Kritty said:
Toskala could be an NHL starter for any team? You have to be kidding. There are maybe a handful of teams that he could start for. He's a solid goalie but has to do alot more before a comment like that can be true.
You seem awful high on alot of these Sharks goalies that don't seem to be that great of prospects to be. Ehelechner and Patzold have to do alot of growing before they're NHL starter material. Good potential but nothing proven yet. Who is this Churchill? I've never even heard of the guy. As for the sleepers, they are just that, sleepers. I would be quite surprised if any panned out to be anything more than backups.
Toskala is the best goalie that has come through the Sharks, better than Kipper and Nabokov. Nabokov has an edge over him only because Toskala doesn't have as much NHL experince as Nabokov otherwise Toskala would be playing.
Ehelechner and Patzold both are highly touted prospects by Strelow and Thomas, both have carried their respective teams farther than they deserved to go and that is one of the most important signs of a good goalie. Plus they are technically sound just need to work on a few things.
Chruchill was picked up this year and supposed to be the type of goalie who will get to the NHL if you just let me refine his game. He was considered one of the better goalies in this years draft.
The sleepers were just that sleepers I just put them in the list so people would notice them and pay attention to some of these guys.
A lot of Sharks prospect are underrated because they aren't popular picks almost all these guys are playing for unknown teams so people just assume that they aren't any good. Why was Kipper a highly touted from within the org while everyone considered him a Euro league guy at best? Why was Morris a surprise pick? Because the Sharks scouts do their homework and pick players by what they should be able to provide and not by what the most popular rankings service recommends.
I am not saying that the Sharks prospects are perfect or the scouting staff is perfect, just that they are underrated because of which people don't view Sharks prospects the same as other more popular choices.