope towards doing something.

Dude your posts read like they were written by somebody who just did an 100m sprint in a 90m gym.

 

[Cleatus]

Lol, you can chirp when you make it out of the first round, okay buddy?

Such an original comeback. You're gonna have a lot of fun watching Karlsson and Hughes tear it up on other teams for years to come.

 

[Rhaegar Targaryen]

Such an original comeback. You're gonna have a lot of fun watching Karlsson and Hughes tear it up on other teams for years to come.

Do people still not realize how low the chances are that the Sens give up the Hughes pick, even if they finish last?

 

[Semantics]

Do people still not realize how low the chances are that the Sens give up the Hughes pick, even if they finish last?

Well, it's really fortunate for the Avs then that this year is a 1a/1b type situation with Kakko. 35% chance of getting one of the two if the Sens finish last.

 

[LEAFANFORLIFE23]

Rielly is tied for the NHL lead in scoring there should not be a single vote for Chabot yet 41 people have chosen to be wrong

 

[bert]

this is the new Rielly looked better than Keith at the same age

Not at all, Keith was a late bloomer situations are nothing alike. But i understand that would be hard for you to identify.

 

[bert]

You didn't answer my question?
Also just looking at basic stats. Rielly faced top 10 hardest minutes last year and had positive possession numbers.

Ceci had bad stats in pretty much evey category bad example.

Similar teams in similar situations right...... Anyways no one is comparing Ceci to Rielly we know Ceci is brutal and atleast some sens fans are capable of evaluating the team we cheer with some humility.

Chabot has more raw talent and skill you can see it if you watch the players. Its like comparing marner to an established forward that was out producing him in his first season. You know Marner has more creativity and skill he just wasnt better yet.

 

[bert]

Rielly is tied for the NHL lead in scoring there should not be a single vote for Chabot yet 41 people have chosen to be wrong

Hahahahaha ok man. I guess the leafs have won the Stanley Cup too 5 games into the season.

 

[Albus Dumbledore]

Similar teams in similar situations right...... Anyways no one is comparing Ceci to Rielly we know Ceci is brutal and atleast some sens fans are capable of evaluating the team we cheer with some humility.

Chabot has more raw talent and skill you can see it if you watch the players. Its like comparing marner to an established forward that was out producing him in his first season. You know Marner has more creativity and skill he just wasnt better yet.

Literally a Sens fan made the comparison to Rielly with ceci since they both play hard minutes. I havent even been comparing Chabot to Rielly, a Sens fan was saying how overrated Rielly is and how's he's a powerplay specialist. I'm a fan of Chabot he has the talent but a long way to go.

 

[Nizdizzle]

Similar teams in similar situations right...... Anyways no one is comparing Ceci to Rielly we know Ceci is brutal and atleast some sens fans are capable of evaluating the team we cheer with some humility.

Chabot has more raw talent and skill you can see it if you watch the players. Its like comparing marner to an established forward that was out producing him in his first season. You know Marner has more creativity and skill he just wasnt better yet.

Geez man, get off the high horse.

 

[Cotton]

My post history shows I'm an incredibly tough and intelligent poster that values eye tests over stupid numbers any day.

Your post history shows you are a casual fan with a weird obsession about the Leafs, you have a penchant to post stupid shit, like that Morgan Rielly is a PP specialist, lol.

 

[araisarena]

If Chabot becomes a high 40-50 point scorer I'd take him regardless of Rielly's offensive ability because Rielly isn't good defensively whatsoever. I'm kind of glad he's going beast mode on offense because it'll mask his poor defensive zone coverage. Great player nonetheless still a #1 Defenseman. Brent Burns is similar in that fashion (albeit way better track record)

 

[ReginKarlssonLehner]

Dude your posts read like they were written by somebody who just did an 100m sprint in a 90m gym.

Lmaoooooooooooooooo

 

[4thline]

My post history shows I'm an incredibly tough and intelligent poster that values eye tests over stupid numbers any day.

Dunning-Kruger: The Effect. The Man. The Post.

 

[1specter]

Why do people engage with Erik Alfredsson?

 

[BAM]

Chabot continues to fly under the radar. All I'm going to say is Rielly definitely didn't look this good when he was Chabot's age, and Chabot has much more responsibility than Rielly did too.

Rielly at 21 was the Leafs best d-man when they were going through scorched earth, he's been through exactly what Chabot is dealing with this season. Rielly put up 36 points at 21 on a team who's highest scorer was Kadri with 45 points, that's very impressive

 

[Sting]

Odd poll. Not very comparable given their ages or their teams.

Chabot is going to have a lot less to work with than Rielly in the years to come, I know that.