Holtby? NOW, there are a lot better goalies at 6.1m. Washington shouldn't expect much in return.
Actually Lehner and Holtby had identical GAA and Save % this year. And Lehner played for the Sabres.
Goalies that go from good teams to poor teams often don't fair well. Seen many Washington pumping Holtby and Grubauer, by really I can't see it. And it looks like this playoff has made their trading value even less.
Yeah I'd say you're seeing it how you want to see it, which is fine but Caps fans are going to see it differently and their position (backed by Holtby's career stats, both RS and POs) is more easily defended. You think the <2.00GAA Holtby has in this playoff after allowing a single goal has had any effect on his value AND you think that effect is negative? Certainly you are an oracle.
As for Holtby/Lehner, Holtby played 54G faced 1495Shots and had 34W.
Lehner played 53G faced 1417Shots and had 14W.
I'm sorry but contrary to your narrative the big difference here (that of Ws) was not entirely
in spite of Holtby and was, at least partially
because of Holtby.