Award & All-Star Voting (1912-present)

[tarheelhockey]

This thread is an index of NHL (and other historic leagues) award and all-star voting. Click-through to reference a particular season's post.

table missing

NHL (and predecessor leagues: ECAHA, NHA):

Other historic leagues:

Manitoba Professional Hockey League: 1906-1907

PCHA: 1911-1912, 1912-1913, 1913-1914, 1914-1915, 1915-1916, 1916-1917, 1917-1918, 1918-1919, 1920-1921, 1921-1922, 1922-1923, 1923-1924

WHL/WCHA: 1921-1922, 1922-1923, 1923-1924, 1924-1925, 1925-1926

For international and European award and all-star voting, see this thread.

Special thanks to HF user BM67, who compiled virtually all of this information in its original format.
Also thanks to user pnep for keeping us updated in the recent years.

This thread is currently closed to keep it tidy, but anyone who finds any useful information on old All-Star teams, has any questions, or wants to engage in any other form of discussion, is encouraged to use this thread.​

Click to read more...

 

[tarheelhockey]

1906-1907, Eastern Canadian Amateur Hockey Association

Ottawa Citizen All-star team (Team East):

Source: Ottawa Citizen, March 22th 1907

Player:	Pos:	Team:
Percy LeSueur	G	Ottawa HC
Harvey Pulford	Point	Ottawa HC
Hod Stuart	Cover Point	Montreal Wanderers
Lester Patrick	Rover	Montreal Wanderers
Russell Bowie	C	Montreal Victorias
Alf Smith	RW	Ottawa HC
Blair Russell	LW	Montreal Victorias

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

 

[tarheelhockey]

1906-1907, Manitoba Professional Hockey League

Ottawa Citizen All-star team (Team West):

Source: Ottawa Citizen, March 22th 1907

Player:	Pos:	Team:
Eddie Giroux	G	Kenora Thistles
Art Ross	Point	Brandon
Si Griffis	Cover Point	Kenora Thistles
Fred Whitcroft	Rover	Kenora Thistles
Joe Hall	C	Brandon
Tommy Philipps	RW	Kenora Thistles
Edgar Dey	LW	Portage

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

 

[tarheelhockey]

1907-1908, Eastern Canada Amateur Hockey Association

Ottawa Free Press All-star team:

Source: Quebec Daily Telegraph, February 21th 1908 (p.7)

Player:	Pos:	Team:
Paddy Moran	G	Quebec HC
Fred 'Cyclone' Taylor	Point	Ottawa HC
Joe Power	Cover Point	Quebec HC
Russell Bowie	Rover	Montreal Victorias
Charles Power	C	Quebec HC
Alf Smith	RW	Ottawa HC
Tommy Philipps	LW	Ottawa HC

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

 

[tarheelhockey]

1911-1912, Pacific Coast Hockey Association

1) All-star team:

Source: Winnipeg Tribune, March 9th 1912 (p.21)

Player:	Pos:	Team:
Hugh Lehman	G	New Westminster Royals
Frank Patrick	Point	Vancouver Millionaires
Ernie 'Moose' Johnson	Cover Point	New Westminster Royals
Lester Patrick	Rover	Victoria Senators
Newsy Lalonde	C	Vancouver Millionaires
Harry Hyland	RW	New Westminster Royals
Jimmy Gardner	LW	New Westminster Royals

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

2) Differing from the above:

Source: "The Trail of the Stanley Cup", Volume 1

Player:	Pos:	Team:
Hugh Lehman	G	New Westminster Royals
Frank Patrick	D	Vancouver Millionaires
Ernie 'Moose' Johnson	D	New Westminster Royals
Tommy Dunderdale	C	Victoria Senators
Newsy Lalonde	C	Vancouver Millionaires
Harry Hyland	C	New Westminster Royals
Ran McDonald	RW	New Westminster Royals

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

 

[tarheelhockey]

1912-1913, Pacific Coast Hockey Association

All-star team:

