Big Phil said:
Personally I said Bure. He actuallt LED his team to a Cup final appearane and had 34 points in the playoffs that year. Neely never did that to Bure's extent. Neely gets really overrated on these boards IMO. Bure won major awards when Neely didnt.
You're right, Phil, Neely never led his team to A finals appearance. He led his team to two finals appearances. Neely was a critical part of Boston reaching the Cup final in 1988 and 1990. His play against Montreal was a big reason the Bruins beat the Habs in 1988, the first time Boston had beaten Montreal in an eternity. His 1990 play was some of the best of his career, surprassed only by 1991, when he scored 16 goals - one off the playoff record - in 19 games.
Plus, let's not forget that the true MVP in the Canucks' 1994 Cup run was Kirk McLean. The Canucks don't go anywhere without his heroics throughout the series vs. Calgary. And for my money, Trevor Linden was a much more valuable all-round contributor to the Canucks' success throughout the playoffs than Bure. Bure was dominant against Dallas, but inconsistent and at time invisible in the other three series.
Plus, Neely never pulled a Houdini disappearing act in the playoffs like Bure did in 1992, 1993 or especially 2000.