ATD championship retrospective

[Nalyd Psycho]

I like modern players because I often think of older players and how they'd work in modern times, as such, I like the idea of how they would work with modern players. I liked imagining how St. Louis and Starshinov would work together. I'd like pairing Datsyuk with Hooley Smith. I think Malkin and Charlie Conacher would be amazing. Clancy-Chara would be hilariously awesome. Cyclone Taylor and Steve Stamkos would be potent.

 

[Sturminator]

ATD Eras Over Time:

- allright, here is the data broken down into 10 year segments

- many players span two eras. I have simply placed them arbitrarily in one era or the other based on my own rough judgment of which era saw the larger part of their peak.

ATD#6:

Result|1890-00|1901-10|1911-20|1921-30|1931-40|1941-50|1951-60|1961-70|1971-80|1981-90|1991-00|01-pres.
Champion|0|0|1|1|0|0|1|6|3|4|6|1
Finalist__|0|0|2|1|2|2|2|2|6|4|2|0
Conf. Fin.|0|0|1|1|2|2|0|4|4|2|7|0
Conf. Fin.|0|1|0|0|0|0|1|0|4|5|9|3

- 1890-00 total: 0 // %: 0
- 1901-10 total: 1 // %: 1.1
- 1911-20 total: 4 // %: 4.3
- 1921-30 total: 3 // %: 3.3
- 1931-40 total: 4 // %: 4.3
- 1941-50 total: 4 // %: 4.3
- 1951-60 total: 4 // %: 4.3
- 1961-70 total: 12 // %: 13.0
- 1971-80 total: 17 // %: 18.5
- 1981-90 total: 15 // %: 16.3
- 1991-00 total: 24 // %: 26.1
- 01-pres. total: 4 // %: 4.3

ATD#7:

Result|1890-00|1901-10|1911-20|1921-30|1931-40|1941-50|1951-60|1961-70|1971-80|1981-90|1991-00|01-pres.
Champion|0|0|3|1|5|2|1|5|4|0|1|1
Finalist__|0|1|2|0|1|0|0|1|4|12|2|0
Conf. Fin.|0|0|1|0|0|0|5|5|6|4|1|1
Conf. Fin.|0|0|0|1|1|2|3|1|6|6|3|0

- 1890-00 total: 0 // %: 0
- 1901-10 total: 1 // %: 1.1
- 1911-20 total: 6 // %: 6.5
- 1921-30 total: 2 // %: 2.2
- 1931-40 total: 7 // %: 7.6
- 1941-50 total: 4 // %: 4.3
- 1951-60 total: 9 // %: 9.8
- 1961-70 total: 12 // %: 13.0
- 1971-80 total: 20 // %: 21.7
- 1981-90 total: 22 // %: 23.9
- 1991-00 total: 7 // %: 7.6
- 01-pres. total: 2 // %: 2.2

ATD#8:

Result|1890-00|1901-10|1911-20|1921-30|1931-40|1941-50|1951-60|1961-70|1971-80|1981-90|1991-00|01-pres.
Champion|0|0|2|1|0|2|1|4|6|6|1|0
Finalist__|0|0|2|2|6|0|1|7|2|2|1|0
Conf. Fin.|0|1|7|0|1|1|2|1|3|2|2|3
Conf. Fin.|0|3|4|3|4|1|0|1|3|2|2|0

- 1890-00 total: 0 // %: 0
- 1901-10 total: 4 // %: 4.3
- 1911-20 total: 15 // %: 16.3
- 1921-30 total: 6 // %: 6.5
- 1931-40 total: 11 // %: 12.0
- 1941-50 total: 4 // %: 4.3
- 1951-60 total: 4 // %: 4.3
- 1961-70 total: 13 // %: 14.1
- 1971-80 total: 14 // %: 15.2
- 1981-90 total: 12 // %: 13.0
- 1991-00 total: 6 // %: 6.5
- 01-pres. total: 3 // %: 3.3

ATD#9:

Result|1890-00|1901-10|1911-20|1921-30|1931-40|1941-50|1951-60|1961-70|1971-80|1981-90|1991-00|01-pres.
Champion|0|0|1|0|1|3|3|13|2|0|0|0
Finalist__|2|2|3|0|0|8|3|2|2|1|0|0
Conf. Fin.|0|0|2|2|0|2|1|4|4|4|1|3
Conf. Fin.|0|1|0|1|2|0|1|3|7|4|2|2

- 1890-00 total: 2 // %: 2.2
- 1901-10 total: 3 // %: 3.3
- 1911-20 total: 6 // %: 6.5
- 1921-30 total: 3 // %: 3.3
- 1931-40 total: 3 // %: 3.3
- 1941-50 total: 13 // %: 14.1
- 1951-60 total: 8 // %: 8.7
- 1961-70 total: 22 // %: 23.9
- 1971-80 total: 15 // %: 16.3
- 1981-90 total: 9 // %: 9.8
- 1991-00 total: 3 // %: 3.3
- 01-pres. total: 5 // %: 5.4

ATD#10:

Result|1890-00|1901-10|1911-20|1921-30|1931-40|1941-50|1951-60|1961-70|1971-80|1981-90|1991-00|01-pres.
Champion|0|2|3|0|2|0|0|5|5|4|1|1
Finalist__|0|0|1|2|0|2|1|1|6|6|3|1
Conf. Fin.|0|0|1|1|0|0|1|3|5|8|4|0
Conf. Fin.|2|2|0|1|0|3|1|5|6|3|0|0

- 1890-00 total: 2 // %: 2.2
- 1901-10 total: 4 // %: 4.3
- 1911-20 total: 5 // %: 5.4
- 1921-30 total: 4 // %: 4.3
- 1931-40 total: 2 // %: 2.2
- 1941-50 total: 5 // %: 5.4
- 1951-60 total: 3 // %: 3.3
- 1961-70 total: 14 // %: 15.2
- 1971-80 total: 22 // %: 23.9
- 1981-90 total: 21 // %: 22.8
- 1991-00 total: 8 // %: 8.7
- 01-pres. total: 2 // %: 2.2

ATD#11:

Result|1890-00|1901-10|1911-20|1921-30|1931-40|1941-50|1951-60|1961-70|1971-80|1981-90|1991-00|01-pres.
Champion|1|1|1|2|3|0|2|6|5|2|1|0
Finalist__|0|0|2|1|0|5|3|0|2|5|3|2
Conf. Fin.|0|2|8|0|0|2|0|2|3|1|3|1
Conf. Fin.|0|2|4|4|2|0|1|2|6|0|1|1

- 1890-00 total: 1 // %: 1.1
- 1901-10 total: 5 // %: 5.4
- 1911-20 total: 15 // %: 16.3
- 1921-30 total: 7 // %: 7.6
- 1931-40 total: 5 // %: 5.4
- 1941-50 total: 7 // %: 7.6
- 1951-60 total: 6 // %: 6.5
- 1961-70 total: 10 // %: 10.9
- 1971-80 total: 16 // %: 17.4
- 1981-90 total: 8 // %: 8.7
- 1991-00 total: 8 // %: 8.7
- 01-pres. total: 4 // %: 4.3

ATD#12:

Result|1890-00|1901-10|1911-20|1921-30|1931-40|1941-50|1951-60|1961-70|1971-80|1981-90|1991-00|01-pres.
Champion|0|1|0|2|5|5|6|3|1|0|0|0
Finalist__|1|0|1|2|1|0|1|6|3|2|5|1
Conf. Fin.|0|1|2|0|1|1|3|1|7|1|3|3
Conf. Fin.|0|0|0|0|3|1|1|1|2|10|5|0