Source: "The Trail of the Stanley Cup", Volume 1

Player:	Pos:	Team:
Bert Lindsay	G	Victoria Senators
Lester Patrick	D	Victoria Senators
Ernie 'Moose' Johnson	D	New Westminster Royals
Tommy Dunderdale	C	Victoria Senators
Ran McDonald	RW	New Westminster Royals
Smokey Harris	LW	Vancouver Millionaires

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

 

[tarheelhockey]

1913-1914, National Hockey Association

1) Ottawa Free Press All-star team:

Source: Toronto Sunday World, March 4th 1914

1st All-star team

Player:	Pos:	Team:
Georges Vézina	G	Montreal Canadiens
Horace Merrill	Point	Ottawa Senators
Sprague Cleghorn	Cover Point	Montreal Wanderers
Tommy Smith	C	Quebec Bulldogs
John Davidson	RW	Toronto Blueshirts
Jack Darragh	LW	Ottawa Senators

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

2nd All-star team:

Player:	Pos:	Team:
Percy LeSueur	G	Ottawa Senators
Harry Cameron	Point	Toronto Blueshirts
George 'Goldie' Prodgers	Cover Point	Quebec Bulldogs
Frank Foyston	C	Toronto Blueshirts
Rusty Crawford	RW	Quebec Bulldogs
Gordon Roberts	LW	Montreal Wanderers

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

3rd All-star team.

Player:	Pos:	Team:
Hap Holmes	G	Toronto Blueshirts
Fred Lake	Point	Toronto Ontarios
Eddie Shore	Cover Point	Ottawa Senators
Newsy Lalonde	C	Montreal Canadiens
Odie Cleghorn	RW	Montreal Wanderers
Jack Walker	LW	Toronto Blueshirts

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

2) Montreal Daily Mail All-star team:

Source: Montreal Daily Mail, March 4th 1914 (p.8)

Goal

#	Player:	Team:	Pts:
1.	Georges Vézina	Montreal Canadiens	21
2.	Hap Holmes	Toronto Blueshirts	3
3.	Sammy Hebert	Toronto Ontarios	2
3.	Billy Nicholson	Montreal Wanderers	2
3.	Percy LeSueur	Ottawa Senators	2
6.	P. Malone	Quebec Bulldogs	1
6.	Paddy Moran	Quebec Bulldogs	1

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

Point (D)

#	Player:	Team:	Pts:
1.	Harry Cameron	Toronto Blueshirts	12
2.	Sprague Cleghorn	Montreal Wanderers	6
3.	Art Ross	Montreal Wanderers	3
3.	Eddie Shore	Ottawa Senators	3
5.	Ernest Dubeau	Montreal Canadiens	2
5.	Harry Mummery	Quebec Bulldogs	2
7.	Horace Merrill	Ottawa Senators	1
7.	Jack Marshall	Toronto Blueshirts	1
7.	Newsy Lalonde	Montreal Canadiens	1
7.	Joe Hall	Quebec Bulldogs	1

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

Cover Point (D)

#	Player:	Team:	Pts:
1.	Sprague Cleghorn	Montreal Wanderers	10
2.	Harry Cameron	Toronto Blueshirts	5
3.	Jack Marshall	Toronto Blueshirts	4
4.	Joe Hall	Quebec Bulldogs	3
5.	Ernest Dubeau	Montreal Canadiens	2
5.	Jack Laviolette	Montreal Canadiens	2
5.	Art Ross	Montreal Wanderers	2
8.	Harry Mummery	Quebec Bulldogs	1
8.	Horace Merrill	Ottawa Senators	1
8.	Newsy Lalonde	Montreal Canadiens	1

