Can you beat this prospects line-up?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Patty Ice

Straight to the Banc
Feb 27, 2002
13,854
3,339
Not California
:sharks

Michalek-Hennessy-Bernier
Plihal-Goc-Kaspar
Joseph-Stevenson-Morris
Clowe-Mitchell-Zalesak

Ehrhoff-Murray
Carle-Spang
Maatta-Gorges

Ehelechner
Patzold
Churchill​
 

Dadof5boys

Registered User
May 25, 2003
1,596
61
Murfreesbo Tennessee
Visit site
Preds

Tim Shishkanov-Oliver Setzinger- Scott Upshall
Konstatin Glazachev-Vaclav Miedl-Alex Radulov
Libor Pivko- Simon Gamache-Brandon Segal
Nick Fugere-Denny Platonov- Darren Haydar

Ryan Suter- Shea Weber
Kevin Klein- Richard Stehlik
Kirill Safronov- Andrew Hutchinson

Brian Finley
Teemu Lassila

Extas:Janne Niskala, Alexander Sulzer,Grigory Shafigulin
 

Teemu

Caffeine Free Since 1919
Dec 3, 2002
28,752
5,227
JayzinSmith said:
Igor Radulov | Mikhail Yakubov | Pavel Vorobiev
Aleksandr Kojevnikov | Jakub Sindel | Dave Bolland
Bryan Bickell | Aleksei Ivanov | Matt Keith
Karel Hromas | Colin Fraser | Matt Ellison
-- ex: Ryan Garlock, Jari Viuhkola

Anton Babchuk | Brent Seabrook
Cam Barker | Michal Barinka
James Wisniewski | Duncan Keith
-- ex: Mitch Maunu, Dustin Byfuglien

Corey Crawford | Mike Brodeur

====================
That's a pretty good set of defensemen. :)


** Ruutu, Vandermeer, Leighton, and Anderson are all past the prospect stage.

Not a fan of Fraser? He was the best hawk at the propects camp this year.
 

NewHabsEra*

Guest
Drake1588 said:
And for Washington:

Alexander Ovechkin - Jakub Klepis - Eric Fehr
Alexander Semin - Jared Aulin - Jonas Johansson
Brooks Laich - Brian Sutherby - Boyd Gordon
Tomas Fleischmann - Mikhail Yunkov - Chris Bourque

Extra: Steve Werner, Peter Guggisberg, Pasi Salonen, Owen Fussey, Andreas Valdix

Shaone Morrisonn - Steve Eminger
Jeff Schultz - Mike Green
Nolan Yonkman - Jakub Cutta

Extra: Sami Lepisto, Oscar Hedman

Maxime Ouellet
Maxime Daigneault
Rastislav Stana

Sorry but I dont think Semin and Eminger are still considered as prospects... I could have added Komisarek and Ryder...
 

NewHabsEra*

Guest
eddy said:
I'd have Duncan Milroy in there over Bonneau. Also J.P. Cote is pretty good on D, he led Hamilton in +/- as a rookie last season with a +27, but it's hard to say who you would have to take out on D.

I think Bonneau is one of the best goons in the CHL and his skills for that type of player are nice... I think he fits well on the fourth line...
 

nomorekids

The original, baby
Feb 28, 2003
33,375
107
Nashville, TN
www.twitter.com
for a thread intended for the sole purpose of some hab-masturbation, i'm feeling a bit underwhelmed. there's some decent prospects on your roster, but nothing that really sets them above about ten other teams.
 

Chaos

And the winner is...
Sep 2, 2003
7,968
18
TX
Ott = Snott said:
I'll just dream a few years ahead and picture a Loui Eriksson and Vojtach Polak on full potential. Two Potential 1st line players, the latter draws comparisons from a poor man's Peter Forsberg, while the former of that of Milan Hedjuk. I'm just going to wish you good luck with those statements...

Think you got them mixed up...
 

NewHabsEra*

Guest
nomorekids said:
for a thread intended for the sole purpose of some hab-masturbation, i'm feeling a bit underwhelmed. there's some decent prospects on your roster, but nothing that really sets them above about ten other teams.

That statement say lot about your prospects knowledge. :)
 

Vic Rattlehead*

Guest
JayzinSmith said:
Igor Radulov | Mikhail Yakubov | Pavel Vorobiev
Aleksandr Kojevnikov | Jakub Sindel | Dave Bolland
Bryan Bickell | Aleksei Ivanov | Matt Keith
Karel Hromas | Colin Fraser | Matt Ellison
-- ex: Ryan Garlock, Jari Viuhkola

Anton Babchuk | Brent Seabrook
Cam Barker | Michal Barinka
James Wisniewski | Duncan Keith
-- ex: Mitch Maunu, Dustin Byfuglien

Corey Crawford | Mike Brodeur

====================
That's a pretty good set of defensemen. :)


** Ruutu, Vandermeer, Leighton, and Anderson are all past the prospect stage.
This may actually be the best team of prospects in the league.
 