- 1890-00 total: 1 // %: 1.1
- 1901-10 total: 2 // %: 2.2
- 1911-20 total: 3 // %: 3.3
- 1921-30 total: 4 // %: 4.3
- 1931-40 total: 10 // %: 10.9
- 1941-50 total: 7 // %: 7.6
- 1951-60 total: 11 // %: 12.0
- 1961-70 total: 11 // %: 12.0
- 1971-80 total: 13 // %: 14.1
- 1981-90 total: 13 // %: 14.1
- 1991-00 total: 13 // %: 14.1
- 01-pres. total: 4 // %: 4.3

ATD 2010:

Result|1890-00|1901-10|1911-20|1921-30|1931-40|1941-50|1951-60|1961-70|1971-80|1981-90|1991-00|01-pres.
Champion|0|0|0|1|4|1|2|3|6|4|2|0
Finalist__|0|0|1|2|0|3|0|1|4|5|6|1
Conf. Fin.|1|0|0|1|2|2|3|3|5|1|2|3
Conf. Fin.|1|0|0|2|2|0|1|4|7|5|1|0

- 1890-00 total: 2 // %: 2.2
- 1901-10 total: 0 // %: 0
- 1911-20 total: 1 // %: 1.1
- 1921-30 total: 6 // %: 6.5
- 1931-40 total: 8 // %: 8.7
- 1941-50 total: 6 // %: 6.5
- 1951-60 total: 6 // %: 6.5
- 1961-70 total: 11 // %: 12.0
- 1971-80 total: 22 // %: 23.9
- 1981-90 total: 15 // %: 16.3
- 1991-00 total: 11 // %: 12.0
- 01-pres. total: 4 // %: 4.3

ATD 2011:

Result|1890-00|1901-10|1911-20|1921-30|1931-40|1941-50|1951-60|1961-70|1971-80|1981-90|1991-00|01-pres.
Champion|0|0|2|1|1|0|4|4|7|1|4|0
Finalist__|1|0|1|2|1|1|0|4|3|1|6|4
Conf. Fin.|1|2|1|1|2|2|5|3|5|0|2|0
Conf. Fin.|0|1|0|0|3|3|2|4|2|2|2|5

- 1890-00 total: 2 // %: 2.1
- 1901-10 total: 3 // %: 3.1
- 1911-20 total: 4 // %: 4.2
- 1921-30 total: 4 // %: 4.2
- 1931-40 total: 7 // %: 7.3
- 1941-50 total: 6 // %: 6.3
- 1951-60 total: 11 // %: 11.5
- 1961-70 total: 15 // %: 15.6
- 1971-80 total: 17 // %: 17.7
- 1981-90 total: 4 // %: 4.2
- 1991-00 total: 14 // %: 14.6
- 01-pres. total: 9 // %: 9.4

ATD 2012:

Result|1890-00|1901-10|1911-20|1921-30|1931-40|1941-50|1951-60|1961-70|1971-80|1981-90|1991-00|01-pres.
Champion|0|0|2|1|3|2|0|0|4|4|3|5
Finalist__|0|0|1|1|0|1|3|1|3|4|8|2
Conf. Fin.|1|1|0|2|3|0|0|7|3|3|4|0
Conf. Fin.|0|1|3|1|1|0|1|4|3|3|5|2

- 1890-00 total: 1 // %: 1.0
- 1901-10 total: 2 // %: 2.1
- 1911-20 total: 6 // %: 6.3
- 1921-30 total: 5 // %: 5.2
- 1931-40 total: 7 // %: 7.3
- 1941-50 total: 3 // %: 3.1
- 1951-60 total: 4 // %: 4.2
- 1961-70 total: 12 // %: 12.5
- 1971-80 total: 13 // %: 13.5
- 1981-90 total: 14 // %: 14.6
- 1991-00 total: 20 // %: 20.8
- 01-pres. total: 9 // %: 9.4

ATD 2013:

Result|1890-00|1901-10|1911-20|1921-30|1931-40|1941-50|1951-60|1961-70|1971-80|1981-90|1991-00|01-pres.
Champion|0|0|2|2|1|0|3|1|6|2|5|2
Finalist__|0|0|1|3|2|3|2|2|2|5|2|2
Conf. Fin.|1|0|1|3|1|1|2|3|4|4|0|4
Conf. Fin.|0|0|1|0|2|3|5|1|7|2|1|2

