Best Goalie fighter ever?

[Steelhead16]

I think most of the support comes from the fact that he beat the snot out of any goalie he's ever fought, and he beat up enforcers in the minors, while not being afraid to drop the gloves with pretty much anyone. The Peters fight in the NHL was kinda silly as it just looked like Emery wasn't really fighting. He was smiling and leaning back. He didn't get caught with many good shots if any in that tussle, but it looked as though he couldn't reach Peters cuz of the goalie equipment.

I think Emery would lay a beating on any of the other goalies mentioned in this thread.

5 official OHL fights. (4) goalies (Craig Anderson twice, Andrew Penner, Andy Chiodo) and the only enforcer Sean McMorrow.

 

[Sybil227]

They showed it today on FSNW - but I don't have a video of it. Ron Hextall going after Chris Chelios. After beating Chelios to the ice (I don't know if he landed a punch, but Chelios was down), the refs separate them. While they're leading Chelios away, Hextall throws a pad or blocker at Chelios.

 

[straka91*]

Hextall would rip emry apart. Why does this guy get credit for being peters punching bag? Hextall went after forwards on a daily basis.

Peters was decent for the 1st couple of seasons. Dropped Brashear.

 

[diligent_d]

Billy Smith. The guy was both nasty and fearless.

 

[moog35]

not the best fighting goalie but Steve Sheilds was pretty tough, he had a good tilt with Burke and fought Snow to