I feel like this warrants it's own thread at this point. Three games in and I have no idea what we are trying to do in the defensive zone???
For far too many extended periods the defensive play has been a train wreck. Are we playing man to man, or we playing zone? Are we collapsing to the middle or are we aggressively attacking the puck? There is times where I feel like all 5 guys on the ice are playing a different defensive scheme. It is a complete mess.
I think I touched on this in the GDT, but honestly I'm not sure exactly what they're trying to do.
Every now and then it has looked like a modified overload, but more often it looks like some sort of hybrid man-to-man with the three lowest in the zone playing man and the two highest playing zone. Sometimes the two men high look like they're playing man as well, but I can't tell if that's intentional or if they're just playing zone poorly.
With the latter, we're getting all sorts of breakdowns. Guys playing man down low don't know when to release. Guys are getting picked off or trapped behind the play and there's no rotation in coverage. The guys playing zone are getting confused anytime there's more than two men high (and the guys low look confused as to what to do then as well). We're having trouble getting organized defensively (handing off responsibilities) once the transition phase is over and everyone has regrouped back in the zone.
Etc.
It's just super inconsistent in how it's being executed, whatever it is. IMO, there's altogether just too much thinking about who should be taking who when and where. So it looks like trash.
This team has a lot of new faces, and a lot of young faces. I think it would be for the best if they just simplified things defensively, then threw in a few wrinkles once everyone was clearly on the same page. This is a talented group. Make it easy for them to play the game and let them get the job done from there.