- 1890-00 total: 1 // %: 1.0
- 1901-10 total: 0 // %: 0
- 1911-20 total: 5 // %: 5.2
- 1921-30 total: 8 // %: 8.3
- 1931-40 total: 6 // %: 6.3
- 1941-50 total: 7 // %: 7.3
- 1951-60 total: 12 // %: 12.5
- 1961-70 total: 7 // %: 7.3
- 1971-80 total: 19 // %: 19.8
- 1981-90 total: 13 // %: 13.5
- 1991-00 total: 8 // %: 8.3
- 01-pres. total: 10 // %: 10.4

---------------------------------------------------------------------

ATD Conference Championship Totals:

- 1890-00 total: 11 // %: 1.1
- 1901-10 total: 25 // %: 2.4
- 1911-20 total: 70 // %: 6.8
- 1921-30 total: 52 // %: 5.1
- 1931-40 total: 70 // %: 6.8
- 1941-50 total: 66 // %: 6.5
- 1951-60 total: 78 // %: 7.6
- 1961-70 total: 139 // %: 13.6
- 1971-80 total: 188 // %: 18.4
- 1981-90 total: 146 // %: 14.3
- 1991-00 total: 122 // %: 11.9
- 01-pres. total: 56 // %: 5.5

 

[Say Hey Kid]

2013 Champs

The 2013 Champs were Co-GMed by Jafar and Sturminator:

MONTREAL CANADIENS

GMs: Jafar / Sturminator
Captain: Mikhailov
Assistant: Bourque
Assistant: Coulter

HEAD COACH

Tommy Gorman

ROSTER

#9 Busher Jackson - #7 Frank Boucher - #13 Boris Mikhailov
#8 Sergei Kapustin - #27 Jeremy Roenick - #19 Helmut Balderis
#91 Shane Doan - #14 Don Luce - #10 Tony Amonte
#17 Joe Klukay - #33 Troy Murray - #41 Mario Tremblay

#77 Raymond Bourque - #2 Art Coulter
#3 Gus Mortson - #5 Jimmy Thomson
#4 Bobby Rowe - #18 Mathieu Schneider

#1 Georges Vézina
#23 Al Rollins

#39 Jason Spezza, #26 Rick Ley, #12 Steve Thomas, #71 Patrik Sundstrom

PP1: Jackson - Boucher - Mikhailov
Schneider - Bourque

PP2: Kapustin - Roenick - Balderis
Thomson - Mortson

PK1: Klukay - Luce
Bourque - Coulter

PK2: Murray - Boucher
Mortson - Thomson

PK3: Roenick - Mikhailov
Rowe​

 

[TheDevilMadeMe]

To open up more room for future stickied threads, the MLD Championship Retrospective thread has been unstickied and a link has been added to the top of the first post in this thread. Since nobody but me had posted in the MLD retrospective thread since 2011, I figured that was the way to go.

Edit: If you have any suggestions on how to manage the sticky threads, you can always PM me

 

[VanIslander]

We should expect a TDMM update shortly. He's our first two-time winner, isn't he?

(Ten years of this and I haven't even won a division in any ATD though players I pick keep getting promoted and I've co-won the MLD twice.)

Such is life.

 

[TheDevilMadeMe]

ATD 2014 champions, New Jersey Swamp Devils (*note: 28-team draft):

GM: The DevilMadeMe

Coach: Tommy Ivan

Toe Blake (A) - Bill Cowley - Bill Cook (C)
Gordon Roberts - Peter Forsberg - Gordon Drillon
Tony Leswick - Patrice Bergeron - Frank Finnigan
Sergei Kapustin - Vladimir Shadrin - Todd Bertuzzi
Ray Getliffe, Ryan Kesler, Alexei Kovalev

Babe Siebert - Red Kelly (A)
Herb Gardiner - Harry Cameron
Ryan Suter - Kevin Hatcher
Ed Van Impe

Grant Fuhr
Chuck Rayner
​

______________________________________________

Grant Fuhr, Tommy Ivan, and Babe Siebert join the exclusive group of 3-time ATD champions. Ivan and Siebert were both part of the previous Swamp Devils winner.

