All-Time Best Hurricanes Goalie #2

[garnetpalmetto]

Cam won fairly heavily in the last round so we move on to the second-best Canes goalie of all time. Irbe's the early favorite given his showing in the first round - will Archie carry the day in this round or will another goalie come out on top? Remember, we are only interested in how goalies performed as a Hurricane, so Kirk McLean's run in Vancouver, Tom Barrasso's time in Pittsburgh, etc., are irrelevant to this.

Goalie | Season | GP | Min | W | L | T | OTL | GA | SO | GAA | SA | Sv% | G | A | PIM
Tom Barrasso|2001-02|34|1908|13|12|5|N/A|83|2|2.61|886|.906|0|0|4
Brian Boucher|2011-12|10|546|1|6|N/A|1|31|0|3.41|260|.881|0|0|0
Sean Burke|1997-98|25|1415|7|11|5|N/A|66|1|2.80|655|.899|0|1|6
Patrick Desrochers|2002-03|2|122|1|1|0|N/A|7|0|3.44|71|.901|0|0|0
Dan Ellis|2012-13|19|997|6|8|N/A|2|52|1|3.13|555|.906|0|2|0
Eric Fichaud|1999-2000|9|490|3|5|1|N/A|24|1|2.94|206|.883|0|0|2
Mark Fitzpatrick|1999-2000|3|107|0|2|0|N/A|8|0|4.49|68|.882|0|0|0
Mike Fountain|1997-98|3|163|0|3|0|N/A|10|0|3.68|68|.853|0|0|2
Martin Gerber|2005-06|60|3493|38|14|N/A|6|162|3|2.78|1719|.906|0|2|4
John Grahame|2006-08|45|2363|15|20|N/A|3|125|0|3.17|1126|.889|0|4|6
Arturs Irbe|1998-2004|309|17816|130|122|44|N/A|739|20|2.49|7884|.906|0|4|46
Pat Jablonski|1997-98|5|279|1|4|0|N/A|14|0|3.01|115|.878|0|0|0
Anton Khudobin|2013-15|70|4004|27|31|N/A|7|167|2|2.50|1950|.914|0|0|0
Trevor Kidd|1997-99|72|4043|28|31|9|N/A|158|5|2.34|1877|.916|0|0|2
Eddie Lack|2015-present|12|629|3|6|N/A|2|35|0|3.34|282|.876|0|2|0
Manny Legace|2009-10|28|1596|10|8|N/A|6|77|1|2.89|800|.904|0|1|0
Michael Leighton|2007-10|29|1537|8|12|N/A|2|82|0|3.20|739|.889|0|0|4
Kirk McLean|1997-98|8|401|4|2|0|N/A|22|0|3.29|181|.878|0|1|0
Tyler Moss|2000-01|12|557|1|6|0|N/A|37|0|3.99|251|.853|0|0|0
Mike Murphy|2011-12|2|36|0|1|N/A|0|0|0|0.00|9|1.000|0|0|0
Justin Peters|2009-14|68|3702|22|31|N/A|8|188|3|3.05|1949|.904|0|2|8
Jamie Storr|2003-04|14|660|0|8|2|N/A|32|0|2.91|262|.878|0|0|0
Kevin Weekes|2001-04|119|6850|39|54|20|N/A|275|11|2.41|3131|.912|0|0|8

Click to read more...

 

[Navin R Slavin]

Second place == first loser.

No voting for losers.

 

[David Tanabe]

Is it too early to cast my vote for Alex Nedeljkovic?

 

[Carolinas Identity*]

Second place == first loser.

No voting for losers.

but i thought the biggest loser was the winner

no i am all confused

 

[VAcaniac]

Are people serious when they vote for Eddie Lack?

I think it's time to start the #3 thread already. This was over before it started.

Not sure what spot I would put Gerber at.

 

[garnetpalmetto]

Is it too early to cast my vote for Alex Nedeljkovic?

Who? You must mean that Needaspellcheck guy And yes, it's too early. The rule I went by is if they played goal for the Canes in a regular season NHL game, they made it to the list.

Second place == first loser.

No voting for losers.

But there are still goalies with winning records up on the board, Hank! And besides, this is the Carolina Hurricanes we're talking about. First loser is still a badge of honor.

At any rate, I'm a bit surprised to see votes for Lack already. On the back of his performance last night, I could see it, but the overall corpus, not so much, especially not ahead of guys like Irbe, Gerber, and maybe even Weekes. I'd be interested to hear anybody's rationale as to why they voted for Lack - not attacking at all, but legitimately interested in their thoughts.

 

[Joe McGrath]

Who? You must mean that Needaspellcheck guy And yes, it's too early. The rule I went by is if they played goal for the Canes in a regular season NHL game, they made it to the list.



But there are still goalies with winning records up on the board, Hank! And besides, this is the Carolina Hurricanes we're talking about. First loser is still a badge of honor.

At any rate, I'm a bit surprised to see votes for Lack already. On the back of his performance last night, I could see it, but the overall corpus, not so much, especially not ahead of guys like Irbe, Gerber, and maybe even Weekes. I'd be interested to hear anybody's rationale as to why they voted for Lack - not attacking at all, but legitimately interested in their thoughts.

I imagine the same reason someone voted for Storr.

 

[VAcaniac]

I wish I had been a Canes fan in 2000 so I could have seen Tyler Moss. His stats look fantastic.

 

[nobuddy]

Jamie Storr only played 14 games as a Hurricane? I feel like it was more.

 

[VAcaniac]

Jamie Storr only played 14 games as a Hurricane? I feel like it was more.

He's lucky he got that many starts the way his debut went.