I'd lose Pederson and include Thornton, i might even play him between Looch and Cam, just because that line is completely unstoppable physically. Oates would be great feeding Nifty and Cashman. I'd lose Gonchar and bring in my personal binky, Johnny Mantruck. He was an underrated PKer (one of the best i've ever seen at firing a puck around the corners and actually getting it out) and obviously a great hitter.
PP1
Espo/Cam/Middleton/Oates
Orr
Espo and Cam in front, Oates on the half wall, Nifty freelancing/bumper. Orr at the point
PP2
Bergy/Marchand/Thornton/Pasta
Bourque
PK1
Bergy/Marchand
Chara/Orr
PK2
Kasper/Whoever
Bourque/Park
Imagine how much fun Looch, Cam, O'Reilly and Cashman would have knowing those guys are going to be killing off the penalties.