Bill Cook, Sergei Kapustin, Ray Getliffe, and Chuck Rayner are now 2-time champs. Getliffe's other championship was on the previous Swamp Devils winner.

Three time champs:

Coach:

Tommy Ivan

Forward:

Johnny Bucyk
Bobby Rousseau
Busher Jackson

Defense:

Babe Siebert

Goal:

Grant Fuhr

Two time champs:

Coach:

Al Arbour
Cecil Hart

Forward:

Adam Oates
Dean Prentice
Hooley Smith
Gordie Howe
Doug Risebrough
Newsy Lalonde
Don Marcotte
Vladimir Martinec
Troy Murray
Pierre Turgeon
Don Marshall
Roy Conacher
Phil Goyette
Alex Delvecchio
Ed Litzenberger
Don McKenney
Ron Ellis
Jack Adams
Dirk Graham
Harry Hyland
Ed Sandford
Reggie Fleming
Harry Watson
Murray Oliver
Denis Savard
Bill Cook
Sergei Kapustin
Ray Getliffe

Defense:

Bill Hajt
Ted Harris
Lloyd Cook
Cy Wentworth
Jim Neilson
Jimmy Thomson
Hap Day

Goal:

Charlie Hodge
Dave Kerr
Roger Crozier
Chuck Rayner

 

[TheDevilMadeMe]

Can a defense-first team still win in the ATD?

At this point, it's been 6 drafts since the last defense-first team won (EB's team in ATD12). Every championship team has had the ability to defend when necessarily, but some have clearly favored offense over defense (ATD2010, 2012, 2014 champions) and the others have been well-balanced (2011, 2013).

My theory is that defensive players are overvalued compared to offensive players in the ATD. It's not that defense-first teams can't win, it's that the best value in the ATD is usually on offensively-oriented players, and good value picks are what win. For just one example, look how much earlier Bobby Clarke and Bryan Trottier get drafted than Phil Esposito every draft. (Or heck, look at all the defensemen drafted before Mario Lemieux this past year)

 

[BenchBrawl]

We should expect a TDMM update shortly. He's our first two-time winner, isn't he?
.

Hockey Outsider has also won two ATDs and Sturminator has won three.

 

[BenchBrawl]

TDMM - You should also update the first post with your team , this is a nice place to quickly look at the evolution of champions.

Thanks in advance.

 

[TheDevilMadeMe]

Hockey Outsider has also won two ATDs and Sturminator has won three.

Meh, Sturminator won two ATDs, then joined the best team in the draft right as the playoffs started to bandwagon to a third. Lucky guy (Kidding mostly, he did a great job of running your team in the playoffs last year).

TDMM - You should also update the first post with your team , this is a nice place to quickly look at the evolution of champions.

Thanks in advance.

Updated it.

 

[BenchBrawl]

Meh, Sturminator won two ATDs, then joined the best team in the draft right as the playoffs started to bandwagon to a third. Lucky guy (Kidding mostly, he did a great job of running your team in the playoffs last year).

Hehe , this is not entirely correct , he did draft a lot of players in the later rounds , plus I could never dream of being half the debater Sturminator is , which counts for a lot in winning tight series.He also played with the line-up.

It's also noteworthy to say that Sturminator teached me a lot of things since I started being a GM in 2011 , so his mentoring has been a huge part of my quick rise as an ATD GM.In this context it was only natural that he would be the one to take over my team.Speaking of which , I haven't heard from him in months so I hope he's okay.

