Proposal: Anaheim-BOS/NJD/TOR

[Gliff]

Silfverberg


DeBrusk
_______


Rakell (@ 1.9 mil)
Manson (@ 2 mil)


Lilegren
Robertson
Hyman (Cap)
2021 1st
_______


Henrique (@ 2.9 mil)


2021 3rd

Edit: Had NJD's 3rd listed as NYI's 3rd by mistake.

Click to read more...

 

[YP44]

Way too much from Toronto IMO

 

[LucicAndChong]

please...PLEASE tell me that leafs one is a joke.

god that is so f***ing bad.

 

[MMC]

Yikes man, I have absolutely no interest in retaining that much on any of those players. And if we were to, I'd want much better returns than those, or it's just not worth it.

 

[CHRDANHUTCH]

unless all of the other 4 teams trade their players in this proposal to BOS, no deal JDB was just extended this past offseason

 

[T_Cage]

Pass from TO. Giving up too much with Robertson AND a 1st AND Lilj, and Hyman isn’t a cap dump

 

[Setec Astronomy]

Devils have NYI’s 2021 second rounder, not third. Also don’t know why they’d trade anything for a guy who was just put on waivers.

 

[Toronto makebeleifs]

Pretty easy pass from the leafs. Debrusk for silf might have some merit, doubt the ducks retain that much for that long on henrique for just a 3rd. 1 outta 3

 

[BigBadBruins7708]

Pass.

I'm down on DeBrusk, but I'm not trading him for a 30yr old version of himself

 

[Gliff]

Devils have NYI’s 2021 second rounder, not third. Also don’t know why they’d trade anything for a guy who was just put on waivers.

My bad! I thought it was the 3rd.
And the 2.9 mil difference in his cap would be the reason.

 

[Leonardo87]

Would prefer to keep Rakell and try to add Debrusk. Not sure if Silfverberg alone is enough to woo Boston.

 

[Gliff]

Pass from TO. Giving up too much with Robertson AND a 1st AND Lilj, and Hyman isn’t a cap dump

I'm curious what you think a return that makes sense for Anaheim is. Getting a top 6 winger and top 4 defensemen for 4 mil total is pretty valuable.
I was between Hyman and Kerfoot but I would honestly want more if the Ducks take on 13 mil in salary to make the numbers work.

 

[SHANNYPLAN]

Hyman > Rakell (to the leafs at least)

Not reading Robertson, Liljigren & 1st for Manson, even with retention

 

[YP44]

Devils have NYI’s 2021 second rounder, not third. Also don’t know why they’d trade anything for a guy who was just put on waivers.

because of the retention

 

[Gliff]

Hyman > Rakell (to the leafs at least)

Not reading Robertson, Liljigren & 1st for Manson, even with retention

I would love to hear the rational on this.

 

[McDonald19]

Devils have NYI’s 2021 second rounder, not third. Also don’t know why they’d trade anything for a guy who was just put on waivers.

Because he would have been claimed at the cap hit in the trade proposal?

 

[BeLeafing]

No chance on that Leafs deal, it's extremely far off. Hyman has more value to the Leafs than Rakell, then we add 2 of our 4 best prospects and a 1st for a defenseman who would play 3rd pairing.

I don't understand why people are still trying to trade Manson to Toronto. Holl has looked like a solid top 4 guy and Bogosian has played very well in his #6 role. The need isn't there at all. Leafs will add a top 6 winger before the deadline and that's it.

 

[cwede]

all unbalanced in Ducks favor

unles the NJD deal has notable salary retention, so they can flip him if/when

always liked Silferberg but not worth DeBrusk by himself at this point

to me the TML deal is understandable to propose from a "competitor goes for it' perspective,
but thats 3 high-upside young assets (not Hyman);
w flat Cap, ELC talent is critical to managng roster

 

[BlueBaron]

Doubtful we spend that much at the deadline. I suspect our 1rst is on the table but none of our top 4 prospects are. Almost 0 chance we trade Hyman. Kerfoot is more likely but then we need a C as well....

We are tough to trade with right now. Has to be just the right deal. Tight Cap and an expansion year could make this a lean deadline and maybe some deflation, I'm hoping anyway.

 

[SpeakingOfTheDevils]

We don’t really have the space or need for Henrique. You could probably get NYR to dance, though, especially with that retention.

 

[CatchyTune]

No offense but that leafs proposal is absolutely horrendous.

the worst part is the (cap) next to Hymans name.

 

[LucicAndChong]

The leafs don’t need another defenceman. Any top 4 d the leafs acquire pushes one of our current top 4 out and they all deserve to be in the top 4.

 

[nbwingsfan]

Yikes man, I have absolutely no interest in retaining that much on any of those players. And if we were to, I'd want much better returns than those, or it's just not worth it.

How much do you think they're worth exactly..?

 

[CatchyTune]

The leafs don’t need another defenceman. Any top 4 d the leafs acquire pushes one of our current top 4 out and they all deserve to be in the top 4.

i agree but you can never have too much defensive depth. imagine Manson or Holl being on the bottom pair.

 

[Hitemwith4]

delete