Discussion in 'Polls - (hockey-related only)' started by Hahahax, Oct 8, 2018.
I’m taking Nate. He carried the avs HARD last season.
Both a great players, but I go with Mack
I'm going with MacK. It's close though. So close that there are days where if I were the Avs I would have taken Barkov 1st. Truly and incredible draft at the top end.
MacKinnon, he is just too good offensively.
Up until last season it was Barkov easily. But if MacKinnon produces him by only 10 points this season I take Barkov.
Best overall isn't always best player for you team. To me Barkov is near the top of the list for best overall player. - A player good-great at everything, all over the rink. If I'm taking one of them for my team, I want Mackinnon because his style of play is where the NHL has been trending to with the speed and skill game. He's a beast on the rink and wants the puck, at all times. Different players and I don't think the poll should be on overall, unless you're jut using an overall ranking.
Went with MacKinnon.
Barkov is very good but overrated on hf and underrated by the average fan
Matthews is overrated even though he's very good. MacKinnon is only overrated when he is compared to Barkov.
MacKinnon by a hair
It surprises me a 23 year old Center can score 97 points in 73 games and be this underrated.
I usually go offense over defense went Mackinnon
Separate names with a comma.