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

Center

#	Player:	Team:	Pts:
1.	Newsy Lalonde	Montreal Canadiens	11
2.	Tommy Smith	Quebec Bulldogs	6
3.	Don Smith	Montreal Canadiens	5
3.	Joe Malone	Quebec Bulldogs	5
5.	Cully Wilson	Toronto Blueshirts	1
5.	Ernest Dubeau	Montreal Canadiens	1
5.	Jack Walker	Toronto Blueshirts	1
5.	Roy McGiffen	Toronto Blueshirts	2
5.	Jack Darragh	Ottawa Senators	1

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

Left Wing

#	Player:	Team:	Pts:
1.	Jack Darragh	Ottawa Senators	12
2.	Jack Walker	Toronto Blueshirts	10
3.	Gordon Roberts	Montreal Wanderers	3
3.	Don Smith	Montreal Canadiens	3
5.	Roy McGiffen	Toronto Blueshirts	1
5.	Newsy Lalonde	Montreal Canadiens	1
5.	Eddie Gerard	Ottawa Senators	1

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

Right Wing

#	Player:	Team:	Pts:
1.	Jack Darragh	Ottawa Senators	10
2.	Jack Walker	Toronto Blueshirts	6
3.	Jack McDonald	Toronto Ontarios	2
3.	John Davidson	Toronto Blueshirts	2
3.	Newsy Lalonde	Montreal Canadiens	1
6.	Frank Foyston	Toronto Blueshirts	1
6.	Tommy Smith	Quebec Bulldogs	1
6.	Punch Broadbent	Ottawa Senators	1
6.	George McNamara	Toronto Blueshirts	1
6.	Jack Marks	Quebec Bulldogs	1
6.	Harry Hyland	Montreal Wanderers	1
6.	Skene Ronan	Ottawa Senators	1
6.	Joe Malone	Quebec Bulldogs	1

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

Voters: 32 readers of the Daily Mail sent in ballots. Among the participants were regular fans as well as NHA goal umpire J. P. O'Loghlin.​

 

[tarheelhockey]

1913-1914, Pacific Coast Hockey Association

All-star team:

Source: Winnipeg Tribune, February 28th 1914 (p.21)

Player:	Pos:	Team:
Hugh Lehman	G	New Westminster Royals
Frank Patrick	Point	Vancouver Millionaires
Ernie 'Moose' Johnson	Cover Point	New Westminster Royals
Fred 'Cyclone' Taylor	Rover	Vancouver Millionaires
Tommy Dunderdale	C	Victoria Aristocrats
Eddie Oatman	RW	New Westminster Royals
Dubbie Kerr	LW	Victoria Aristocrats

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

 

[tarheelhockey]

1914-1915, Pacific Coast Hockey Association

All-star team:

Source: Oregon Daily Journal, February 28th 1915 (p.18)

Player:	Pos:	Team:
Hugh Lehman	G	Vancouver Millionaires
Ernie 'Moose' Johnson	RD	Portland Rosebuds
Lester Patrick	LD	Victoria Aristocrats
Fred 'Cyclone' Taylor	Rover	Vancouver Millionaires
Mickey MacKay	C	Vancouver Millionaires
Eddie Oatman	RW	Portland Rosebuds
Frank Nighbor	LW	Vancouver Millionaires
Dubbie Kerr	F, spare	Victoria Aristocrats
Charles Tobin	D, spare	Portland Rosebuds

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

 

[tarheelhockey]

1915-1916, Pacific Coast Hockey Association

1) All-star team:

Source: "The Trail of the Stanley Cup", Volume 1

1st All-star team

Player:	Pos:	Team:
Hugh Lehman	G	Vancouver Millionaires
Lester Patrick	D	Victoria Aristocrats
Ernie 'Moose' Johnson	G	Portland Rosebuds
Smokey Harris	LW	Portland Rosebuds
Bernie Morris	C/RW	Seattle Metropolitans

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

2nd All-star team

Player:	Pos:	Team:
Hap Holmes	G	Seattle Metropolitans
Lloyd Cook	D	Vancouver Millionaires
Mickey MacKay	C	Vancouver Millionaire
Ran McDonald	RW	Victoria Aristocrats

