Which of these players was a better all-time player? I pick Lindsay. This was an extremely tough choice to make, since both are extremely great players and are so much different in terms of what they bring to the table. I guess it is just a matter of personal preference. I guess that I would rather have Lindsay, and his greatly superior overall game, to Jagr and his somewhat very gifted yet enigmatic play. I just think that Lindsay would perhaps help a team win more games in crucial times (playoffs, overtimes, etc.) than Jagr would. But that is only my opinion. Who do you pick though?