To me, it comes down to the square pegs and round holes thing. The staff seems to be using name recognition to set positions on the power play, instead of putting players in positions to succeed based on their skills.
- Somebody has it in their heads that Slavin is a better offensive player than he actually is. He's got nice 1-on-1 moves and some nifty hands in close, but those skills aren't particularly useful as a power-play point man. To be honest, he doesn't belong on a power play at all.
- I get that Staal is a horse. I get that he does more for this team than pretty much anybody, and is probably -- outside of Aho -- our MVP. The power play, however, is the place for skill guys to have room to make skill plays. Staal is not a skill guy.
- Don't get me started about Williams. I'm not giving up on the guy, but he's closer to healthy scratch territory than first unit power play, right now.
- Svech is being treated like Zykov, a net-front presence, when he's shown us that's not the player he is. If I've been pleasantly surprised by anything this season, it's how good a passer Svech is. He showed us in the preseason, but we decided to ignore that for some reason and treat him like a shooter.
- Hamilton is not a true power play quarterback, like Faulk. He's more of a rover.
With those facts in mind, I'd like to see a first unit that includes: Hamilton (umbrella, rover), Aho (halfboards, umbrella), Svechnikov (umbrella), Ferland (deep slot), Zykov (goalline, netfront).
The second would be: Faulk (qb, point, umbrella), TT (halfboards, umbrella), Slavin/Wallmark/Rask (when healthy) (umbrella), Staal (deep slot), Williams (goalline, netfront).
If you want to swap Svech/Faulk to try to put the twin blasters together on the first unit, I'm OK with that, but I'd like to see Svech passing to people who can put the puck in the net (i.e. Ferland, Aho and Zykov) and I'd hate to see a second unit led by TT the way he's playing right now.