Better dman: TJ Brodie vs Ryan Ellis

[stl76]

This came up in a trade thread and I'm curious what others think.

Question is straight forward: who is a better defenseman, TJ Brodie or Ryan Ellis?

Click to read more...

 

[VoluntaryDom]

ellis had a down year but its still him easily, brodie has shown nothing to me when away from gio

 

[stl76]

ellis had a down year but its still him easily, brodie has shown nothing to me when away from gio

Ironically, I completely agree with you but 100% thought it was you disagreeing with me in the trade board thread.

Value of: - Nashville-Calgary blockbuster

Go figure.

 

[VoluntaryDom]

Ironically, I completely agree with you but 100% thought it was you disagreeing with me in the trade board thread.

Value of: - Nashville-Calgary blockbuster

Go figure.

oh @DominikBokkFan is my web pal, (s)hes a flames/brodie/elias lindholm homer

 

[tony d]

I actually went with Brodie. Both are very good though, surprised it's this lopsided.

 

[Bjornar Moxnes]

oh @DominikBokkFan is my web pal, hes a flames/brodie/elias lindholm homer

Not so much Brodie homer anymore, I still feel it's a tossup based on needs in regards to him and Ellis, however Lindholm is awesome.

 

[ijuka]

Brodie. Ellis is vastly overrated right now IMO, his contract will be a disaster.