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

2) All-star team picked by Oregon Daily Journal:

Source: Oregon Daily Journal, January 16th 1916 (p.17)

Player:	Pos:	Team:
Hugh Lehman	G	Vancouver Millionaires
Lester Patrick	Point	Victoria Aristocrats
Ernie 'Moose' Johnson	Cover point	Portland Rosebuds
Frank Foyston	Rover	Seattle Metropolitans
Eddie Oatman	C	Portland Rosebuds
Charles Tobin	RW	Portland Rosebuds
Lloyd Cook	LW	Vancouver Millionaires

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

3) All-star team picked by Tommy Philipps:

Source: Ottawa Journal, February 18th 1916 (p.11)

Player:	Pos:	Team:
Hugh Lehman	G	Vancouver Millionaires
Lester Patrick	Point	Victoria Aristocrats
Ernie 'Moose' Johnson	Cover point	Portland Rosebuds
Eddie Oatman	Rover	Portland Rosebuds
Mickey MacKay	C	Vancouver Millionaire
Charles Tobin	RW	Portland Rosebuds
Jack Walker	LW	Seattle Metropolitans
Si Griffis	D, spare	Vancouver Millionaires
Lloyd Cook	F, spare	Vancouver Millionaires

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

 

[tarheelhockey]

1916-1917, Pacific Coast Hockey Association

1) All-star team:

Source: Calgary Daily Herald, February 6th 1917

Goal:

#	Player:	Team:	Pts:
1.	Hec Fowler	Spokane Canaries	2
2.	Hap Holmes	Seattle Metropolitans	1
2.	Hugh Lehman	Vancouver Millionaires	1

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

Point (D):

#	Player:	Team:	Pts:
1.	Lester Patrick	Spokane Canaries	3
2.	Frank Patrick	Vancouver Millionaires	1

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

Cover point (D):

#	Player:	Team:	Pts:
1.	Ernie 'Moose' Johnson	Portland Rosebuds	4

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

Rover:

#	Player:	Team:	Pts:
1.	Mickey MacKay	Vancouver Millionaires	2
2.	Bernie Morris	Seattle Metropolitans	1
2.	Jack Walker	Seattle Metropolitans	1

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

Center:

#	Player:	Team:	Pts:
1.	Bernie Morris	Seattle Metropolitans	2
2.	Sibby Nichols	Spokane Canaries	1
2.	Dick Irvin	Seattle Metropolitans	1

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

Right Wing:

#	Player:	Team:	Pts:
1.	Frank Foyston	Seattle Metropolitans	3
2.	Bernie Morris	Seattle Metropolitans	1

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

Left Wing:

#	Player:	Team:	Pts:
1.	Gordon Roberts	Vancouver Millionaires	4

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

Voters:
Royal Brougham (Seattle Post-Intelligencer)
A. P. Garvey (Vancouver Province)
J. S. Bain (Spokane Review)
Lou Kennedy (Portland Telegraph)​

2) Most Valuable Player:

Source: Calgary Daily Herald, March 6th 1917

#	Player:	Team:	Voting:
1.	Frank Foyston	Seattle Metropolitans	2-1
2.	Mickey MacKay	Vancouver Millionaires	1-1
3.	Bernie Morris	Seattle Metropolitans	1-0
4.	Gordon Roberts	Vancouver Millionaires	0-1
4.	Jack Walker	Vancouver Millionaires	0-1

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

Voters:
Royal Brougham (Seattle Post-Intelligencer)
A. P. Garvey (Vancouver Province)
J. S. Bain (Spokane Review)
Lou Kennedy (Portland Telegraph)​

 

[tarheelhockey]

1917-1918, Pacific Coast Hockey Association

1) All-star team:

Source: Lethbridge Herald, May 11th 1918, p.3

Player:	Pos:	Team:
Hec Fowler*	G	Portland Rosebuds
Hugh Leman*	G	Vancouver Millionaires
Tommy Murray*	G	Seattle Metropolitans
Ernie 'Moose' Johnson	D	Portland Rosebuds
Lloyd Cooke	D	Vancouver Millionaires
Mickey MacKay	Rover	Vancouver Millionaires
Fred 'Cyclone' Taylor	C	Vancouver Millionaires
Charlie Tobin	RW	Portland Rosebuds
Frank Foyston	LW	Seattle Metropolitans
Eddie Oatman	substitute	Portland Rosebuds

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

*No decision between the three goaltenders.

