All Rookie Team Face Off: 2006-07 vs 2016-17

[blundluntman]

Which of these all rookie teams do you think would win?

Judge the lineups based off of their Rookie season production ONLY.


2006-07 Team

G	Mike Smith	Dallas Stars						23	12	5	2	2.23
D	Matt Carle	San Jose Sharks	77	11	31	42	30
D	Marc-Edouard Vlasic	San Jose Sharks	81	3	23	26	18
F	Evgeni Malkin	Pittsburgh Penguins	78	33	52	85	80
F	Jordan Staal	Pittsburgh Penguins	81	29	13	42	24
F	Paul Stastny	Colorado Avalanche	82	28	50	78	42

[TBODY] [/TBODY]

2016-17

G	Matt Murray	Pittsburgh Penguins						49	32	10	4	2.41
D	Brady Skjei	New York Rangers	80	5	34	39	42
D	Zach Werenski	Columbus Blue Jackets	78	11	36	47	14
F	Patrik Laine	Winnipeg Jets	73	36	28	64	26
F	Mitchell Marner	Toronto Maple Leafs	77	19	42	61	38
F	Auston Matthews	Toronto Maple Leafs	82	40	29	69	14

[TBODY] [/TBODY]

Click to read more...

 

[Sidney the Kidney]

Matt Carle had 42 points as a rookie? That surprises me.