- Jan 22, 2007
- 14,400
- 7,077
j,
I should have included Terry on the list. Huge oversight on my part. Not that I think he was the baddest dude ever, but he certainly warrants a top spot. I voted Twist over Probert and Brown. When Twist was in his hayday, his knockout punch rivaled Kocur and he was more feared than anyone I could remember. Dudes just did not want to fight him at all costs.
Were Schultz and Williams THAT tough? Seems to me they get extra credit for just being the most frequent fighters.
I think there needs to be a distinction made between enforcer and fighter. This would separate the Clark Gillies' from the Dave Schulz's. Schultz was a fighter not an enforcer. Gillies was an enforcer, not a fighter. The difference? Enforcers do not fight as much as the fighters. They contribute more to the team than just riding shotgun. Their reputation is such that their presence on the ice/game is enough to keep things under control. The mere threat of having to deal with the enforcer has an effect on its own. The first player to come to mind for me was Larry Robinson. He was an enforcer. He fought his fair share of fights early in his career. After he pounded Schultz to a pulp he wasn't challenged as much. His mere presence in the game was enough to stop other players from taking cheap shots at Lafleur, Shutt, etc...I would make similar arguments for Gillies, O'Reilly, Probert and Wendel Clark to name a few. Thoughts?
I think there needs to be a distinction made between enforcer and fighter. This would separate the Clark Gillies' from the Dave Schulz's. Schultz was a fighter not an enforcer. Gillies was an enforcer, not a fighter. The difference? Enforcers do not fight as much as the fighters. They contribute more to the team than just riding shotgun. Their reputation is such that their presence on the ice/game is enough to keep things under control. The mere threat of having to deal with the enforcer has an effect on its own. The first player to come to mind for me was Larry Robinson. He was an enforcer. He fought his fair share of fights early in his career. After he pounded Schultz to a pulp he wasn't challenged as much. His mere presence in the game was enough to stop other players from taking cheap shots at Lafleur, Shutt, etc...I would make similar arguments for Gillies, O'Reilly, Probert and Wendel Clark to name a few. Thoughts?
there is not enough Tony Twist in this thread. He was the most feared fighter I have ever seen.