Voters (assumed):
Royal Brougham (Seattle Post-Intelligencer)
A. P. Garvey (Vancouver Province)
Lou Kennedy (Portland Telegraph)​

2) All-star teams picked by referee Fred 'Mickey' Ion:

Source: Toronto World, March 9th 1918

Player:	Pos:	Team:
Hugh Lehman	G	Vancouver Millionaires
Lester Patrick	Point	Vancouver Millionaires
Ernie 'Moose' Johnson	Cover Point	Portland Rosebuds
Mickey MacKay	Rover	Vancouver Millionaires
Fred 'Cyclone' Taylor	C	Vancouver Millionaires
Charlie Tobin	RW	Portland Rosebuds
Frank Foyston	LW	Seattle Metropolitans
Bernie Morris	substitute	Portland Rosebuds
Tommy Dunderdale	substitute	Portland Rosebuds

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

3) All-star team picked by referee George Irvine:

Source: Toronto World, March 9th 1918

Player:	Pos:	Team:
Hugh Leman	G	Vancouver Millionaires
Lloyd Cooke	Point	Vancouver Millionaires
Ernie 'Moose' Johnson	Cover Point	Portland Rosebuds
Mickey MacKay	Rover	Vancouver Millionaires
Fred 'Cyclone' Taylor	C	Vancouver Millionaires
Charlie Tobin	RW	Portland Rosebuds
Frank Foyston	LW	Seattle Metropolitans
Bobby Rowe	substitute	Seattle Metropolitans
Eddie Oatman	substitute	Portland Rosebuds

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

 

[tarheelhockey]

1918-1919, National Hockey League

Source: Calgary Herald (March 3rd 1919)

"The Ottawa, Toronto and Montreal press rate [Harry] Cameron as the best [player] in the game today."
​

It is unknown whether this just refers to the general consensus or an actual poll that was conducted.

 

[tarheelhockey]

1918-1919, Pacific Coast Hockey Association

All-star team:

Source: Seattle Star, March 3rd 1919 (p.12)

1st All-star team

Player:	Pos:	Team:
Hugh Leman	G	Vancouver Millionaires
Ernie 'Moose' Johnson	D	Victoria Aristocrats
Bobby Rowe	D	Seattle Metropolitans
Mickey MacKay	Rover	Vancouver Millionaires
Bernie Morris	C	Seattle Metropolitans
Charlie Tobin	RW	Portland Rosebuds
Cully Wilson	RW	Seattle Metropolitans
Smokey Harris	LW	Vancouver Millionaires

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

2nd All-star team

Player:	Pos:	Team:
Hap Holmes	G	Seattle Metropolitans
Lloyd Cook	D	Vancouver Millionaires
Art Duncan	D	Seattle Metropolitans
Jack Walker	Rover	Seattel Metropolitans
Fred 'Cyclone' Taylor	C	Vancouver Millionaires
Charlie Tobin	RW	Portland Rosebuds
Eddie Oatman	RW	Victoria Aristocrats
Frank Foyston	LW	Seattle Metropolitans

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

Previously the PCHA All-star team had been voted on by the official scorekeepers of each league city. From 1919 on, the teams were picked by referee Fred 'Mickey' Ion.

