Bryce Harper or Aaron Judge

[BigBadBruins7708]

I think Aaron Judge is my first overall pick in baseball. Everything about him is top notch and just getting started.

you can make a valid argument for any of Judge, Betts and Trout there.

but overall, yeah Judge > Harper

 

[AtlantaWhaler]

you can make a valid argument for any of Judge, Betts and Trout there.

but overall, yeah Judge > Harper

I realize my homer goggles are on tight here, but I'd rather have Acuna even though he's only had one season.

 

[GIN ANTONIC]

I realize my homer goggles are on tight here, but I'd rather have Acuna even though he's only had one season.

Not an unreasonable position. Soto also. They obviously don’t have the track record only being rookies last year but they could easily be better than Harper going forward

 

[BigBadBruins7708]

I realize my homer goggles are on tight here, but I'd rather have Acuna even though he's only had one season.

yeah, that's more than fair. he's younger and cheaper than the other 3.

I think he's on the cusp of that group, just needs to take the expected next step this year and enter the MVP race.

 

[Newsworthy]

Give me Judge.

 

[OilersTheNorth9729]

Judge all the way...