Starsdude

Registered User
Jul 7, 2002
3,509
0
Visit site
Drake1588 said:
And for Washington:

Alexander Ovechkin - Jakub Klepis - Eric Fehr
Alexander Semin - Jared Aulin - Jonas Johansson
Brooks Laich - Brian Sutherby - Boyd Gordon
Tomas Fleischmann - Mikhail Yunkov - Chris Bourque

Extra: Steve Werner, Peter Guggisberg, Pasi Salonen, Owen Fussey, Andreas Valdix

Shaone Morrisonn - Steve Eminger
Jeff Schultz - Mike Green
Nolan Yonkman - Jakub Cutta

Extra: Sami Lepisto, Oscar Hedman

Maxime Ouellet
Maxime Daigneault
Rastislav Stana

Best from top to bottom
 

Pengunz

Registered User
Jul 22, 2004
8
0
Penguin prospects

You would be hard pressed to match this prospect list for lines!!

KOLTSOV MALKIN ANSHAKOV
MALONE KRAFT SUROVY
EAVES TALBOT FATA
MOULSON BARTSCHI OUELLET

WHITNEY WELCH
ORPIK NEMEC
BISSONNETTE FERNHOLM
SCUDERI (AND DONT FORGET ABOUT TARNSTROM & JACKMAN HEHE)

FLEURY CHIODO CARON

And there are so more that definitly are just as worthy to put in there. How about
Eric Christensen who in 2002-2003 led the WHL in scoring with 54 goals 54 assists
in just 67 games :handclap:
 

nomorekids

The original, baby
Feb 28, 2003
33,375
107
Nashville, TN
www.twitter.com
Pengunz said:
You would be hard pressed to match this prospect list for lines!!

KOLTSOV MALKIN ANSHAKOV
MALONE KRAFT SUROVY
EAVES TALBOT FATA
MOULSON BARTSCHI OUELLET

WHITNEY WELCH
ORPIK NEMEC
BISSONNETTE FERNHOLM
SCUDERI (AND DONT FORGET ABOUT TARNSTROM & JACKMAN HEHE)

FLEURY CHIODO CARON

And there are so more that definitly are just as worthy to put in there. How about
Eric Christensen who in 2002-2003 led the WHL in scoring with 54 goals 54 assists
in just 67 games :handclap:

except malone,kraft, surovy, fata, koltsov, orpik, chiodo and caron are all out of the prospect stage

that would be like if i made a nashville list and included dan hamhuis, marek zidlicky and martin erat.
 

clefty

Retrovertigo
Dec 24, 2003
18,009
3
Visit site
Drake1588 said:
And for Washington:

Alexander Ovechkin - Jakub Klepis - Eric Fehr
Alexander Semin - Jared Aulin - Jonas Johansson
Brooks Laich - Brian Sutherby - Boyd Gordon
Tomas Fleischmann - Mikhail Yunkov - Chris Bourque

Extra: Steve Werner, Peter Guggisberg, Pasi Salonen, Owen Fussey, Andreas Valdix

Shaone Morrisonn - Steve Eminger
Jeff Schultz - Mike Green
Nolan Yonkman - Jakub Cutta

Extra: Sami Lepisto, Oscar Hedman

Maxime Ouellet
Maxime Daigneault
Rastislav Stana

Eminger, Semin and Sutherby are surely past the prospect stage.
 

Pengunz

Registered User
Jul 22, 2004
8
0
nomorekids said:
except malone,kraft, surovy, fata, koltsov, orpik, chiodo and caron are all out of the prospect stage

that would be like if i made a nashville list and included dan hamhuis, marek zidlicky and martin erat.

Well lets see everyone of those players is 24 years old or younger and have spent
1 season or less in the NHL except Caron and Fata who have 2 years!! how could
you call them anything less than prospects still, especially when they are NOWHERE
near reaching their potential yet :dunno:
 

clefty

Retrovertigo
Dec 24, 2003
18,009
3
Visit site
Pengunz said:
Well lets see everyone of those players is 24 years old or younger and have spent
1 season or less in the NHL except Caron and Fata who have 2 years!! how could
you call them anything less than prospects still, especially when they are NOWHERE
near reaching their potential yet :dunno:
Look at how many games they've played, dude. They can't be considered.
 

nomorekids

The original, baby
Feb 28, 2003
33,375
107
Nashville, TN
www.twitter.com
Pengunz said:
Well lets see everyone of those players is 24 years old or younger and have spent
1 season or less in the NHL except Caron and Fata who have 2 years!! how could
you call them anything less than prospects still, especially when they are NOWHERE
near reaching their potential yet :dunno:


i'm just telling you...the guidelines you're using are contrary to those that everyone else is using. you're using players that are already regulars for the penguins.
 