 

[tarheelhockey]

1919-1920, Pacific Coast Hockey Association

All-star team:

Source: Regina Morning Leader, March 19th 1920

1st All-star team

Player:	Pos:	Team:
Hugh Lehman	G	Vancouver Millionaires
Lloyd Cook	Point	Vancouver Millionaires
Art Duncan	Cover Point	Vancouver Millionaires
Frank Foyston*	Rover	Seattle Metropolitans
Tommy Dunderdale	C	Victoria Aristocrats
Eddie Oatman	RW	Victoria Aristocrats
Smokey Harris	LW	Vancouver Millionaires

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

*Comment by Fred 'Mickey' Ion who picked the All-star team: "I figured that while he has played centre all season that he would prove a great rover...". (Calgary Daily Herald, March 9th 1920)


2nd All-star team

Player:	Pos:	Team:
Hap Holmes	G	Seattle Metropolitans
Lester Patrick	Point	Victoria Aristocrats
Bobby Rowe	Cover Point	Seattle Metropolitans
Jack Walker	Rover	Seattle Metropolitans
Fred 'Cyclone' Taylor	C	Vancouver Millionaires
Alf Skinner	RW	Vancouver Millionaires
Jim Riley	LW	Seattle Metropolitans

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

 

[tarheelhockey]

1920-1921, Pacific Coast Hockey Association

1) All-star team:

Source: Winnipeg Free Press, March 7th 1921

All-star team

Player:	Pos:	Team:
Hugh Lehman	G	Vancouver Millionaires
Lloyd Cook	C	Vancouver Millionaires
Ernie 'Moose' Johnson	D	Victoria Aristocrats
Jack Walker	Rover	Seattle Metropolitans
Frank Fredrickson	C	Victoria Aristocrats
Jack Adams	RW	Vancouver Millionaires
Frank Foyston	LW	Seattle Metropolitans

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

2) Differering from the above:

Souce: "The Trail of the Stanley Cup", Volume 1

1st All-star team

Player:	Pos:	Team:
Hugh Lehman	G	Vancouver Millionaires
Jack Adams	C	Vancouver Millionaires
Frank Fredrickson	C	Victoria Aristocrats
Frank Foyston	C/RW	Seattle Metropolitans
Bernie Morris	LW	Seattle Metropolitans
Jack Walker	F	Seattle Metropolitans

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

2nd All-star team

Player:	Pos:	Team:
Hap Holmes	G	Seattle Metropolitans
Ernie 'Moose' Johnson	D	Victoria Aristocrats
Clem Loughlin	D	Victoria Aristocrats
Wilf Loughlin	D	Victoria Aristocrats
Mickey MacKay	C	Vancouver Millionaires
Alf Skinner	RW	Vancouver Millionaires
Jim Riley	LW	Seattle Metropolitans

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

 

[tarheelhockey]

1921-1922, Pacific Coast Hockey Assocation

All-star team:

Source: Calgary Daily Herald, February 24th 1922

1st All-star team

Player:	Pos:	Team:
Hugh Lehman*	G	Vancouver Millionaires
Hap Holmes*	G	Seattle Metropolitans
Hec Fowler*	G	Victoria Aristocrats
Art Duncan	RD	Vancouver Millionaires
Eddie Oatman	D	Victoria Aristocrats
Mickey MacKay	Rover	Vancouver Millionaires
Jack Adams	C	Vancouver Millionaires
Bernie Morris	RW	Seattle Metropolitans
Tommy Dunderdale	LW	Victoria Aristocrats
Frank Fredrickson	substitute	Victoria Aristocrats
Jack Walker	substitute	Seattle Metropolitans

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

*No decision between the three goaltenders by Fred 'Mickey' Ion. However, A. P. Garvey (Vancouver Province) ranked them as follows: 1) Lehman, 2) Holmes, 3) Fowler.

