Congratz! I'm not sure if this is good advice but if you would prefer to work at the other company, you could contact them and tell them you have another offer but you would prefer to work with them and need to make a decision. There's probably a better way to put it.
Thank you! I'm not sure if that other company is one that I'm more interested in. I was at one point but the interview process and also just the timing of interviews has shifted my thinking a bit.
Pros for the other company:
The company is more interesting and I think has more room for growth
The work is more transferrable to other companies because it's traditional FP&A
I heard nothing about equity but if they do offer it that would be a game changer
Cons:
I'd still have to interview unless they expedite it because they like me
The hiring manager kind of talked down the role as junior for an MBA, while at the company I got an offer at they talked up the role. But I don't know if it's more junior but it just left a bad taste in my mouth.
Related to the above the other company made their projects sound very interesting, this one did too but it's more traditional FP&A so it'll be closer to what I'm doing now so might be less learning and not as interesting
Barring there being equity I think they'll pay less
It's remote and honestly remote work saves money and time but I think I'd rather work at an office, I find life more interesting that way. This other company has an office that we may go back to, but it won't be required till next year, so still not exactly office work for a while there either.
I do think this latest company has really grown on me lately and it would be a strong mental shift not to accept, especially since they have an offer and the other company doesn't.