 

[Sturminator]

Your 2015 ATD champions, Pittsburgh Athletic Club:

Coach: Anatoli Tarasov
Assistant Coach: Billy Reay

Paul Kariya-Gordie Howe
Ebbie Goodfellow-Ted Kennedy(C)
Dit Clapper(A)

Darryl Sittler (A)-Dany Heatley
Glen Harmon-Dave Taylor
Herb Gardiner

Veniamin Alexandrov-Vladimir Vikulov
Pit Lepine-Lennart Svedberg
Rod Seiling

Kelly Miller-Ryan Kesler-Ron Stewart

Johnny Bower
Roberto Luongo

Spares: Mike Green, Johnny Gagnon, Paul Shmyr​

-------------------------------------------------------

- Gordie Howe joins the three-time winners club.

- Vladimir Vikulov, Paul Kariya, Pit Lepine, Ryan Kesler, Herb Gardiner, Rod Seiling and Johnny Bower join the two-time winners club.

 

[Sturminator]

Your 2016 ATD champions, Pittsburgh Athletic Club:

Coach: Lester Patrick

Vladimir Krutov-Frank Boucher-Brett Hull
Frank Foyston (C)-Marty Barry-Andy Bathgate
Jiri Holik-Ivan Hlinka (A)-Bob Nevin
Don Marshall-Dale Hunter-Terry O'Reilly
Kent Nilsson, Brenden Morrow, Jack Adams

Ebbie Goodfellow (A)-Doug Harvey
Georges Boucher-Bob Goldham
Rod Seiling-Nikolai Sologubov
Viktor Kuzkin

Grant Fuhr
Rogie Vachon​

--------------------------------------------------------------------------

- Grant Fuhr is the first member of the four-time winners' club

- Don Marshall, Jack Adams and Rod Seiling join the three-time winners' club

- Frank Boucher, Frank Foyston, Bob Nevin, Terry O'Reilly, Ebbie Goodfellow, Doug Harvey, Georges Boucher and Rogie Vachon join the two-time winners' club.

- given the importance of coaching in the ATD, this is surprisingly Lester Patrick's first title.

- Ebbie Goodfellow and Rod Seiling join Grant Fuhr and Don McKenney as the only players to win back-to-back titles for the same franchise.

 

[Hawkey Town 18]

Looks like RS is only the second GM to win back-to-back titles joining Sturm

 

[BenchBrawl]

ATD2017 Champions: Montreal Canadiens - (25 teams draft)

GM: BenchBrawl

MONTREAL CANADIENS



GM: BenchBrawl

Captain: Derian Hatcher
Assistant: Bryan Trottier
Assistant: Shea Weber
Assistant: Doug Harvey

HEAD COACH

Al Arbour

ROSTER

Patrik Elias - Bryan Trottier (A) - Bernard Geoffrion
Paul Thompson - Mike Modano - Glenn Anderson
Jamie Benn - Frank Fredrickson - Tony Amonte
Dave Andreychuk - Gregg Sheppard - Jerry Toppazzini

Doug Harvey (A) - Shea Weber (A)
Derian Hatcher (C) - Georges Boucher
Jimmy Watson - Ted Green

Frank Brimsek
Carey Price

Spares: Joe Pavelski, Marian Gaborik, Brian Campbell, Bill Thoms

PP1: Andreychuk - Trottier - Fredrickson - Harvey - Geoffrion
PP2: Thompson - Modano - Elias - Weber - Boucher

PK1: Modano - Toppazzini - Hatcher - Harvey
PK2: Trottier - Sheppard - Boucher - Weber


Forward Minutes

Player | ES | PP | PK | Total
Trottier | 14 | 4 | 3 | 21
Modano| 13 | 3 | 4 | 20
Geoffrion | 14 | 5* | 0 | 19
Fredrickson | 13 | 4 | 0 | 17
Elias | 14 | 3 | 0 | 17
Thompson| 13 | 3 | 0 | 16
Anderson| 13 | 0 | 0 | 13
Benn | 13 | 0 | 0 | 13
Amonte | 13 | 0 | 0 | 13
Toppazzini | 6 | 0 | 4 | 10
Andreychuk | 6 | 4 | 0 | 10
Sheppard | 6 | 0 | 3 | 9
TOTAL | 138 | 26* | 14 | 178*

