MessRich11*
Guest
For Rangers fans, remember back in 96, when Neil Smith could've traded Alex Kovalev and 2 draft picks (Dan Cloutier and Christian Dube) for Brendan Shanahan? Do you think he should've followed through with that?
What did the Rangers get when they traded him to Pittsburgh? He was traded, right?
Shanny signed as a FA with NY and then signed as a FA with the Devils. The Rangers never traded for him or traded him.
Also, Shanny never played for the Pens.
Kovalev? Smith traded him in November 98 for Petr Nedved. Didn't help the Rangers make the playoffs though.
Yes I meant Kovalev. Guess the "he" was too vague. And given what he was traded for, yeah that first trade would have obviously been worth it. I still don't know if they would have been a playoff team all those years - their defense and goaltending were in shambles after beukeboom and richter got hurt.
The question gets to if Shanahan went to New York in 1996, does Detroit win a Cup in 1997? I've often said that adding Shanahan was the final piece to Detroit's Cup hopes. Wonder if they win it all in 1997 without him.
Do you think Shanahan could've been the missing piece for the Rangers in 1997? Especially with his goal scoring and size, that would've given the Rangers a better chance against Philly.