Yes, the responsibility is ultimately Michael Barnett's, or Wayne Gretzky if you think Barnett is just a puppet. But the blame (or credit if he turns out) should not be focused squarely on them. Dave Draper and Vaughn Karpan have the most influential voices when it comes to draft matters. They are the ones putting their reputations on the line. They are the ones trying to convince Gretzky and Barnett to draft a high school junior. While Barnett scouted the International Tournaments well, I doubt he saw Wheeler play a lot. You know Gretzky did not see him. This was a collective decision and right or wrong, it sounds like all in the organization were comfortable taking him at 5.
===================
"This young man has a tremendous upside," Gretzky said. "We took a bit of a risk, but we’re very comfortable picking him (at No. 5). He’s a tremendous athlete.’’
"We didn’t want to risk moving down and not get him. We have good information that says he wouldn’t have lasted,’’ Coyotes general manager Mike Barnett said. "We were striving to find someone we project as an impact player. The more we looked at Blake Wheeler, the more our scouts felt he could have the biggest impact.’’
"The kid is going to be a star,’’ Draper said. "Sometimes you have to pay a higher price than you’d like or what people would think, but we think we have a real gem and a guy who will play in the NHL for a long time.’’
East Valley Trib
In addition, scouts at the draft reportedly used the words "amazed" and "floored" to describe their reactions to the pick.
Coyotes General Manager Mike Barnett shrugged off the doubts and criticisms.
"That's not a concern," Barnett said. "You've got to believe in what your scouts present to you.
"We feel strongly that as committed and convicted as they were to Blake Wheeler, it certainly wouldn't be wise for us to go against their decision when they've put in hundreds and hundreds of hours to arrive at this player."
"We think we've got a real gem," said Dave Draper, vice president of scouting and director of player personnel. "This guy's going to play in the National Hockey League for a long time."
Arizona Republic