2nd All-star team

Player:	Pos:	Team:
Hap Holmes	G	Seattle Metropolitans
Ernie 'Moose' Johnson	D	Victoria Aristocrats
Clem Loughlin	RD	Victoria Aristocrats
Roy Rickey	LD	Seattle Metropolitans
Harry Meeking	Rover	Victoria Aristocrats
Frank Foyston	C	Seattle Metropolitans
Alf Skinner	RW	Vancouver Millionaires
Smokey Harris	LW	Vancouver Millionaires
Slim Halderson	substitute	Victoria Aristocrats
Jim Riley	substitute	Seattle Metropolitans

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

 

[tarheelhockey]

1921-1922, Western Canada Hockey League

1st All-star team

Player:	Pos:	Team:
Red Dutton	D	Calgary Tigers
Joe Simpson	D	Edmonton Eskimos
Duke Keats	C	Edmonton Eskimos
George Hay	LW	Regina Capitals
Barney Stanley	RW	Calgary Tigers

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

2nd All-star team

Player:	Pos:	Team:
Bill Laird	G	Regina Capitals
Bobby Trapp	D	Edmonton Eskimos
Percy Traub	D	Regina Capitals
Dick Irvin	C	Regina Capitals
Ty Arbour	LW	Edmonton Eskimos
Art Gagné	RW	Edmonton Eskimos

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

 

[tarheelhockey]

1922-1923, Pacific Coast Hockey Association

1st All-star team

Player:	Pos:	Team:
Hugh Lehman	G	Vancouver Maroons
Bobby Rowe	D	Seattle Metropolitans
Lloyd Cook	D	Vancouver Maroons
Frank Fredrickson	C	Victoria Cougars
Mickey MacKay	RW	Vancouver Maroons
Frank Foyston	LW	Seattle Metropolitans
Haldor 'Slim' Halderson	D, spare	Victoria Cougars
Frank Boucher	C, spare	Vancouver Maroons
Eddie Oatman	RW, spare	Victoria Cougars
Jim Riley	LW, spare	Seattle Metropolitans

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

2nd All-star team

Player:	Pos:	Team:
Hap Holmes	G	Seattle Metropolitans
Art Duncan	D	Vancouver Maroons
Clem Loughlin	D	Victoria Cougars
Bernie Morris	C	Seattle Metropolitans
Alf Skinner	RW	Vancouver Maroons
Harry Meeking	LW	Victoria Cougars
Gord Fraser	D, spare	Seattle Metropolitans
Corb Denneny	C, spare	Vancouver Maroons
Ernie Parkes	RW, spare	Vancouver Maroons
Archie Briden	LW, spare	Seattle Metropolitans

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

 

[tarheelhockey]

1922-1923, Western Canada Hockey League

1st All-star team

Player:	Pos:	Team:
Hal Winkler	G	Edmonton Eskimos
Herb Gardiner	D	Calgary Tigers
Bobby Trapp	D	Edmonton Eskimos
Joe Simpson	D	Edmonton Eskimos
Duke Keats	C	Edmonton Eskimos
Charley McVeigh	C/LW	Regina Capitals
Barney Stanley	RW	Regina Capitals
Art Gagné	RW	Edmonton Eskimos
George Hay	LW	Regina Capitals

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

2nd All-star team

Player:	Pos:	Team:
Bill Laird	D	Regina Capitals
Percy Traub	D	Regina Capitals

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

 

[tarheelhockey]

1923-24, National Hockey League

Hart Trophy:

Source: Montreal Gazette, March 11th 1924

#	Player:	Pos:	Team:	Pts:
1.	Frank Nighbor	C	Ottawa Senators	37
2.	Sprague Cleghorn	D	Montreal Canadiens	36
3.	John Ross Roach	G	Toronto St. Patricks	35
4.	Georges Boucher	D	Ottawa Senators	?
5.	Billy Burch	C	Hamilton Tigers	?
6.	Howie Morenz	C	Montreal Canadiens	?
7.	Jake Forbes	G	Hamilton Tigers	?
8.	Goldie Prodgers	D	Hamilton Tigers	?
9.	Cy Denneny	LW	Ottawa Senators	?
10.	Babe Dye	RW	Toronto St. Patricks	?

