Ivo
Registered User
Would be interesting to compare their playoffs careers too. Marchand certainly hasLet's look at the possbility of Marchand in the HHOF
Keep in mind, Kariya, Hossa, Iginla, St Louis, Recchi and Shanahan are HHOF, while Heatley, Tkachuk, Fleury, and Alfredsson are not currently HHOFers.[TBODY] [/TBODY]
Player Goal Finishes Assist finishes Point Finishes Selke finishes All-star team voting Hart Voting Marchand 4,6 5,8 5,5,6, 9,10 1,2,2,4,5 5,7,9 Kariya 4,7,9,10 3,8 3,3,4,7 - 1,1,1,2,6,7,7,8 2,8,9 Heatley 2,5,6,8,8,9 - 4,4,9 - 1,2,4,4,5 10 Tkachuk 1,6,7,7,10 - - - 2,2,3,3,4,4,5,5,6 10 Hossa 4,5,5,6 - 5,6 5,7,10 2,3,3,3,6 10 Fleury 2,6,7 6,7 6,7,8 5 2,3,3,4,7,10 5,5 Iginla 1,1,3,3 10 1,3,6,8 - 1,1,1,2,3,5,5,7,7 2,2,3,10 St. Louis 4,5 1,1,2,5,7,9 1,1,2,5,6 4, 1,2,2,2,2,3,5,6,7,8 1,3,9 Recchi 9 1,4,7,9 3,4,5,10 - 2,4,4,4,5,7,7 6,9 Alfredsson 9,9,9 8 4,7,9 4,10 2,3,4,5,7,8,9,9 5, Shanahan 5,6,6,9,10 - 8,10 - 1,1,2,3,3,4,4,4,4,6,7,9,10 9,
If you compare how Marchand has done in Hart voting, he has done better than the non-HHOF guys and behind only Kariya, Iginla, and St. Louis. Who knows what the end of the season will bring.
Marchand has been a first and second-team all-star three times. That is also better than the non-HHOF players and better than Recchi (1), Hossa (1), tied with Shanahan (3), but Kariya (4), Iginla (4), St. Louis (5). Aside from Hossa, the other HHOFers have him on longevity. How this year finishes can have an impact.
Marchand is 3rd best in Selke voting, behind Alfredsson and Hossa, but I think he will get in the top-10 again this year.
Offensively, Marchand is probably the weakest, but he is having a great year this year and will make a big difference.
If Marchand had to retire tomorrow, he isn’t in the HHOF IMO. If Marchand was liked like Hossa was, he most likely gets in. However, since he is hated, it would be easy to put him in with Heatley, Tkachuk, Alfredsson, and Fleury. His peak is better than these players, but behind in longevity to Tkachuk, Alfredsson, and Fleury IMO.
Nevertheless, a strong finish this season gets him in the HHOF conversation. Another elite season would seal it IMO reputation be damned!
a more substantial playoff resume than the non-HoF players (maybe Alfredsson is comparable, but without a cup and I think Alfredsson will make the Hall eventually). Of the HoF guys, only Recchi, Hossa and Shanahan have a playoff advantage over Marchand.