Defensemen Minutes

Player | ES | PP | PK | Total
Harvey | 20 | 5 | 5 | 30
Weber | 17 | 2 | 2 | 21
Boucher | 17 | 2 | 2 | 21
Hatcher | 15 | 0 | 5 | 20
Green | 15 | 0 | 0 | 15
Watson | 8 | 0 | 0 | 8
TOTAL | 92 | 9* | 14 | 115*

*Geoffrion plays the point on the PP
​

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Al Arbour, Doug Harvey and Georges Boucher join the exclusive group of 3-times ATD Champions.Harvey and Boucher won back-to-back titles in 2016 and 2017.This also makes Doug Harvey the only elite player to win three times alongside Gordie Howe.

Paul Thompson, Tony Amonte, Jerry Toppazzini, Ted Green and Jimmy Watson join the group of 2-times ATD Champions.

Derian Hatcher becomes the first american captain to win it, just like in real life.

Four time champs:

Goal:

Grant Fuhr

Three time champs:

Coach:

Tommy Ivan
Al Arbour

Forward:

Gordie Howe
Johnny Bucyk
Bobby Rousseau
Busher Jackson
Don Marshall
Jack Adams

Defense:

Doug Harvey
Georges Boucher
Babe Siebert
Rod Seiling

Two time champs:

Coach:

Cecil Hart

Forward:

Adam Oates
Dean Prentice
Hooley Smith
Doug Risebrough
Newsy Lalonde
Don Marcotte
Vladimir Martinec
Troy Murray
Pierre Turgeon
Roy Conacher
Phil Goyette
Alex Delvecchio
Ed Litzenberger
Don McKenney
Ron Ellis
Dirk Graham
Harry Hyland
Ed Sandford
Reggie Fleming
Harry Watson
Murray Oliver
Denis Savard
Bill Cook
Sergei Kapustin
Ray Getliffe
Vladimir Vikulov
Pit Lepine
Paul Kariya
Ryan Kesler
Frank Boucher
Frank Foyston
Bob Nevin
Terry O'Reilly
Paul Thompson
Tony Amonte
Jerry Toppazzini

Defense:

Bill Hajt
Ted Harris
Lloyd Cook
Cy Wentworth
Jim Neilson
Jimmy Thomson
Hap Day
Herb Gardiner
Ebbie Goodfellow
Ted Green
Jimmy Watson

Goal:

Charlie Hodge
Dave Kerr
Roger Crozier
Chuck Rayner
Johnny Bower
Rogie Vachon

 

[BenchBrawl]

The Montreal Canadiens solidify their lead as the most successful franchise in ATD history with 4 titles under two different managements (Hockey Outsider and BenchBrawl/Sturminator).

Milt Dunnell Cups:

Montreal Canadiens (4)
New Jersey Swamp Devils (2)
Pittsburgh Athletic Club (2)
Regina Pats (1)
Inglewood Jacks (1)
San Francisco Spiders (1)
Nanaimo Clippers (1)
Buffalo Bisons (1)
Boston Bruins (1)
Detroit Falcons (1)

 

[Iceman]

Dynasty?

 

[BenchBrawl]

Dynasty?

I doubt a dynasty could ever happen in the ATD.It would take one insane GM to draft 4 winners in a row all the while avoiding voters fatigue.It would be kindda cool if someone did it though.

 

[ResilientBeast]

I doubt a dynasty could ever happen in the ATD.It would take one insane GM to draft 4 winners in a row all the while avoiding voters fatigue.It would be kindda cool if someone did it though.

If Rob Scuderi comes back next year and wins I'd say 3 in 4 is a "dynasty"

 

[tinyzombies]

Well done BenchBrawl - you did the name proud.

 

[BenchBrawl]

Well done BenchBrawl - you did the name proud.

Thanks. I hope you enjoyed the experience enough to come back next year.

 

[BenchBrawl]

If Rob Scuderi comes back next year and wins I'd say 3 in 4 is a "dynasty"

Borderline. Three is not enough unless it's consecutive.