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

Voters:
P. Jones (Hamilton Herald)
W. MacMullen (Hamilton Spectator)
C. W. McQueen (Mail and Empire, Toronto)
R. Hewitson (The Telegram, Toronto)
Basil O'Meara (The Journal, Ottawa)
A. Laberge (La Presse, Montreal)
E. W. Ferguson (The Herald, Montreal)

 

[tarheelhockey]

1923-24, Pacific Coast Hockey Association

All-star team:

Source: Ottawa Journal, March 6th 1924 (p.12)

Player:	Pos:	Team:
Hugh Lehman	G	Vancouver Maroons
Gord Fraser	D	Seattle Metropolitans
Art Duncan	D	Vancouver Maroons
Frank Frederickson	C	Victoria Cougars
Jack Walker	W	Seattle Metropolitans
Archie Briden	W	Victoria Cougars, Seattle Metropolitans
Frank Boucher	substitute	Vancouver Maroons
Clem Loughlin	substitute	Victoria Cougars
Gizzy Hart	substitute	Victoria Cougars

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

 

[tarheelhockey]

1923-24, Western Canada Hockey League

All-star team:

Player:	Pos:	Team:
Red McCusker	G	Regina Capitals
Red Dutton	D	Calgary Tigers
Percy Traub	D	Regina Capitals
Duke Keats	C	Edmonton Eskimos
Bill Cook	F	Saskatoon Sheiks
George Hay	F	Regina Capitals
Dick Irvin	substitute	Regina Capitals
Newsy Lalonde	substitute	Saskatoon Sheiks
Harry Oliver	substitute	Calgary Tigers
Joe Simpson	substitute	Edmonton Eskimos

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

 

[tarheelhockey]

1924-1925, National Hockey League

Hart Trophy:

#	Player:	Pos:	Team:	Pts:
1.	Billy Burch	C/LW	Hamilton Tigers	79
2.	Howie Morenz	C	Montreal Canadiens	60
3.	Clint Benedict	G	Montreal Maroons	58
4.	Babe Dye	RW	Toronto St. Patricks	50
5.	Aurèle Joliat	LW	Montreal Canadiens	48
6.	Hap Day	LW	Toronto St. Patricks	44
7.	Jimmy Herbert	C	Boston Bruins	41
7.	King Clancy	D	Ottawa Senators	41
9.	Shorty Green	RW	Hamilton Tigers	28
9.	Jake Forbes	G	Hamilton Tigers	28
11.	Georges Boucher	D	Ottawa Senators	16
12.	Hooley Smith	RW	Ottawa Senators	14
13.	Frank Nighbor	C	Ottawa Senators	10
14.	Red Green	LW	Hamilton Tigers	8

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

Byng Trophy:
Awarded to Frank Nighbor (center, Ottawa Senators) by NHL president Frank Calder.

 

[tarheelhockey]

1924-1925, Western Canada Hockey League

1) All-star team:

Player:	Pos:	Team:
Hap Holmes	G	Victoria Cougars
Herb Gardiner	D	Calgary Tigers
Joe Simpson	D	Edmonton Eskimos
Bill Cook	RW	Saskatoon Sheiks
Duke Keats	C	Edmonton Eskimos
Mickey MacKay	C	Vancouver Maroons
Frank Boucher	C	Vancouver Maroons
Harry Oliver	RW	Calgary Tigers

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​

2) All-star team picked by Fred 'Mickey' Ion:

Source: The Calgary Daily Herald, March 17, 1925

Player:	Pos:	Team:
Hap Holmes	G	Victoria Cougars
Herb Gardiner	D	Calgary Tigers
Red Dutton	D	Calgary Tigers
Mickey MacKay	C	Vancouver Maroons
George Hay	LW	Regina Capitals
Bill Cook	RW	Saskatoon Sheiks
Frank Fredrickson	F, substitute	Victoria Cougars
Bob Trapp	D	Edmonton Eskimos

[TBODY] [/TBODY]
[TBODY] [/TBODY]

​