Player Discussion: All time Tampa Bay Lightning team

[The Macho King]

Theres a real lack of one Matthew Carle in here

Mods please Ban him.

 

[BoltSTH]

Theres a real lack of one Matthew Carle in here

I call your Carle and raise you Sustr

 

[Volodya Krutov]

There's a lack of Tyler Johnson over here IMO. Sure he declined sharply, but the things he achieved in the playoffs between 2014 and 2016 were amazing.

 

[CupsOverCash]

Palat Point Kucherov
Modin Richards St. Louis
Gagne Lecavalier Stamkos
Maroon Paquette Andreychuck
Bradley Johnson Gratton

Hedman Boyle
McDonagh Stralman
Sergachev Hamrlik
Sydor Kubina

 

[Outl4w]

Send Gagne to the minors and bring up Taylor and Fedetenko. Bye Stralman . Call up Sarich

 

[Point21]

where does Steve Downie and Zenon Konopka fit into this? even David Koci or Nick Tarnasky would suffice

 

[2020 Cup Champions]

I call your Carle and raise you Sustr

anders lindback

 

[LightningStrikes]

anders lindback

Dan Ellis and Mike Smith forming the infamous “Smellis” duo was a treat too.

 

[Venzio X]

Corpse of Nabokov

 

[Nautica54]

I'd have Killorn, Johnson and Palat over Tucker and Callahan. I assume Zamunov is Rob Zamuner? Don't know enough about him to have a clue but I'd have Modin there.

Also I'm not sure Vasi has done enough yet to overtake Bishop. It can't be emphasized enough how big of a part he was in turning this team around. He had way worse teams in front of him than Vasi.

Um im as big of a Bish fan there is....but yes Vasi has overtaken him

Wow edit...didnt see the dates lol

 

[The Macho King]

Corpse of Nabokov

He was so bad for us.

 

[Hoek]

Please, if we're talking bad Lightning goaltenders there are many worse than those. Dieter Kochan probably takes the prize. A guy called up directly from the UHL couldn't hack it in the NHL? Who would've thunk it? Certainly not Rick Dudley.

 

[BoltSTH]

anders lindback

Ramo and Denis were worse: Tampa Bay Lightning Goalies | Hockey-Reference.com

 

[Point21]

Please, if we're talking bad Lightning goaltenders there are many worse than those. Dieter Kochan probably takes the prize. A guy called up directly from the UHL couldn't hack it in the NHL? Who would've thunk it? Certainly not Rick Dudley.

Gerald Coleman, Riku Helenius, Sebastien Caron, Wade Flaherty, Kevin Hodson, Wendell Young, even Mark Fitzpatrick. Would Dan Cloutier and his 12-43-6 record be one of the worst? or Bill Ranford and his 3-18-3 record beat that

 

[Stammertime91]

Someone said Denis. Ah yes, the ole Denis for Modin trade. That shaved off a few years of my life.

 

[HoseEmDown]

Gerald Coleman, Riku Helenius, Sebastien Caron, Wade Flaherty, Kevin Hodson, Wendell Young, even Mark Fitzpatrick. Would Dan Cloutier and his 12-43-6 record be one of the worst? or Bill Ranford and his 3-18-3 record beat that

0.00 GAA and a 1.000 save %, one of these goalies is not like the others.

 

[Point21]

0.00 GAA and a 1.000 save %, one of these goalies is not like the others.

i mean 2 saves is 2 saves, but for a 15th overall pick? i think Gudlevskis would have done better if given more time

 

[Flat Ronnie]

Any dream lineup the team can put out there must have Stamkos/St. Louis pairing at the top. That was the deadliest, most dominant duo we ever had. That duo produced 2x Rockets (including a 60 goal scorer).

 

[HoseEmDown]

Any dream lineup the team can put out there must have Stamkos/St. Louis pairing at the top. That was the deadliest, most dominant duo we ever had. That duo produced 2x Rockets (including a 60 goal scorer).

Let me know when Stamkos hits 100 points. He's a distant #2 behind Vinny for centers.

 

[Hoek]

Let me know when Vinny hits 60 goals.

 

[HoseEmDown]

Let me know when Vinny hits 60 goals.

52 goals 56 assists 108 points > 60 goals 37 assists 97 points. Stamkos is a one trick pony.

 

[DrMartinVanNostrand]

Where's Sustr ? Gotta be an oversight.

Let me assure you that nobody could ever "overlook" Andrej Sustr.

 

[WhoozYerrDaddy]

How about the legendary bust Jason Bonsignore ??

 

[Flat Ronnie]

52 goals 56 assists 108 points > 60 goals 37 assists 97 points. Stamkos is a one trick pony.

He had 59 assists in '17-'18 and 53 in '18-'19.

 

[BoltSTH]

How about the legendary bust Jason Bonsignore ??

Here's 2 more:
3rdOA Alexandr Svitov NHL Bolts: 74 games 4G 3A = 7 pts NHL Totals: 179 games 13G 34A= 47 pts

first round pick Andy Rogers who never played in the NHL