Blockbuster Proposal

[Lindys Lazy Eye]

So. I check my league today and I see this fine proposal:

I would get: Tavares, Moulson, Backes, Mike Green, Shattenkirk

I would trade: Malkin, Parise, Purcell, Hamhuis, Streit

Do I accept or pass here?

Click to read more...

 

[LT]

What are the scoring stats in your league?

 

[Lindys Lazy Eye]

what are the scoring stats in your league?

g
a
p
+/-
pim
ppp
shp
sog
fw
hit
gs
w
l
gaa
sv
sv%
sho

 

[c4rdsh4rk]

whether or not it is keeper or annual draft .. accept the offer

 

[LT]

It's honestly fairly even. You're getting the better fantasy defenders for a downgrade in forwards, although if you can add two centers for one, I'd do with it.

Unless you just have a personal preference for the players you have now, I'd take the deal.

 

[McHortton]

do it

 

[njdevilfan2005]

I would accept that trade. Lots of good potential with what you will get

 

[I Am Ziggy Palffy]

You might be getting better value, but only slightly.

Tavares might come close to matching Malkin and Moulson might match Parise. You're getting stronger on D, but Streit is no throw in. He should be solid in PHI.

 

[junyab]

So. I check my league today and I see this fine proposal:

I would get: Tavares, Moulson, Backes, Mike Green, Shattenkirk

I would trade: Malkin, Parise, Purcell, Hamhuis, Streit

Do I accept or pass here?

Malkin > Tavares
Parise > Moulson
Purcell < Backes
Hamhuis = Green
Streit < Shattenkirk

I'd pass...on the basis of him getting the best of the first two comparisons.

 

[Lindys Lazy Eye]

I'm thinking about sending a counter-offer. Losing both Malkin and Parise is what's making me hesitate. Counter offer looks like:

Tavares, Backes, Mike Green, Shattenkirk

For Giroux, Purcell, Hamhuis, Streit