Pengunz

Registered User
Jul 22, 2004
8
0
clefty said:
Eminger, Semin and Sutherby are surely past the prospect stage.

I dunno how you think these 3 players are not still prospects (still soo young drafted
in 2002) Is a player not a prospect if he is over 18???? :dunno:
 

kasper11

Registered User
Feb 27, 2002
7,674
13
New York
Visit site
NewHabsArea said:
Higgins - Plekanec - Kostitsyn

Hossa - Chipchura - Perezhogin

Lambert - Locke - Urquhart

Bonneau - Lapierre - Ferland

Hainsey O'Byrn

Korneev Archer

Korpikari Yemelin

Danis
Lindberg
Halak
Really, not all that overwhelming. No prospects on d or in goal that would make the top of any list (Hainsey seems to have regressed the past couple of years, and Dannis needs to prove himself before I consider him a top prospect). A few nice forwards, but with Perezhogin's suspension for a year, and Hossa's inabillity to make the team the past couple of seasons, there isn't much scoring depth either. On the whole, I would rate Nashville, Florida, LA, NJ, NYR pretty similar to Montreal. None have as many high level forwards, but they all have better depth elsewhere.
 

montreal

Go Habs Go
Mar 21, 2002
57,329
39,838
www.youtube.com
There's really no such thing as the top group of prospects, as it's all based on potential or upside, which in reality doesn't amount to a hill of beans. Yes there are teams with more depth then others, or teams with better top end talent then others and that will likely always be the case. What you get here goes from discussing teams prospects to a pissing match with ra ra chants of my teams better then yours. But it's fun to read some comments. :banana:
 

AvengerK

Registered User
Mar 9, 2004
1,880
0
Cal Poly, the good 1
NewHabsArea said:
Higgins - Plekanec - Kostitsyn

Hossa - Chipchura - Perezhogin

Lambert - Locke - Urquhart

Bonneau - Lapierre - Ferland

Hainsey O'Byrn

Korneev Archer

Korpikari Yemelin

Danis
Lindberg
Halak

Yeah, with Bruce Lee. Since he's not around though, Mike Tyson could beat that line up pretty well too.
 

Drake1588

UNATCO
Sponsor
Jul 2, 2002
30,083
2,431
Northern Virginia
clefty said:
Eminger, Semin and Sutherby are surely past the prospect stage.
Well, Eminger and Semin are only 20 years old, and have appeared in only 57 and 52 NHL games, respectively. Both finished the season in the AHL working on their games, honing the rough edges.

Now Brian Sutherby is 22 and he is the closest to shedding the prospect label... but on the other hand, he only played 30 games in the NHL last season, with minimal fourth-line ice time, and finished the 2003-04 season in the AHL, before he sustained a groin injury. He may be getting a little older, but he has hardly reached the level of an NHL regular yet.


If one were to remove them...

Alexander Ovechkin - Jakub Klepis - Eric Fehr
Tomas Fleischmann - Jared Aulin - Jonas Johansson
Owen Fussey - Brooks Laich - Boyd Gordon
Steve Werner - Mikhail Yunkov - Chris Bourque

Extra: Peter Guggisberg, Pasi Salonen, Andreas Valdix

Shaone Morrisonn - Mike Green
Jeff Schultz - Sami Lepisto
Nolan Yonkman - Jakub Cutta

Extra: Oscar Hedman

Maxime Ouellet
Maxime Daigneault
Rastislav Stana
 

Chartrand

Registered User
Dec 3, 2003
2,209
0
Visit site
Drake1588 said:
Well, Eminger and Semin are only 20 years old, and have appeared in only 57 and 52 NHL games, respectively. Both finished the season in the AHL working on their games, honing the rough edges.

Now Brian Sutherby is 22 and he is the closest to shedding the prospect label... but on the other hand, he only played 30 games in the NHL last season, with minimal fourth-line ice time, and finished the 2003-04 season in the AHL, before he sustained a groin injury. He may be getting a little older, but he has hardly reached the level of an NHL regular yet.

What is the cut-off for prospects anyway? Our own opinions, of HF's guidelines?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad

-->