 

[ResilientBeast]

Borderline.Three is not enough unless it's consecutive.

2 consecutive and 3 in 4 is a dynasty to me

 

[TheDevilMadeMe]

2018 Champions

​

NY Americans
GM: rmartin65

Note: 24 Team Draft

Coaches: Anatoli Tarasov, Billy Reay
Captain: Boris Mikhailov
Alternate Captains: Sid Abel, Anze Kopitar, Brad Park

Paul Kariya-Stan Mikita-Boris Mikhailov
Sid Abel-Steven Stamkos-Rod Gilbert
Gordon Roberts-Anze Kopitar-Ace Bailey
Dave Balon-Don Luce-Blair Russel

Spare Forwards: Lynn Patrick, LW, Terry O'Reilly, RW

Borje Salming-Brad Park
Babe Siebert-Bob Goldham
Vasili Davydov-Joe Hall

Spare Defense: Lars-Erik Sjoberg

Bernie Parent
Sergei Bobrovsky

PP1
Stamkos-Mikita-Mikhailov
Kariya-Park

PP2
Roberts-Abel-Gilbert
Salming-Hall

PK1
Luce-Bailey
Salming-Goldham

PK2
Kopitar-Dave Balon
Siebert-Park
​

2019 Champions

Chicago Shamrocks
GM: Hawkey Town 18

Note: 20 Team no-trade Draft

Chicago Shamrocks​

Coach: Fred Shero

Patrick Elias - Milt Schmidt (A) - Guy Lafleur
Sweeney Schriner - Joe Malone - Cecil Dillon
Brad Marchand - Neil Colville - Claude Provost
Zach Parise - Edgar Laprade - Ryan Kesler
Spares: Pat Lafontaine, Bob Davidson

Scott Stevens (C) - Red Kelly
Herb Gardiner - Georges Boucher (A)
Jim Neilson - P.K. Subban
Spares: Red Dutton, Rod Seiling

Vladislav Tretiak
Rogie Vachon


Special Teams
PP1: Schriner - Malone - Lafleur - Subban - Kelly
PP2: Elias - Schmidt - Parise - Gardiner - Boucher

PK1: Kesler - Dillon - Stevens - Neilson
PK2: Laprade - Provost/Colville - Gardiner - Boucher
Extra F: Schmidt, Marchand
Extra D: Kelly​

ATD 2020 Champions

New Jersey Swamp Devils
GM: TheDevilMadeMe

Note: 40 Team no-trade Draft (most GMs had 2 Teams)

NJ Swamp Devils

Coach: Ken Hitchcock
Assistant/PP Coach: Bob Johnson

Vladimir Krutov - Sid Abel (C) - Guy Lafleur
Boris Mayorov (A) - Vyacheslav Starshinov - Bobby Bauer
Tony Leswick - Cooney Weiland - Mush March
Ab McDonald - Mike Ricci - Tim Kerr

Allan Stanley - Earl Seibert (A)
Vladimir Lutchenko - Flash Hollett
Vasili Pervukhin - Doug Young

George Hainsworth
Ben Bishop

PP1:
Tim Kerr
- Vladimir Krutov - Sid Abel - Guy Lafleur
Flash Hollett

PP2:
Boris Mayorov - Vyacheslav Starshinov - Bobby Bauer
Allan Stanley - Earl Seibert

PK1: Cooney Weiland - Tony Leswick - Allan Stanley - Earl Seibert
PK2: Viachelsav Starshinov - Mush Marsh - Vladimir Lutchenko - Doug Young
PK3: Vladimir Krutov - Sid Abel

Spares: Jack Evans (D), Steve Sullivan (F)​

 

[BenchBrawl]

Someone should update the OP with the 2020 team while respecting the original format. There are also some formatting error in it, like rmartin65's name is misspelled (as well as TheDevilMadeMe's name in ATD2014 has a superfluous space) and the font is not the same in ATD2019.

I'd do it, but I can't.